1. The verdict
Photo-first appraisal of 35 Facebook Marketplace listings returned by a round-table search within 10 km of Ipswich QLD. 21 of the 35 are NOT round tables — the keyword harvest also caught rectangular and oval tables, a printed round rug, chairs, a radio, a vase, a ceramic elephant and woven mats — and are grouped and labelled separately below, exactly as their appraisers flagged them. Read the scope note.
21 of 35 items are out of scope — not round tables (see each card’s scope note).
5 bargain · 13 fair · 8 overpriced · 9 insufficient evidence
This report appraises all 35 listings the keyword search returned within the 10 km Ipswich radius. 14 are genuinely round (or round-configurable) tables. 21 are not round tables — the keyword harvest also matched rectangular and oval tables, a round printed floor rug, a bentwood chair, a Bakelite radio, a ceramic vase, a ceramic elephant, woven table mats and table parts. Those items carry out_of_scope=true with the appraiser's own one-line reason, are grouped after the in-scope items, and their verdicts should be read as ‘do not buy for this purpose’, not as table valuations.
2. Key numbers
A$20–A$12,345
asking range
2b. How these numbers were tested
10 appraisals were put through an adversarial review
— a second model paid to attack the 5 ‘bargain’ calls and the 5 highest values — and
5 listings went to a blind re-appraisal that never saw the first appraiser’s numbers.
2 bargain calls did not survive and are downgraded on their cards
(the original verdicts are still shown next to the correction); the rest were upheld or could not be
falsified from the pixels. The blind re-check disagreed with the first appraisal on several items and
its verdicts and ranges are printed inside a bordered panel on each affected card.
Downgraded after review:
Blind re-appraisal results:
Full per-item detail is on the cards, in the
‘Second opinions’ panel. Treat a downgraded bargain as ordinary-market, not a steal.
3. The items
Each card: the listing photos, the asking price against my estimated value range, the visual evidence behind the identification, and the comparables used.
Round dining table
Bargainconfidence: medium
⇄
My fair market value
A$120–A$260 (pt A$180)
Identification
- Form
- round pedestal dining/table, 4-splay webbed foot base on turned column
- Period
- c.1960s-70s Australian casual dining
- Timber
- honey-toned hardwood — silky oak or Queensland maple appearance; possibly solid or veneer over core
- Marks
- none visible; underside not shown
- Construction features visible
- thick bullnose edge top
- turned column with square blocking to 4 splayed webbed feet
- gloss polyurethane finish
- no visible plank seams (top reads as one disc)
Why — the visual evidence
The pixels show a solid-looking honey hardwood round with a fat bullnose edge on a turned pedestal and four splayed webbed feet in gloss poly — a 1960s-70s Australian table room staple, not Victorian as a 'vintage' label might imply. Honest wear (light scratches) but sound and recently finished. As a used item it is clearly worth more than the A$100 asked.
Evidence notes
Anchors: an antique Australian cedar round (120 cm) realised A$200 at Leonard Joel — a better table than this one — and a Victorian mahogany breakfast table made A$120; a silky oak side table bottomed out at A$25. A 1055 mm solid-look pedestal dining in good used order therefore sits ~120-260 in AU trade. Point 180 vs ask 100 → bargain. Cannot see underside, thread insert, or confirm solid vs veneered core.
1960s-70s, not antique — 'vintage' at bestsolid vs veneered core unverifiablesilky-oak/softwood marks show easily
Comparables used
| Photo | Comparable | Price | AUD |
|---|
 | Victorian Australian cedar dining table, 75H x 120 DIA — antique cedar round 120cm realised only A$200 — the trade ceiling for anonymous rounds | 200 ≈A$200 | A$200 |
 | Victorian mahogany breakfast/centre table (a/f), 73H x 117 dia — Victorian mahogany breakfast A$120 | 120 ≈A$120 | A$120 |
 | Silky oak side table with carved legs, 72 x 40 x 42 cm, Albion Antique Auction Centre — QLD silky oak clears at rock bottom ($25) — timber alone is not value | 10 ≈A$25 | A$25 |
 | Antique turned silky oak pedestal table, Queensland, early 20th C [hammer price behind Carter's subscription wall; image is the sold-lot photo] — silky oak turned pedestal, sold at Carter's (price behind subscription) — same market | — | — |
Second opinions — adversarial review & blind re-check
These are later, independent tests of the appraisal above. Where they disagree, the disagreement is shown side by side — the original verdict text is kept intact so you can see exactly what changed.
Adversarial review
Original verdictBargain · point A$180
Reviewer verdictupheld by adversarial review
Corrected rangeA$120–A$260
Pixel test'possibly solid or veneer over core' — pixels show thick solid-looking bullnose edge, no visible banding; appraiser hedged correctly, no overclaim found. Turned pedestal and webbed feet as described; no hidden damage visible in 3 photos.
WhyPixels confirm the form: solid timber (or at least thick solid-appearing) round top with heavy rounded bullnose, turned pedestal column with deep decorative grooves, four splayed webbed/strap feet, gloss poly — consistent with the appraiser's 'c.1960s-70s Australian casual dining, silky oak/maple look'. Counter-anchors found independently support the band from both sides: Leski realised A$200 for an Australian Arts & Crafts silky oak pedestal (est 300-500) and A$550 for a Harry Goldman blackwood round dining setting — so honey-hardwood pedestal forms do clear low-hundreds at AU auction, and the appraiser's 120-260 is not fantasy. The one soft spot is species: 'silky oak or maple appearance' is admitted and unverifiable from pixels; but the bargain call rests on realised Leonard Joel cedar/mahogany rounds (A$120-200) which it beats anyway at a A$100 ask. Upheld.
New evidence- Leski Auctions cat 586: Australian Arts & Crafts silky oak pedestal, REALISED A$200 (est 300-500) — silky-oak pedestal forms clear low hundreds (A$200) Leski Auctions (realised) ↗
- Leski cat 586: Harry Goldman 7-pc blackwood round dining setting c.1920s, REALISED A$550 (est 600-1000) — upper anchor for honey-hardwood round settings (A$550) Leski Auctions (realised) ↗
Verdict: Bargain. Hermes appraiser subagent (photo-first), 2026-09-21
Solid Wood Extendable Table
Bargainconfidence: medium
⇄
My fair market value
A$80–A$200 (pt A$130)
Identification
- Form
- expandable (drop-leaf/segment) dining table, round-to-oval config, currently oval
- Period
- c.1970s, likely Italian or AU 'convertible' type
- Timber
- walnut-toned veneer/MDF top over metal segmental expansion frame; black-painted tube legs
- Marks
- none visible
- Construction features visible
- two-fold top with centre seam and metal segment rails underneath
- black tubular steel legs with screw collars
- banded edges — veneer/laminate, not solid timber
- stained dark brown finish
Why — the visual evidence
Contradicts the seller's title 'Solid Wood': the edge banding, dead-flat surfaces and the visible segmented metal expanding mechanism read as a 1970s veneer-on-board convertible table, not solid wood. Shape when closed is round-ish/oval (photos show it half-extended). Scuffs and a tired finish are visible on the top. It is, however, a genuinely useful size (to ~180+ cm extended) and A$30 is nothing — bought and cleaned it is worth several multiples of the ask.
Evidence notes
Anonymity plus laminate = low auction numbers (LJ anonymous retro clears $120-220; anonymous round table PASSED at $400-600). At A$30 the ask is below any plausible value, hence 'bargain' — but the bargain is modest in dollars, not thousands. Underside mechanism condition (do all segments fold?) could not be verified.
not 'solid wood' — veneered board toptired finish, scuffsmechanism working order unverified from photos
Comparables used
| Photo | Comparable | Price | AUD |
|---|
 | 1970s teak low side table by Parker, 43cm H x 76 dia — anonymous retro furniture clears ~A$120 at Leonard Joel | 120 ≈A$120 | A$120 |
 | Victorian mahogany breakfast/centre table (a/f), 73H x 117 dia — anonymous Victorian round: A$120 — sets the trade floor | 120 ≈A$120 | A$120 |
 | Parker teak round extendable dining, 1970s, refinished — retail ceiling: a *refinished* Parker round extendable asks $1,290 — branded | 1290 ≈A$1,290 | A$1,290 |
 | 1960s Australian glass-topped hardwood circular table, 53H x 145 dia (passed, est 400-600) — anonymous round table did not sell at $400-600 | 400 ≈— | — |
Second opinions — adversarial review & blind re-check
These are later, independent tests of the appraisal above. Where they disagree, the disagreement is shown side by side — the original verdict text is kept intact so you can see exactly what changed.
Adversarial review
Original verdictBargain · point A$130
Reviewer verdictupheld by adversarial review
Corrected rangeA$80–A$200
Pixel testveneer/MDF+metal-tube claim CONFIRMED by pixels (laminated edge, black metal rod legs, segmental folding frame); appraiser's material read is correct — and correct in a way that KEEPS the value low, so bargain is robust to it.
WhyPixels fully support the unglamorous ID: thin laminated/veneer top over a board, black metal rod/tube legs folding under, visible segmental expansion mechanism and the seven stowed leaves — a 1970s '7-in-1' convertible, not solid timber furniture. The bargain call survives because it is priced off realised anchors (Leonard Joel A$120 for a 1970s Parker teak table), not asking prices: at A$30 even the trade floor of ~A$80-120 is a clean flip. The Retro Bay A$1,290 figure is used by the appraiser only as a labelled retail ceiling, not as value. I could not find a realised AU auction result for a generic walnut-veneer/metal 7-in-1 specifically; the band 80-200 sits on branded-retro realiseds, which are if anything more generous than this unbranded piece deserves — but not enough to break the bargain verdict at a A$30 ask.
Blind re-appraisal (independent appraiser, original numbers hidden)
Second appraiserBargain · A$30–A$100 (point A$60) · confidence low
IdentificationOval (not round) extendable dining table, centre split leaf exposed in photo 3, running on metal rails. Dark brown stain over a figured/veneer-look top (surface reads glossy, scratched, water-marked — consistent with thin veneer over a carcase, 'solid wood' claim NOT confirmed by the pixels). Four dark-stained turned legs ending in screw-in black metal feet/castors. Form and hardware read as a mid-to-late 20th-century domestic extension table (1950s-80s Australian/English 'country club' type), possibly grained/stained softwood; NOT an antique, NOT cedar-identifiable.
ReasoningEven honest oak gatelegs/drop-leafs clear only A$260-320 at AU regional houses (evidence rows 7, 6); a stained-veneer repro extension table is a tier below that 'junk-to-vanity' band, and the playbook flags stained pine pretending to be better timber as the common Ipswich marketplace trap. Ask A$30 is at or below my floor, so even as a repaint project it clears the bargain test.
Evidence notesPhoto 3 shows several tables in one garage frame (incl. a light round table with cross-stretcher); I have assumed the subject is the dark oval with the exposed leaf, matching the 'Extendable' title. Underside not shown; leaf count/rails condition not verifiable; cannot confirm solid vs veneer from photos alone; no maker mark visible; no metal-tube legs (legs are timber, feet metal).
Verdict: Bargain. Hermes appraiser subagent (photo-first), 2026-09-21
Vintage Circular Coffee Table Stool Set 3
Bargainconfidence: medium
⇄
My fair market value
A$80–A$180 (pt A$120)
⚠ Adversarial review downgraded this verdict — see the second-opinions panel below the appraisal.
Identification
- Form
- Circular 'coffee-table-stool' set: four wedge pouf-stools nesting around a central drum table with a copper-lined well — a 1970s Australian modular conversation set, not an antique table
- Period
- c.1970s (retro, not antique)
- Timber
- Reddish sapele/mahogany-look veneer or laminate drum base with splayed battens; copper/brass-toned inner well; vinyl/PVC cushions with beige-brown floral damask print
- Marks
- No label or maker's mark visible
- Construction features visible
- Circular drum carcass, knife-edge veneered panels, four wedge cushions with stitched pip edges, copper bowl in centre (originally perhaps for plants/ice); no turned legs — the seller's 'wooden bases' is the drum
Why — the visual evidence
Photos agree with the seller's text — this IS the floral faux-leather wedge-stool set around a central drum, and it does look clean (no rips visible). But it is 1970s retro plastic-laminate/vinyl, not antique. AU realised anchor for 1970s round retro tables: Leonard Joel sold a 1970s Parker teak low table at A$120 and a teak coffee table at A$220, while an unmarked 1960s glass-top hardwood circular PASSED at est 400-600 — unmarked retro clears ~A$120-220. The vinyl upholstery caps it below designer teak: A$80-180 trade. The $50 ask is under that band, so bargain.
Evidence notes
Driven by pixels: wedge-segmented circular upholstered top, copper centre well, reddish veneered drum with splayed battens, pink shag-era carpet. Could NOT determine: exact diameter (~90-100cm est), whether cushions lift off, underside/labels, water damage inside the copper well (some staining visible in photo 1).
Retro, not antique — vinyl perishes and this style only sells to nostalgia buyersCopper well shows interior stainingSeller's 'perfect condition' partly holds: no rips seen, but cushion foam compression cannot be judged from photosBargain only because the ask is token-level
Comparables used
| Photo | Comparable | Price | AUD |
|---|
 | 1970s teak low side table by Parker, 43H x 76 dia — REALISED A$120 | 120 ≈A$120 | A$120 |
no img | Retro teak coffee table, 50cm H — REALISED A$220 | 220 ≈A$220 | A$220 |
 | 1960s Australian glass-topped hardwood circular table — PASSED (est 400-600): unmarked retro does not chase estimates | 400 ≈A$500 | A$500 |
Second opinions — adversarial review & blind re-check
These are later, independent tests of the appraisal above. Where they disagree, the disagreement is shown side by side — the original verdict text is kept intact so you can see exactly what changed.
Adversarial review
Original verdictBargain · point A$130
Reviewer verdictDOWNGRADED — value overstated
Corrected rangeA$50–A$120
Pixel testForm, wedge segmentation, copper centre with staining, reddish drum: ALL confirmed by pixels. No tears visible at photo resolution, but copper-well staining is real. Appraiser's ID stands; it is the VALUE of the form that doesn't.
WhyThe pixels corroborate the identification (four wedge vinyl poufs, copper-lined centre well with visible interior staining, drum base) — but that identification is exactly what defeats the bargain call. The value band (80-180) leans on realised anchors for branded teak retro (Parker A$120) and a 'retro teak coffee table A$220'; this set is unbranded, vinyl-upholstered (not teak), 1970s conversation-circle forms are a saturated and fading category on AU secondhand platforms, the copper well is stained and the vinyl is a dated floral PVC. I could not find a single realised AU price for this specific form; at A$50 ask with no label, the assumed resale is optimism, not evidence. Downgrade to 'not demonstrably a bargain'; corrected 50-120 (essentially at-or-below ask, money-good only if you want it).
New evidence- No realised auction evidence located for vinyl/copper 1970s conversational stool-circle sets in AU; nearest realised anchors the appraiser used are BRANDED teak (Parker A$120) — brand transfer to an unbranded vinyl set is unproven Search across Leonard Joel/Leski/auction archives (negative result)
Verdict: Bargain. appraiser-child part3 (photo-first, indices 18-26)
Victorian Colonial Circa 1860's Red Cedar Dropside Table Pick up Ipswich $675
Fairconfidence: medium
⇄
My fair market value
A$400–A$750 (pt A$550)
Identification
- Form
- photos show a round/oval CENTRE table on a central pedestal with carved splay legs ending in claw-type feet, plus — at the right edge in photos 1 and 3 — a small drop-leaf table standing on end; which of the two is the item is ambiguous, the title says the drop-leaf ('dropside')
- Period
- late Victorian / Edwardian colonial, c.1890-1910 more likely than the claimed c.1860 (cedar claw-pedestal rounds of this kind are usually 1890s-1900s; 'c.1860' is seller optimism)
- Timber
- Australian red cedar plausible: warm rose-honey colour with flame/figured grain visible on the top in photos 2-3; under-apron tone matches the top (not an obvious stained-pine fake)
- Marks
- none readable
- Construction features visible
- turned pedestal column, carved cabriole/club feet with claw, rounded top edges; drop-leaf at right has thin flaps with hinges; finish has an even soft sheen suggesting a cleaned/refinished surface rather than heavy old shellac
Why — the visual evidence
Photo-first: the pixels agree with 'cedar' better than they agree with '1860'. The figure and rose colour support Australian cedar; the pedestal-claw form and clean turns are more consistent with 1890s-1900s colonial work than 1860s. AU realised prices for colonial cedar tables are brutally trade-level: Leonard Joel sold an anonymous Victorian cedar round dining at $200; Leski sold an H.T. Jones & Son Parramatta cedar piece at $320; dealer asking for a restored cedar round is $550 (Marlborough). A good cedar drop-leaf/round in presentable refinished condition therefore sits ~$400-750, so $675 is a fair-ish market ask for what is arguably the nicer of the two tables shown — not a bargain, and the photo ambiguity is a real risk.
Evidence notes
Drove: rose-toned figured grain under even light (cedar), pedestal-and-claw base, refinished sheen, the small drop-leaf seen standing at right. Could NOT determine: which table is actually for sale, leaf mechanism and hinges up close, underside, worm, exact diameter, whether the '1860' claim or a stamp exists.
'circa 1860' likely overstated by ~30-50 yearsphotos show TWO tables — unclear which is for salesurface looks cleaned/refinished, not original patinano marks/stamp visible to support the dateleaf hinges and underside not shown
Comparables used
| Photo | Comparable | Price | AUD |
|---|
 | Australian cedar tilt-top round dining, c.1840, 132cm dia (top-end dealer sale — ceiling case, not comparable quality) | 4495 ≈A$4,495 | A$4,495 |
 | Early Australian cedar round dining, 120cm dia, restored | 550 ≈A$550 | A$550 |
no img | Henry T. Jones and Son Parramatta, Australian cedar table | 320 ≈A$320 | A$320 |
 | Victorian Australian cedar dining table, 75H x 120 DIA | 200 ≈A$200 | A$200 |
 | Rustic Australian cedar centre/side/wine table, tripod, carved legs, c.1880 | 750 ≈A$750 | A$750 |
Second opinions — adversarial review & blind re-check
These are later, independent tests of the appraisal above. Where they disagree, the disagreement is shown side by side — the original verdict text is kept intact so you can see exactly what changed.
Adversarial review
Original verdictFair · point A$550
Reviewer verdictupheld by adversarial review
Corrected rangeA$400–A$750
Pixel test'circa 1860s' NOT supported by pixels (form reads 1890s-1900s; appraiser flagged). Second table in photo CONFIRMED — item identity ambiguity real (appraiser flagged). Refinished gloss CONFIRMED. Appraiser's own caveats cover every failure mode I could find.
WhyTwo pixel probes: (1) yes, a second smaller table stands on end at the right edge of the photos — the appraiser's ambiguity flag is real and material (if the item for sale is the drop-leaf at the edge, not the big oval, every anchor shifts); (2) the finish is a bright cleaned/refinished gloss, not original patina, and the date claim '1860s' is not supported — the pedestal-claw form is 1890s-1900s, which the appraiser itself corrected. Both adversarial findings were ALREADY in the appraisal, which is why 'fair' at 400-750 holds: AU realised cedar anchors (LJ A$200 anonymous round, Leski/Parramatta A$320, restored early cedar round A$550) bracket the band, and a refinished piece sits below dealer asks not above. Nothing here lets the piece clear its A$675 ask at auction; 'fair' rather than 'bargain' is the correct call and it survives.
New evidence- Leski cat 586 realised-results page pattern for colonial cedar/hardwood dining forms (A$200-550 realised band) corroborates 400-750 as ceiling-leaning (A$550) Leski Auctions (realised) ↗
Verdict: Fair. Hermes dealer-appraiser child (photo-first), session 2026-09-21
Antique dining room table 3
Fairconfidence: medium
⇄
My fair market value
A$150–A$300 (pt A$220)
Identification
- Form
- Oval (round-ended) extending DINING table — not a small round table: four cabriole legs, moulded oval top with the ends lifted to store the two loose leaves and the crank barrel (photo 3 shows the dark underside of the stacked leaves and the chromed crank handle lying on the top)
- Period
- c.1920s-1940s 'antique' dining — Queen Anne-revival cabriole legs with pad feet indicate 20th-C reproduction of Georgian form, consistent with a crank-extension table; not early/Georgian as 'antique' might imply
- Timber
- Light honey-brown timber under a polished varnish — reads as satin walnut or polished oak/fruitwood rather than cedar or mahogany; even figured grain on top, apron shows light scratches and a worn patch at the moulding
- Marks
- No label or maker's mark visible in the three photos
- Construction features visible
- Crank-and-screw centre extension (the crank barrel and handle are present and original, seller claims +30cm per insert on a 166x114 base); top is a jointed/segmented oval with moulded edge; legs screwed to corner blocks (typical machine-made 20th-C)
Why — the visual evidence
Photo-first check against the text: the seller's 'two inserts + crank mechanism, 166x114' is CORROBORATED — the crank handle, barrel and stacked leaves are visible. The pixels also correct the word 'antique': cabriole legs + pad feet + machine-fitted crank = a good honest interwar/1940s reproduction-Georgian, which is exactly the playbook's 'Edwardian/20s copies of Georgian forms push down' case. Anchors: LJ realised A$200 for a genuine Victorian cedar round dining and A$360 for a pub table; extending crank tables with both leaves present and working do better than plain tables because the mechanism adds utility — A$150-300 AU trade, point ~220. Ask $200 is inside that band: fair, possibly worth $250 in person if the mechanism runs sweet.
Evidence notes
Driven by: photo 2 (apron scratches, pad feet, polished light timber), photo 3 (crank handle + barrel + two loose leaves stored on end — proves full leaf count and working hardware; leaf undersides dark/unfinished as expected). Could NOT determine: exact species (satin walnut vs polished oak vs stained pine — colour suggests walnut), underside labels, whether the crank screw is bent or stiff, full open length, and water rings on the stored leaf faces.
20th-C reproduction Georgian form, not a true antique despite the titleApron scuffs and worn moulding; likely needs clean/polishLeaf faces stored dark-side — cannot check rings/stainsOval dining size: bulk to move, limits buyer poolSpecies unconfirmed from photos
Comparables used
| Photo | Comparable | Price | AUD |
|---|
 | Victorian Australian cedar dining table (round) — REALISED A$200: direct size-class comparable, plain top, no mechanism | 200 ≈A$200 | A$200 |
no img | Victorian pub table (round) — REALISED A$360: what a heavy period round clears at LJ (ceiling for this piece) | 360 ≈A$360 | A$360 |
no img | Anonymous turned colonial round table a/f — REALISED A$100 (floor) | 100 ≈A$100 | A$100 |
 | Colonial cedar round dining (Victorian) — REALISED A$200 | 200 ≈A$200 | A$200 |
Verdict: Fair. appraiser-child part3 (photo-first, indices 18-26)
4 chair round table
Fairconfidence: medium
⇄
My fair market value
A$150–A$260 (pt A$200)
Identification
- Form
- round table + 4 moulded shell chairs (5-piece set)
- Period
- table c.1990s-2000s; chairs Eames-DSW-style reproductions
- Timber
- light honey hardwood top (maple/beech look) with visible board joints; black-painted base
- Marks
- none visible
- Construction features visible
- segmented/strip-plank round top (joints visible across surface)
- 4 splayed black-painted legs (bolt-on)
- chairs: black polypropylene shells on black metal legs
- pen/ink marks on top (seller-admitted)
Why — the visual evidence
Pixels: the top is made of visible joined boards of light honey timber under a satin finish, on a bolt-on black 4-leg base — a modern (1990s-2000s) flat-pack-style round, not vintage. The four chairs are black moulded plastic shell replicas, cheap new equivalents are ~$60-90 each. Seller's 'comes apart' matches the bolt-on legs; the pen marks are visible. Nothing here is antique; this is contemporary used furniture sold as a set.
Evidence notes
No auction evidence applies to modern flat-pack; value is Marketplace-equivalent used: table 60-120 + 4 repro shell chairs ~25-40 each = 160-280; point 200 ≈ ask 200 → fair. Citations below are used to show the trade floor for anonymous retro/design-adjacent items, with the caveat that this is newer than any comp. Chairs' crack/wobble state not provable in photos.
modern, not vintagevisible pen marks on topreproduction chairsbolt-on joints: check for play/wobble
Comparables used
| Photo | Comparable | Price | AUD |
|---|
 | Charles & Ray Eames for Herman Miller circular table, 71H x 140 dia — the real Eames round made A$480 — these are repro shells, not the design | 480 ≈A$480 | A$480 |
 | 1970s teak low side table by Parker, 43cm H x 76 dia — anonymity floor: retro pieces clear ~$120 | 120 ≈A$120 | A$120 |
 | 1960s Australian glass-topped hardwood circular table, 53H x 145 dia (passed, est 400-600) — anonymous casual round PASSED at $400-600 — sets expectations for generic rounds | 400 ≈— | — |
 | Parker teak round extendable dining, 1970s, refinished — refinished branded retro round asks $1,290 — brand does the work | 1290 ≈A$1,290 | A$1,290 |
Verdict: Fair. Hermes appraiser subagent (photo-first), 2026-09-21
Vintage round cane and timber table and chairs
Fairconfidence: low
⇄
My fair market value
A$120–A$200 (pt A$160)
Identification
- Form
- round cane-top bistro table + 4 mismatched cane chairs (5-piece set)
- Period
- c.1980s-2000s casual; chairs a mix, refinished
- Timber
- painted/whitewashed softwood (pine) + woven cane webbing; some chrome/black steel hardware
- Marks
- none visible in the photos
- Construction features visible
- woven cane webbing top in timber ring frame
- turned/painted pedestal-style legs
- shabby-chic chalk/whitewash repaint
- chairs: 2 painted pine spindle-back caned seats, at least 1 different profile (set is not matching)
Why — the visual evidence
Pixels first: the round top is cane webbing, not timber — a woven panel in a painted ring frame with a black-painted centre pole. All frames are whitewash/shabby-chic painted with no legible original finish anywhere; the four chairs are visibly mismatched (back profiles and paint tones differ). Nothing in the photos (443 px wide) shows turned period detailing, mouldings, or feet. The seller's 'vintage' is the loose Marketplace sense; this is a 1980s-2000s casual cane set, recently redecorated.
Evidence notes
Photos are small (443×960) — cane tears and joint looseness cannot be verified, so confidence is low. Underside, actual seat heights and whether the black pole is original hardware are undeterminable.
cane top, not timber — 'timber table' is seller optimismshabby-chic repaint kills original surfacechairs do not match as a setsmall photos: cane condition unverifiable
Comparables used
| Photo | Comparable | Price | AUD |
|---|
 | 1960s Australian glass-topped hardwood circular table, 53H x 145 dia (passed, est 400-600) — demand reality: anonymous casual round table PASSED at a 400-600 estimate | 400 ≈— | — |
 | 1970s teak low side table by Parker, 43cm H x 76 dia — anonymous retro furniture clears ~$120 at LJ | 120 ≈A$120 | A$120 |
 | Charles & Ray Eames for Herman Miller circular table, 71H x 140 dia — contrast: designer label holds $480 — anonymity is the discount | 480 ≈A$480 | A$480 |
 | Rustic Australian cedar centre/side/wine table, tripod, carved legs, c.1880 — dealer asking ceiling $750 for casual rustic — asking, not paid | 750 ≈A$750 | A$750 |
Second opinions — adversarial review & blind re-check
These are later, independent tests of the appraisal above. Where they disagree, the disagreement is shown side by side — the original verdict text is kept intact so you can see exactly what changed.
Blind re-appraisal (independent appraiser, original numbers hidden)
Second appraiserOverpriced · A$50–A$140 (point A$90) · confidence medium
IdentificationRound low-to-standard bistro-size table whose top is WOVEN white-painted wicker/rattan (spiral weave), not a timber top with cane panel; the legs are wrapped/woven wicker, solid timber rim only at the edge — no metal tube. Two matching chairs: timber slat seats/ladder backs painted white with blue cushions, painted frames chipped. Set reads as mass-market 1970s-90s patio/café rattan, painted; not an antique. Title's 'cane and timber' overstates it.
ReasoningThe auction evidence file contains NO realised Australian result for wicker/rattan café furniture, so I must say the class has no comparable and anchor on judgment: painted bistro sets in chipped condition are commodity op-shop goods; four-figure designer-rattan retail asks do not apply. A$190 for a chipped-paint 3-piece painted wicker set sits well above what the class returns at AU trade level.
Evidence notesNo wicker/rattan/cane rows exist in auction-evidence.md — comparable set is empty for this material class; pricing is judgment, not anchored. Cannot see underside, weave breaks close-up, or any label; chairs' joint quality unclear; size estimated from photo perspective.
Verdict: Fair. Hermes appraiser subagent (photo-first), 2026-09-21
Dining room round table
Fairconfidence: medium
⇄
My fair market value
A$60–A$150 (pt A$100)
Identification
- Form
- round glass-top table on whitewashed bamboo/rattan X-frame base (verandah/dining)
- Period
- c.1980s-2000s casual
- Timber
- whitewashed bamboo/rattan frame; clear glass top
- Marks
- none visible
- Construction features visible
- round glass top on woven-cane shelf
- lashed/bound bamboo X-cross legs
- painted/limed finish
Why — the visual evidence
The seller's 'dining room round table ~1.2 m' tests against pixels showing a bamboo-and-glass verandah table: limed bamboo X-frame with a cane lower shelf under a round glass top, photographed outside on a patio. Charming, but it is casual rattan furniture, not a timber dining table — and it is not what this report's timber-round buyers want.
Evidence notes
Closest realized evidence: a 1960s glass-topped hardwood round PASSED at $400-600 at Leonard Joel (better than this), and anonymous retro pieces clear ~$120. Bamboo-and-glass is light, dated and two-tone white is a matter of taste: 60-150, point 100; ask 150 sits at the top of value → fair but no room. Photo 3 (180×225 px) adds nothing; glass condition at edges and whether the frame is sound could not be checked.
not a timber dining table — bamboo/rattan + glassphoto 3 unreadable (180 px)limed finish is polarising
Comparables used
| Photo | Comparable | Price | AUD |
|---|
 | 1960s Australian glass-topped hardwood circular table, 53H x 145 dia (passed, est 400-600) — glass-topped round PASSED even at 400-600 estimate — direct category evidence | 400 ≈— | — |
 | 1970s teak low side table by Parker, 43cm H x 76 dia — anonymous retro clears ~$120 | 120 ≈A$120 | A$120 |
 | Australian Art Deco circular occasional table, silky oak, QLD c.1930, 50cm H x 55cm dia [hammer price behind Carter's subscription wall; image is the sold-lot photo] — Art Deco circular sold at Carter's (price behind subscription) — even better examples move modestly | — | — |
Verdict: Fair. Hermes appraiser subagent (photo-first), 2026-09-21
Authentic Vintage Italian Inlaid Wood Multi-Game Table (Complete Set)
Overpricedconfidence: medium
⇄
My fair market value
A$600–A$1,100 (pt A$800)
Identification
- Form
- circular ebonised game/card table, hinged top over game interior, on turned and splayed legs
- Period
- mid-20th century Italian (c.1950s-70s), NOT 19th-century Sorrento
- Timber
- ebonised (black lacquered) fruitwood/walnut carcass; bone/ivory-tone and warm-wood inlay bands
- Marks
- none readable in photos
- Construction features visible
- hinged/flip top revealing game surfaces
- machine-cut repetitive inlay bands, too uniform for hand-laid Sorrento marquetry
- high-gloss lacquer
- turned, splayed legs
- gilt-painted stringing
Why — the visual evidence
Against the seller's 'Authentic Vintage Italian from Sorrento': the pixels show a black lacquered game table with machine-cut, highly repetitive inlay bands — the motifs repeat at identical spacing with no lippage or hand-adjusted seams. Genuine Sorrento work is hand-laid marquetry with varied tones and visible piece seams, and is usually pale inlaid ground, not ebonised with gold decal-like banding. The hinged multi-game interior (chess/tables) is a 20th-century leisure-table format. So: attractive vintage Italian, not antique — and the ask prices it like one.
Evidence notes
Valuation logic: an inlaid/marquetry game table of this class sells on thin AU demand; the closest realised comp is a Continental marquetry card table at £75 (~A$150) in the UK. Even a genuine 19th-c rosewood-veneered round pedestal cleared ~A$1,350 in Italy. Retail asking ceilings (Chairish $2,900 for a genuine 1870 rosewood loo) are not what anyone paid. Discounted for freight/duty and AU taste: 600-1100. Could not open the interior fully in photos; felt condition and completeness of game fittings unverified.
'Sorrento' attribution not supported by pixels — machine-cut inlay, lacquered blackrepro/revival, not antiqueAU demand for decorative Italian game tables is thininterior game fittings not fully visible
Comparables used
| Photo | Comparable | Price | AUD |
|---|
 | Continental marquetry card table, 73cm wide — inlaid card table realises A$150 in UK trade — international, discount further for AU | 75 ≈A$150 | A$150 |
 | Round rosewood-veneered pedestal table, 19th C, 128cm dia (Il Ponte, Italy) — a genuine 19th-c rosewood veneer round only made ~A$1,350 in Italy | 800 ≈A$1,350 | A$1,350 |
 | Victorian rosewood round loo/breakfast table, 1870, 135cm dia (Camden Antiques via Chairish) — asking ceiling $2,900 for a REAL 1870 inlaid loo — this is not that | 1896 ≈A$2,900 | A$2,900 |
 | Rustic French Provincial tilt-top wine tasting table, 19th C, 40in dia, sold $425 +BP — US game/tilt-top conversion $645 — international, freight/duty discount needed | 425 ≈A$645 | A$645 |
 | 19th-c mahogany tilt-top tea table, tripod — genuine 19th-c mahogany tilt-top estimate ~A$460-770 — a better table asks less | 300 ≈— | — |
Second opinions — adversarial review & blind re-check
These are later, independent tests of the appraisal above. Where they disagree, the disagreement is shown side by side — the original verdict text is kept intact so you can see exactly what changed.
Adversarial review
Original verdictOverpriced · point A$800
Reviewer verdictupheld by adversarial review
Corrected rangeA$600–A$1,100
Pixel test'machine-cut shallow stringing, not hand marquetry' CONFIRMED (uniform channels, no age crazing); black ground + bone-tone inlay CONFIRMED; appraiser's 'mid-20th c, not 19th-c Sorrento' is the correct read and the new realised comp confirms the money is low-hundreds-to-~800 AUD regardless.
WhyAdversarial test: can the 600-1100 band be pushed DOWN (if the piece is a modern repro) or UP (if it is a real period compendium)? Both probes land inside the appraiser's band. Pixels: shallow, machine-regular stringing in black lacquer ground with cream/yellow inlay — mid-20th-century notturno-sorrento work, not 19th-c hand marquetry, exactly as appraiser says; interior shows chequer/chess surfaces with some losses. Found the closest realised comp in the world: Burstow & Hewett sold 'An Italian Notturno Sorrento marquetry games compendium table with chess, backgammon, card and roulette' — same form, same category — hammer £420 (Feb 2024) ≈ A$789 at 1.879. That is almost exactly the appraiser's A$800 point. The 'overpriced' verdict vs the A$2,800 ask is unbreakable; the ask looks like it was anchored on the Chairish A$2,900 asking price, which the appraiser correctly identified as ceiling-of-optimism, not value.
Verdict: Overpriced. Hermes appraiser subagent (photo-first), 2026-09-21
Vintage Table and 8x chairs
Overpricedconfidence: medium
⇄
My fair market value
A$300–A$600 (pt A$450)
Identification
- Form
- round single-pedestal dining table on four splayed legs + 8 matching slip-seat chairs
- Period
- 1970s-1990s reproduction of Georgian/Chippendale style
- Timber
- mahogany-veneer over hardwood/veneer core; even orange-brown stained finish, no figured mahogany or cedar glow visible
- Marks
- none visible
- Construction features visible
- turner-style baluster column, radially splayed legs, machine-matched chair frames, carved crest rails repeated identically, drop-in fabric seats
Why — the visual evidence
Photos show a matched 8-chair round pedestal set with the tell-tales of factory reproduction: identical pressed/repeated carving on all chair crests, uniform satin finish top to bottom (no age-shading in the leg shadows), and thin applied mouldings. Seller says only 'vintage', which the pixels agree with in the loose sense, but this is a 20th-c reproduction dining suite, not antique. AU auction evidence for ordinary dining suites is low 3-digits (Parker 9-pc setting est $150-600); reproduction mahogany-look suites clear $200-600 at regional AU houses. Retail asks for 1980s Baker/Ethan Allen repro pedestal tables sit at $1,000-3,600 but are asking-only ceilings. Ask $1,000 is roughly double realistic trade value for the whole set.
Evidence notes
Drove the number: repeated identical chair carving, uniform poly-era satin finish, veneer-edge look on the top, no original patina anywhere. Could NOT determine: solid vs veneer top from photos, whether all 8 chairs are a true matched set, underside, any maker label.
factory reproduction, not antiqueuniform refinished/poly-era finish destroys patina valuefabric seats likely need replacement8-chair sets move slowly in AU trade$1,000 ask is 2x realistic resale
Second opinions — adversarial review & blind re-check
These are later, independent tests of the appraisal above. Where they disagree, the disagreement is shown side by side — the original verdict text is kept intact so you can see exactly what changed.
Adversarial review
Original verdictOverpriced · point A$450
Reviewer verdictupheld by adversarial review
Corrected rangeA$300–A$600
Pixel test'identical pressed/repeated carving, uniform finish, no patina' CONFIRMED by pixels — repro suite, not antique, exactly as claimed.
WhyPixels confirm factory reproduction: identical repeated crest carving on all eight chairs (press-carved, not hand), uniform satin finish with no age-shading in leg shadows, thin applied mouldings, 1970s-90s Georgian-style suite in mahogany-veneer. Critically, the appraiser handled the asking-price trap correctly: the Chairish Baker A$3,645 and Ethan Allen A$1,122 are explicitly labelled 'asking, not sold' and used only to discount, never as value. The realised anchor that matters — LJ nine-piece Parker dining setting est 400-600 — plus LJ small-chair groups selling A$120-480 put a 9-piece unbranded repro suite squarely in the 300-600 range against a A$1,000 ask. Overpriced verdict is solid; tried to break it from both directions and could not.
New evidence- Leonard Joel Thursday results: set of four Louis XVI-style chairs sold A$480 — matched suite components clear in low hundreds, corroborating sub-A$600 for an unbranded repro 9-piece (A$480) Leonard Joel (realised) ↗
Verdict: Overpriced. appraiser-child part4 (photo-first, indices 27-34)
French style Upcycled tilt table
Overpricedconfidence: medium
⇄
My fair market value
A$200–A$450 (pt A$320)
Identification
- Form
- small round tilt-top wine/tea table: circular top on a turned column with wooden gimbal/box tilt, tripod-to-platform base with splayed feet; 'French style' is styling language, form is the familiar country wine-table type
- Period
- old substrate plausible early-mid 20th c; the PAINT is the news — 'upcycled' means painted/distressed, which the photos confirm
- Timber
- obscured by paint; pale wood showing at rub-through points could be pine or fruitwood — cannot identify
- Marks
- none
- Construction features visible
- painted cream/grey finish with deliberate distressing, turned column, wooden tilt gimbal visible, tripod legs with flat feet; no visible modern metal brackets in the tilt
Why — the visual evidence
Photo-first: the gimbal and turnings look traditional, so there may be a genuine old country tilt-top under the paint — but paint and distressing destroy exactly what the auction market pays for (original surface, figured timber). Realised comparables for honest UNPAINTED tilt-tops are already modest: Vickhoad sold a Georgian pad-foot tilt-top at A$380, and a US rustic French Provincial tilt-top wine table made only US$425+BP (A$645, freight/duty not included). A painted 'upcycled' version of that same form in the AU market clears $200-450; $895 is roughly double, pricing décor styling on top of a low-five-figure category at auction.
Evidence notes
Drove: full paint coverage + distressing (a value-reducing refinish, not original shellac), small top diameter (~70cm against the room), visible wooden gimbal (supports genuine tilt, not a fake). Could NOT determine: timber species, true age of substrate, underside/joinery, wobble in the gimbal, whether 'adjustable height' is real or marketing.
fully painted + distressed: original surface destroyed (playbook: paint is a major deduction)timber unidentifiable, so no figure premium possible$895 ask is ~2x realised market for unpainted originals of this size'adjustable height' unverifiable in photosphone-screenshot images
Verdict: Overpriced. Hermes dealer-appraiser child (photo-first), session 2026-09-21
Antique Wicker Accent Table 3
Overpricedconfidence: medium
⇄
My fair market value
A$40–A$90 (pt A$65)
Identification
- Form
- Round 'tomato-cage' accent table: black-painted metal hoop-and-wire cage frame (spiral ring construction, not natural wicker), topped with a black rim holding a dark slate/stone inset disc, ~50cm dia; a second stacked white-painted version appears behind it in photo 1
- Period
- 1970s Australian retro (the tomato-cage table is an iconic 70s form; seller text 'Material Wicker, Country of Origin Australia' is partly wrong — the visible frame is painted WIRE/metal, and there is no wicker weave)
- Timber
- n/a — painted metal + stone top; the seller's 'wicker' claim is contradicted by the pixels
- Marks
- None visible
- Construction features visible
- Concentric wire rings welded to a central column, painted black; top ring carries a painted timber/MDF rim with inset dark stone slab; cast-iron-ish weight, feet are bent wire ring
Why — the visual evidence
The photos decide this one. Form: a round 70s tomato-cage plant/occasional table, correct as a retro object, but it is painted WIRE, not wicker, and the finish is a later/distressed black paint with a replaced-looking stone-look top — the seller's 'Antique... Wicker' title is doubly wrong. Tomato-cage tables are hugely common in AU retro trade and clear cheap: Leonard Joel realised A$120 for a genuine 1970s Parker TEAK low table — a materially superior retro piece — and a 1960s glass-top hardwood round PASSED at A$400-600 est., showing how thin retro-table demand is. Painted metal decor tier: $40-90. Ask $150 is ~2x trade. FLAG: photo 3 is a DIFFERENT object (a white shabby-chic carved/turned pedestal table) that does not match photos 1-2 — the seller has mixed listings or photographed two items.
Evidence notes
Driven by: photo 1 (black wire cage, ring stack, ~50cm round top with dark inset, white twin behind), photo 2 (top detail: rope-like black rim around a matte dark slab; surface scuffs on cage). Could NOT determine: whether the top slab is original slate or a replacement, whether the white cage behind is included in the price, and which object photo 3 belongs to; underside/feet not shown.
Title wrong on both counts: not antique, not wicker (painted wire cage)Painted/distressed finish = decor value onlyPhoto 3 shows a DIFFERENT table (white carved pedestal) — listing integrity issueStone-look top may be a replacement$150 ask is ~2x realistic resale
Comparables used
| Photo | Comparable | Price | AUD |
|---|
 | 1970s teak low side table by Parker — REALISED A$120 (genuine retro designer piece; a painted wire cage must sit below this) | 120 ≈A$120 | A$120 |
no img | 1960s Australian glass-top hardwood round low table — PASSED at est. A$400-600 (no-sale evidence for retro round tables) | 400 ≈A$500 | A$500 |
no img | Retro teak coffee table — REALISED A$220 (ceiling for retro coffee-height in AU rooms) | 220 ≈A$220 | A$220 |
Verdict: Overpriced. appraiser-child part3 (photo-first, indices 18-26)
Antique apprentice mini table 3
Overpricedconfidence: medium
⇄
My fair market value
A$10–A$25 (pt A$15)
Identification
- Form
- Miniature round tray/dish-top on a short turned pedestal column and disc foot — a decorative sweet-meat/etui stand, not a functional table
- Period
- Late 20th century (modern Mediterranean/trade souvenir work); NOT a 19th-c apprentice piece
- Timber
- Pale golden burl (olive-wood or fruitwood burl look) with a contrasting dark-veneer circular field and four-point star marquetry inlay; surface thick and glossy (poly/urethane)
- Marks
- None visible
- Construction features visible
- Shallow turned dish top with visible laminated/segmented rim join lines; applied marquetry medallion; turned stub column on plain disc foot; no drawboring, no wedge, no period hardware
Why — the visual evidence
The seller's words ('antique apprentice mini table... class up any dinner party') are contradicted by the pixels: photo 1 shows a ~20-25 cm decorative burl-wood pedestal dish with machine-crisp star marquetry and a wet poly gloss, sitting in a rendered wall niche — a modern souvenir/etui stand, the kind sold in tourist markets for AUD 20-40 new. No antique apprentice table evidence (no period turning, no hand joinery, no patina). Comparable anchor: nothing in the auction evidence trades as an 'apprentice' table; the closest real-category floor is small decorative/wine tables clearing LJ at A$100-240 — and this is not even in that class. As décor it clears $10-25 in Brisbane second-hand trade.
Evidence notes
Driven by: photo-1 pixels only — burl figure, applied star inlay, poly gloss, segmented rim, stub pedestal, and scale against the niche moulding (~20-25 cm). Photos 2 and 3 are 225px unrelated meme/thumbnail images and contributed nothing. Could NOT determine: underside, actual diameter (no ruler), whether it is real olive wood vs stained beech/burl veneer.
Not an antique and not an apprentice table — modern decorative souvenir warePhotos 2-3 are irrelevant meme thumbnails (225px) — listing hygiene is poorPoly gloss + applied marquetry = no collector market in AUDish top is shallow; useless as a table
Comparables used
| Photo | Comparable | Price | AUD |
|---|
 | 19th c continental walnut centre table (a/f), 80H x 130 dia — REALISED A$240 | 240 ≈A$240 | A$240 |
 | 1970s teak low side table by Parker, 43cm H x 76 dia — REALISED A$120 | 120 ≈A$120 | A$120 |
no img | 1stDibs drum/side category band avg ask USD 2,784 (AUD 3,910) — asking ceiling, applies only to real period drum tables | 2784 ≈A$3,910 | A$3,910 |
Second opinions — adversarial review & blind re-check
These are later, independent tests of the appraisal above. Where they disagree, the disagreement is shown side by side — the original verdict text is kept intact so you can see exactly what changed.
Blind re-appraisal (independent appraiser, original numbers hidden)
Second appraiserFair · A$25–A$100 (point A$50) · confidence low
IdentificationA genuine MINIATURE/apprentice-style table, not full-size: photo 1 shows it standing in a narrow brick wall niche with normal books beside it, putting it at roughly 40-50 cm high. Round top with concentric inlaid/banded sectors (marquetry-style segments + edge banding), single turned column, tripod base with bun/ball feet, dark stain. Workmanship and patina read as old-but-folk (c.1900-1930 candidate), though inlay could be transfer/painted — cannot confirm from pixels. Only one of three photos is the actual table.
ReasoningInlaid small forms are a thin market: an inlaid Sutherland that 'didn't rescue the form' hammered £60 (~A$120) in the UK (row 48), and AU tilt-top tea tables of full size sold A$380 with lesser examples passing at A$300-500 (rows 1, 3) — the miniature niche is narrower still, and this listing's seller used two unrelated advertisement images for photos 2-3, a trust red flag that suppresses what a buyer will pay. A$40 ask is roughly at fair value for the class.
Evidence notesPhotos 2 and 3 are unrelated Nivea deodorant advertisement images — the listing effectively has ONE photo of the object; underside, marks, and true dimensions unseen; genuine apprentice-made provenance untestable from pixels. No miniature/apprentice comparables exist in the evidence file — band derived from small-inlay and tilt-top rows discounted for format.
Verdict: Overpriced. appraiser-child part3 (photo-first, indices 18-26)
Antique Table in need of TLC
Insufficient evidenceconfidence: low
⇄
My fair market value
A$150–A$450 (pt A$250)
Identification
- Form
- small round table, 660mm H x 400mm dia — turned mahogany-toned tripod base with circular metal top hand-painted with flowers
- Period
- base possibly 19th/early-20th c; painted metal top likely 20th c, possibly not original to the base
- Timber
- mahogany-toned hardwood base (could be stained beech — photo colour only)
- Marks
- none visible
- Construction features visible
- baluster-turned single column
- tripod splayed legs
- circular top sheeted/painted metal with floral decoration and greek-key rim band
- underside shows plain round timber disc with three fixing holes and short stub legs (photo 3)
Why — the visual evidence
This is the only genuinely round table in the slice, and it is odd: photo 1 shows a pretty mahogany-toned turned tripod pedestal, photo 2 a dark metal top hand-painted with a flower bouquet and a key-pattern border (bistro/plant-stand scale at 40cm), and photo 3 an underside with a bare timber disc and three holes — suggesting the painted top may be a later or mismatched addition to an old base. The stated 'metal/cast iron top, very heavy' partly matches (dark metal face), but nothing dates the pair. As decor the painted top sells well; as an antique the marriage is unproven. Ask shown is a placeholder (12,345 = 'make an offer'), so no ask-vs-value verdict is possible.
Evidence notes
Driven by: AU cast-iron-top pub/bistro round precedent ($360, LJ lot 1007) discounted for unproven marriage and small size, with a premium for the decorative painted top. Could NOT determine: whether base and top are original to each other, cast iron vs sheet metal, rust/paint condition on the top face edges, leg feet, underside of base. Confidence low on everything but diameter.
placeholder price (12,345) — no real ask to judgetop may be a later/mismatched additionthird photo shows bare, hole-drilled underside — evidence of modificationcould be cast iron or sheet metal — unverifiedsmall size limits use
Comparables used
| Photo | Comparable | Price | AUD |
|---|
no img | Victorian circular cast-iron & hardwood pub table, 63cm dia — nearest AU comp, metal-top round | 360 ≈A$360 | A$360 |
no img | Georgian mahogany tilt-top tea table 71cm dia — what an all-original small old round clears | 380 ≈A$380 | A$380 |
no img | Victorian mahogany breakfast table (a/f) $120 — floor if the marriage fails | 120 ≈A$120 | A$120 |
Verdict: Insufficient evidence. Hermes appraiser subagent (photo-first), 21 Sep 2026
Out of scope — caught by the keyword search, not round tables
Appraised anyway for completeness; grouped and badged so a reader is never misled about what a round-table survey actually contains.
Antique Colonial washstand 3
out of scope — not a round tableBargainconfidence: medium
⇄
My fair market value
A$250–A$450 (pt A$340)
Out of scope: Not round-topped (rectangular) — out of the search brief — flagged by the appraiser; the keyword search also caught non-table items.
⚠ Adversarial review downgraded this verdict — see the second-opinions panel below the appraisal.
Identification
- Form
- Australian colonial washstand / hall stand: rectangular top with a shaped (scalloped) back and end gallery carried on scroll returns, single frieze drawer, four turned legs joined by a flat board lower shelf — NOT a round-top table
- Period
- Late Victorian / Edwardian colonial, c.1890-1920 — the seller's date range is supported by the pixels
- Timber
- Australian red cedar (read from the deep rose-brown body colour and the pale salmon freshly-exposed timber on the dovetailed board in photo 3); drawer/board ends show fine even grain, no grain-painting
- Marks
- No label or maker's mark visible; no underside view given
- Construction features visible
- Hand-cut through-dovetails at the board corner (photo 3) = pre-1900s technique; legs ring-turned with baluster and vase turnings, terminating in turned ball-and-disc feet above a plinth block; two-turn gallery with column finials; lower shelf housed into the legs (not floated); drawer with matching turned wooden pulls
Why — the visual evidence
Seller text ('c.1890-1930, solid timber, single dovetailed drawer, perfect condition') is CORROBORATED by the pixels: hand dovetails, ring-turned legs with ball feet, shaped gallery. It is genuinely antique colonial cedar, which is the strongest category in the AU evidence: Leonard Joel realised A$200 for a plain Victorian cedar round dining and A$1,800 (Leski) for a good cedar round side/tilt-top, and a Moonee Ponds dealer ASKS A$750 for a rustic cedar tripod wine table. A complete, well-modelled cedar washstand with gallery and drawer sits above the $200-360 anonymous-table band — AU trade A$250-450, with dealer asks reaching $600-900. One deduction: the surface is refinished to a bright even satin gloss (playbook: poly/refinish over patina −25-40%), so I have not gone near the $750-900 asking ceiling. Ask $200 is at/below my floor: bargain.
Evidence notes
Driven by: photo 1 (gallery profile, drawer, turning, ball feet, shelf, ~85-90cm high against the door), photo 3 (hand-cut through dovetails + pale raw cedar colour — the single most decisive detail, and the reason I accept the cedar attribution over stained pine). Could NOT determine: underside, whether the top is a single board or jointed, whether the drawer is original, whether there is water damage under the top (washstands almost always have some), extent of the refinish, and whether the feet are original or replaced. It is also not round-topped, so it sits outside the stated search brief.
Refinished — bright uniform satin gloss, likely stripped and re-varnished (−25-40% on patina value); seller's 'perfect condition' is optimisticNot round-topped (rectangular) — out of the search briefWashstand tops nearly always carry water rings/blotch underneath the new finish — cannot be checked from photosNo underside shown, so drawer/tenon originality and worm are unverifiableBall feet may be replacements
Second opinions — adversarial review & blind re-check
These are later, independent tests of the appraisal above. Where they disagree, the disagreement is shown side by side — the original verdict text is kept intact so you can see exactly what changed.
Adversarial review
Original verdictBargain · point A$340
Reviewer verdictDOWNGRADED — value overstated
Corrected rangeA$180–A$320
Pixel test'hand-cut dovetails' NOT supported: close-up shows uniform machine-grade pins/tails (fine for post-1860, but the appraiser used 'hand' as period corroboration — overstated). Lower shelf reads as plain modern board (possible replacement). Rectangular, not round — appraiser flagged this honestly. Refinished bright gloss confirmed.
WhyThree of the appraiser's corroborating claims survive the pixels (shaped gallery, frieze drawer, ring-turned legs) but the pivotal one does not: the close-up shows regular, uniform pins and tails — consistent with machine/planer-cut dovetails, not the 'hand-cut' joint the appraiser said 'the pixels corroborate'. Machine dovetails are still period post-1860, so the c.1890-1920 date is not broken, but the corroboration argument is overstated. Worse for the bargain: bright gloss refinish, and a lower shelf that is a featureless flat board reading like a later replacement (marriage risk the appraiser never tested), plus ball feet that look chunky/new. UK realiseds bracket the form tightly: Chorleys sold a Regency mahogany washstand £180 (~A$338) and a Georgian square oak one £35 (~A$66). A refinished, possibly-part-replaced cedar washstand should sit at the LOW side of the A$250-450 band; against a A$200 ask that leaves no meaningful bargain margin. Downgrade; corrected 180-320.
New evidence- Chorleys auction archive: 'A Regency mahogany washstand' SOLD £180 (~A$338 at 1.879) (A$338) Chorleys auction results (realised) ↗
- Chorleys: 'A Georgian square oak washstand, 37cm wide' SOLD £35 (~A$66) — floor for plain washstands (A$66) Chorleys auction results (realised) ↗
- RKTA auction: turned Australian cedar washstand, c.1900 — estimate only A$260-300 (realised not visible); RKTA estimates corroborate a low-hundreds trade band, not a mid-hundreds one (A$280) RKTA (estimate, NOT realised) ↗
- Antiques Atlas dealer ASKS: period cedar 2-drawer washstand £980 (~A$1,840) — asking ceiling only, correctly excluded from value (A$1,840) Antiques Atlas (asking) ↗
Blind re-appraisal (independent appraiser, original numbers hidden)
Second appraiserOverpriced · A$50–A$130 (point A$90) · confidence low
IdentificationNOT A TABLE AND NOT AN ANTIQUE WASHSTAND as titled in the strict sense: a low colonial-revival side/wash table — rectangular dished top with fitted panel (no marble or ceramic basin visible), scalloped gallery back carried on two turned uprights with bun finials, one shallow drawer, lower shelf/box, four turned legs. Timber reads as dark-stained softwood (drawer interior is pale, fresh-looking pine); surfaces too glossy/uniform for genuine 19c — this presents as a 20th-century (c.1960s-80s) 'Colonial' reproduction, possibly Australian cedar-look stained pine. No marks visible.
ReasoningThe evidence file has NO realised washstand results of any period, so the class has no comparable and I anchor conservatively: Victorian AU cedar rounds — genuinely old, better forms — cleared only ~A$200 (row 22) and a mahogany centre table A$120 (row 44) at AU trade; a repro washstand of stained pine cannot out-price those. A$200 ask is above what this tier returns.
Evidence notesTop is rectangular/semicircular-in-plan, not round — say so plainly. No marble basin; can't rule out one removed. Underside, back, joinery and hardware quality unseen; species (cedar vs stained pine) NOT determinable from pixels; a real cedar piece with maker stamp would change the number upward. Drawer interior looks modern/raw.
Verdict: Bargain. appraiser-child part3 (photo-first, indices 18-26)
Vintage T.H. Brown Extendable Dining Table with 4 Matching Chairs
out of scope — not a round tableBargainconfidence: medium
⇄
My fair market value
A$120–A$300 (pt A$180)
Out of scope: not round (oval) — flagged by the appraiser; the keyword search also caught non-table items.
Identification
- Form
- extendable oval dining table + 4 chairs (NOT round)
- Period
- c.1960s–70s, South Australian factory (T.H. Brown)
- Timber
- walnut-veneer top over manufactured boards; hardwood frames
- Marks
- T.H. Brown 'Made in South Australia' round sticker — visible in photo
- Construction features visible
- oval extendable top
- tapered legs
- circular T.H. Brown sticker visible on underside/apron (photo 1 inset)
- red vinyl/velour chair upholstery
- veneer chipping/loss along top edge (close-up photo)
- surface wear and light delamination at edges
Why — the visual evidence
The pixels confirm the seller's claim and more: the round T.H. Brown sticker is visible, the suite is a genuine 1960s-70s SA factory dining set. Condition issues are real — veneer chipped away at the edge and the red upholstery is dated — but a 5-piece solid-factory dining suite for $50 is below AU resale: comparable mid-century branded dining sets estimate $150-600 at Leonard Joel/Lawsons, and even a worn one clears four figures privately as a 'starter dining'. As a round table it fails (oval), but as value it is the best number in this slice.
Evidence notes
Driven by: visible maker sticker + complete suite + $50 ask vs auction comps for retro dining sets. Could not determine: extent of substrate damage at the chipped edge, whether the extension leaf is present and functional, frame condition of chairs.
not round (oval)veneer chipped at edgered upholstery dated — re-cover cost ~$300+extension leaf function untested
Comparables used
| Photo | Comparable | Price | AUD |
|---|
no img | Nine-piece Parker dining setting (extension table) — est 400-600 AUD | 400 ≈A$500 | A$500 |
no img | 1960s Parker extension table + 8 chairs — est 150-200 | 150 ≈A$175 | A$175 |
no img | 1970s Parker teak low side table — branded retro floor $120 | 120 ≈A$120 | A$120 |
Second opinions — adversarial review & blind re-check
These are later, independent tests of the appraisal above. Where they disagree, the disagreement is shown side by side — the original verdict text is kept intact so you can see exactly what changed.
Adversarial review
Original verdictBargain · point A$200
Reviewer verdictupheld by adversarial review
Corrected rangeA$120–A$300
Pixel test'oval not round' CONFIRMED (central leaf seam visible); TH Brown sticker CONFIRMED legible in photo; veneer chip on left chair CONFIRMED; walnut-veneer over manufactured boards consistent with uniform surface and edge construction.
WhyPixels check out on every load-bearing claim: the oval (not round) walnut-veneer top IS present, the round T.H. Brown sticker IS visible on the underside of the left leaf, the front-left chair back has a visible chip with veneer loss, and the set has splayed tapered legs with red/vinyl chairs. So the appraiser's honest reframe — 'damaged 1960s-70s factory suite, value only via maker's mark + usable parts' — is the pixels' own story, and the bargain verdict survives an adversarial read. New realised anchor strengthens rather than breaks it: Leonard Joel's published results page shows a T.H. Brown fondue table and stools (80 DIA) sold for A$320 against a A$300-400 estimate — the THB brand clears mid-hundreds even on small forms, so table+4 chairs at A$50 ask is comfortably below trade. Corrected band unchanged; I would not raise it either, since the veneer chip caps it.
Blind re-appraisal (independent appraiser, original numbers hidden)
Second appraiserBargain · A$50–A$150 (point A$90) · confidence medium
IdentificationOval (not round) extendable dining table — a centre leaf/seam visible in the extended photo — with four dark timber tapering legs (no metal tube). Top is VENEERED (figured brown veneer, high build-up gloss) and is genuinely damaged: white water marks, scratches, and two edge chips lifting to bare substrate. Maker confirmed by photo: round red/white sticker on underside reading 'PRODUCT OF T.H. BROWN & SONS PTY LTD / THB / SOUTH AUSTRALIA' — Adelaide mass-market maker, c.1960s-70s. Four matching chairs are timber-framed, red-velvet upholstered in a colonial-revival style (not period design).
ReasoningClean, restored AU mid-century branded extendables (Parker/Chiswell) retail A$1,290-1,490 (playbook rows 51-52) and Parker extension dining sets carry auction estimates A$150-600 (row 21) — but those are teak design pieces in good condition; this is a veneer-chipped, water-marked colonial-repro set, so it belongs at the bottom of / below that band, as a re-veneer-and-upholster project. At A$50 for six pieces the ask is at or under the parts value, hence bargain — while the honest retail of THIS condition remains low.
Evidence notesExtension slides/leaf count not shown; underside visible only in the label close-up; chairs' frames look timber but joints unseen; veneer chips on both near corners; set photographed in a carport/shed. Value stated for as-is condition, pre-restoration.
Verdict: Bargain. Hermes appraiser subagent (photo-first), 21 Sep 2026
Antique dining table
out of scope — not a round tableFairconfidence: low
⇄
My fair market value
A$120–A$300 (pt A$180)
Out of scope: not round — flagged by the appraiser; the keyword search also caught non-table items.
Identification
- Form
- rectangular plank-top dining table 180x105cm (NOT round)
- Period
- probably early-mid 20th c vernacular; possibly a later reproduction
- Timber
- medium honey-brown hardwood; grain and colour could suit cedar or a stained hardwood — not certain
- Marks
- none visible
- Construction features visible
- top built of 2-3 wide boards with visible joints
- plain square/peg legs, minimal apron
- surface polished with visible scratches as claimed
- photographed in what looks like a second-hand furniture showroom
Why — the visual evidence
Photos show a heavy plank-top rectangular table with plain legs and honest old-looking wear — the seller's 'very heavy solid, obvious scratches' matches the pixels, but the form is rectangular, not round, and there is nothing (no turning, no pedestal, no moulding, no stamp) that lifts it above anonymous vernacular. Photo 3 is an unrelated tropical-resort aerial. Even genuinely old plain timber dining tables clear ~$200 at Australian trade auction, so $150 is about right — a fair ask for a possible 1920s-50s farm table, a bargain only if it proves to be documented cedar.
Evidence notes
Driven by: plank construction + plain legs = vernacular category, priced by LJ lot 1097 ($200). Could NOT determine: age (no underside or hardware shown), species under the warm finish, whether boards are original or a replaced top — low confidence.
not roundage unverifiable from photosscratched surfaceirrelevant 3rd photo (resort aerial)showroom stock — check for replaced top in person
Comparables used
| Photo | Comparable | Price | AUD |
|---|
no img | Victorian Australian cedar dining table 120cm dia — genuine old cedar round: $200 | 200 ≈A$200 | A$200 |
no img | Victorian mahogany breakfast table (a/f) — as-found anonymous old table: $120 | 120 ≈A$120 | A$120 |
no img | Flemish oak draw-leaf 300yo — old + real features is what gets you past $200 | 700 ≈A$700 | A$700 |
Verdict: Fair. Hermes appraiser subagent (photo-first), 21 Sep 2026
Antique Dining Table
out of scope — not a round tableFairconfidence: low
⇄
My fair market value
A$120–A$250 (pt A$180)
Out of scope: NOT a round table — rectangular — flagged by the appraiser; the keyword search also caught non-table items.
Identification
- Form
- REFUTED-round: this is a RECTANGULAR dining table, ~1.4-1.6m, four legs; it does not belong in a round-table search at all
- Period
- most likely 20th-century (1960s-1980s) 'antique-style' country table, refinished; not the 'Antique Dining Table' the title implies
- Timber
- honey-blond hardwood or stained pine — bright even colour with mild grain; consistent with a stripped/refinished softwood or oak, NOT cedar or mahogany
- Marks
- none visible
- Construction features visible
- plain rectangular top with rounded corner blocks, straight apron, heavy baluster-turned legs with pointed/turned feet; screw-fixed legs likely (no pegged mortise visible)
Why — the visual evidence
Pixels override title: photos 1-2 (phone screenshots, 432px wide) clearly show a rectangular top, so 'round table' value logic does not apply. The satin even sheen and clean blond colour say a stripped and poly/satin-refinished 20th-century country-style table. Ordinary refinished rectangular dining tables clear the low hundreds at AU auction (cf Leonard Joel's anonymous colonial-style dining results around $200), so $250 ask is roughly at the top of value — fair but not a bargain.
Evidence notes
Drove: rectangular top in both visible photos; baluster turnings look machine-clean; finish uniform satin (refinished). Could NOT determine: underside, hardware, true timber (pine vs oak), dimensions, whether leaves/drawers exist; images are cropped phone screenshots with UI chrome.
NOT a round table — rectangulartitle claims 'antique'; pixels read 20th-c refinishedscreenshots with phone UI, 432px wide, no underside visible'seats 6, minor wear' untestable from photos
Comparables used
| Photo | Comparable | Price | AUD |
|---|
 | Victorian Australian cedar dining table, 75H x 120 DIA (anonymous AU dining table at trade level) | 200 ≈A$200 | A$200 |
 | 1970s teak low side table by Parker | 120 ≈A$120 | A$120 |
Verdict: Fair. Hermes dealer-appraiser child (photo-first), session 2026-09-21
Solid wood table + chairs
out of scope — not a round tableFairconfidence: low
⇄
My fair market value
A$100–A$260 (pt A$160)
Out of scope: not round — flagged by the appraiser; the keyword search also caught non-table items.
Identification
- Form
- rectangular vernacular dining table with one frieze drawer (NOT round), sold with 5 chairs
- Period
- uncertain: early-mid 20th c colonial-revival vernacular, or 1970s antique-style reproduction
- Timber
- dark-stained hardwood — possibly cedar under stain, unverifiable
- Marks
- none visible
- Construction features visible
- moulded overhanging top
- single frieze drawer with turned pull
- four bobbin/ring-turned legs with knee spares
- worn broken varnish with bleached water-worn patches
- mismatched spindle/slat-back chairs
Why — the visual evidence
The seller's 'solid wood, 20+ years, needs a wipe down' is contradicted on two counts: the form is rectangular, not round, and the 'wipe down' understates a top whose finish has failed over most of the surface. Visually it is a heavy vernacular turned-leg farm table — the all-over dark stain defeats species ID (could be genuine cedar, could be 1970s stained hardwood reproduction), and photo 3 is an unrelated car shot, which tells you how little effort went into provenance. On the AU market, even genuine old anonymous dining tables clear ~$200 (LJ cedar round lot 1097); a rectangular example with a failed finish and a part-matched chair set sits at the ask, not above it.
Evidence notes
Drove the number: failed surface (refinish cost ~$300+), non-round anonymous form, mixed chairs. Could NOT determine: species under stain, underside joinery, age, any maker mark — hence low confidence.
not roundfinish failed over most of top — full refinish requiredspecies and age unverifiable under dark stainchairs are a mismatched setirrelevant 3rd photo (a car)
Comparables used
| Photo | Comparable | Price | AUD |
|---|
no img | Victorian Australian cedar dining table, 120cm dia — ordinary genuine cedar round clears only ~$200 | 200 ≈A$200 | A$200 |
no img | Colonial NSW cedar Regency supper table c.1835 — documented, attractive cedar commands 1.8k | 1800 ≈A$1,800 | A$1,800 |
no img | Victorian mahogany breakfast/centre table (a/f) — 'as found' anonymous rounds sell at 120 | 120 ≈A$120 | A$120 |
Verdict: Fair. Hermes appraiser subagent (photo-first), 21 Sep 2026
Antique Colonial Red Cedar Table legs pick up Ipswich $125 3
out of scope — not a round tableFairconfidence: medium
⇄
My fair market value
A$70–A$140 (pt A$100)
Out of scope: Not a table — parts only, out of scope for the round-table brief — flagged by the appraiser; the keyword search also caught non-table items.
Identification
- Form
- NOT a table — a matched pair of loose antique turned legs with square fixing blocks (top tenons) and long mounting spigots; gaffer-taped with '760 x 75' written on the tape (≈760mm long, 75mm square tenons)
- Period
- Victorian/Edwardian colonial, c.1880-1910; heavy baroque-baluster turning with ring turns and a large vase bead near the foot end
- Timber
- Genuine Australian red cedar reads correctly: faded rose-brown with grey weathered patches, dry old surface, dirt in the turning hollows — not painted, not stained pine (matches seller text 'colonial cedar, never painted')
- Marks
- Handwritten size on tape only; no maker's mark
- Construction features visible
- Lathe-turned from solid stock; square tenon block at one end (for a base/apron mortise), long turned spigot at the other (for a pedestal/socket) — these are pedestal-column legs or centre-table supports, not ordinary four-leg table legs
Why — the visual evidence
Photo-first: the pixels agree with the description — old, unpainted, correctly cedar-coloured turnings with genuine dried patina and no breaks visible. Value is that of salvage/woodworker parts: AU auction evidence prices whole anonymous cedar tables at $200-360, so a pair of loose legs cannot approach that; but good solid 760cm cedar turnings do carry a real parts premium with restorers (a matched pair of genuine colonial turnings is not obtainable new). Trade band $70-140; ask $125 sits at the top of the range but inside it — fair, haggle to ~$100. Not a round table (parts only), flagged accordingly.
Evidence notes
Driven by: photo 1 (full pair laid on carpet with 760x75 measurement tape — baluster turning profile, spigot ends), photo 3 close-up (square tenon blocks, dry check-free timber, original wax/dirt surface, minor dings but no splits or worm holes visible in the grain shown). Could NOT determine: whether both are truly a matched pair from ONE table (turnings look consistent), the underside of the tenons (old screw holes/mortise), species confirmation without a raw cut, and whether the '75' is tenon square or diameter.
Not a table — parts only, out of scope for the round-table briefOnly 2 legs (a set of 4 would be worth ~double)No top/apron; provenance of donor piece unknownSmall dings/dirt in turnings; needs light cleaning or refinishingCannot verify both legs came from the same piece
Comparables used
| Photo | Comparable | Price | AUD |
|---|
 | Victorian Australian cedar dining table (whole table) — REALISED A$200: the ceiling no parts lot can exceed | 200 ≈A$200 | A$200 |
no img | Anonymous turned colonial round table (a/f) 74H x 65 — REALISED A$100: what turned colonial parts-to-table grade fetches | 100 ≈A$100 | A$100 |
no img | Playbook: 'A painted or poly-coated cedar table sells at the bottom of its band — -30-50%' (these are UNpainted, so they sit at the TOP of the parts band instead) | band ≈A$0 | A$0 |
Verdict: Fair. appraiser-child part3 (photo-first, indices 18-26)
Beautiful Vintage side table 3
out of scope — not a round tableFairconfidence: medium
⇄
My fair market value
A$60–A$150 (pt A$100)
Out of scope: NOT a round table — rectangular console (misfits the search brief) — flagged by the appraiser; the keyword search also caught non-table items.
Identification
- Form
- Console/sofa table — RECTANGULAR glass-inset top (not round): clear bevelled glass set into a stained-timber frame carved with leaf/feather motifs, on a black wrought-iron double-scroll base with scrolled feet
- Period
- c.1980s French-Provincial-style reproduction (metal-and-glass console), not antique
- Timber
- Stained hardwood frame (mahogany-tone, likely beech or a bonded timber), painted/distressed black iron with gilt-painted acanthus rosettes at the corners
- Marks
- None visible
- Construction features visible
- Frame mitred and fixed over the glass rebate; iron legs are tubular/flat-bar scrolls with volute feet, H-stretcher; gilt carved-wood leaf blocks at corners; no castors, no screws visible from top
Why — the visual evidence
Seller calls it an 'ornate vintage side table 128x46x66' — the pixels confirm the dimensions and the ornate claim, but it is NOT round (it is a rectangular glass-top console), so it only half-matches a round-table hunt. The combination of machine-pressed repeating leaf carvings, black paint + gold-painted rosettes and a bent-iron base is the classic 1980s 'French Provincial' repro formula (playbook: 'pressed mouldings, identical repeated carvings' = factory reproduction). Paint/distress and repro status kill antique value; it sells as decor. AU auction reality for decor-tier tables: LJ anonymous round/centre tables clear $100-240 — a repro iron console sits below that, $60-150. Ask $150 is the top of that band: fair, negotiable to ~$100.
Evidence notes
Driven by: rectangular bevelled glass inset, repeating machine-leaf carving on the frame rails, black-painted scroll iron with gilt corner blocks, scrolled strap feet. Could NOT determine: whether the timber frame is solid or bonded, underside fixings, glass originality or replacement, any label. Photos 2-3 are the same table at other angles.
NOT a round table — rectangular console (misfits the search brief)1980s reproduction; painted iron + gilt = decor value onlyGlass inset likely original but untested for rattles/scratchesNo maker's mark; import-era provenance unknown
Comparables used
| Photo | Comparable | Price | AUD |
|---|
 | 19th c continental walnut centre table (a/f) 80H x 130 — REALISED A$240 (a genuine 19th-c occasional table, ceiling for this class) | 240 ≈A$240 | A$240 |
no img | Victorian pub table (round) — REALISED A$360 | 360 ≈A$360 | A$360 |
no img | 1980s Baker 'Georgian' repro pedestal tea table — Chairish ASKING USD 2,595 (AUD 3,645): shows repro furniture only asks, rarely realises, and this is iron-repro not wood-repro | 2595 ≈A$3,645 | A$3,645 |
Verdict: Fair. appraiser-child part3 (photo-first, indices 18-26)
Solid Timber coffee table
out of scope — not a round tableFairconfidence: medium
⇄
My fair market value
A$50–A$150 (pt A$90)
Out of scope: not round — flagged by the appraiser; the keyword search also caught non-table items.
Identification
- Form
- rectangular coffee table 130x80x47 (NOT round)
- Period
- c.1985–2000 retail rustic
- Timber
- mixed-tone 'barnwood' boards + silky-oak/rubberwood-look turned legs
- Marks
- none visible
- Construction features visible
- moulded-edge top of mixed-tone boards with end-grain blocks between
- chunky baluster-turned legs
- apron rails
- glossy orange-toned polyurethane
- minor surface marks only
Why — the visual evidence
The pixels show machine-turned chunky baluster legs and a deliberate mixed-tone 'barnwood' top under thick orange poly — a late-20th-century retail rustic design, not an antique farm piece: the wear is even and manufactured-looking, the poly is intact, and there are no hand marks, worm, or true age patina. Solid and presentable as-is. Worth around the $60 asked, maybe a little more to a buyer who likes the look.
Evidence notes
Driven by: glossy poly + machine turning = post-1985. Retro hardwood tables clear ~$100-220 at AU auction when branded/teak; unbranded poly rustic sits under that. Could not determine: species of the top boards, underside.
not round1985-2000 retail rustic, not antiquethick orange poly limits refinishing options
Comparables used
| Photo | Comparable | Price | AUD |
|---|
no img | 1970s Parker teak low side table — branded retro benchmark $120 | 120 ≈A$120 | A$120 |
no img | Teak coffee table — $220 shows the ceiling for anonymous retro | 220 ≈A$220 | A$220 |
no img | Octagonal inlaid coffee table $100 — retro/antique-look coffee table floor | 100 ≈A$100 | A$100 |
Verdict: Fair. Hermes appraiser subagent (photo-first), 21 Sep 2026
Solid timber coffee table
out of scope — not a round tableFairconfidence: medium
⇄
My fair market value
A$50–A$130 (pt A$80)
Out of scope: not round — flagged by the appraiser; the keyword search also caught non-table items.
Identification
- Form
- SQUARE low coffee table 120x120cm (NOT round)
- Period
- modern rustic, c.2000s (retail or workshop-made)
- Timber
- light honey-coloured Australian hardwood — blackbutt/tallowwood look
- Marks
- none visible
- Construction features visible
- plank top built from boards
- massive square-section stubby legs
- housed/pegged mortise-tenon corner joints
- cross-battens under top (photo 2 underside)
- open frame, no shelf
- very dirty, worn, almost unfinished surface
Why — the visual evidence
Photos show a square (not round) heavy rustic hardwood coffee table with pegged through-tenons at the corners and chunky square legs — a 'bush/outback' catalogue design of the 2000s, or a competent workshop copy. It is honestly solid and structurally sound, exactly as claimed ('needs a sand and a coat' matches the dirty, worn, stain-marked surface). Solid hardwood + real joinery gives it genuine utility resale value, but no antique interest.
Evidence notes
Number driven by: real solid-timber construction visible in underside/leg-joint photos vs modern date. Retro coffee tables at AU auction clear ~$100-220 even when older/better-looking, and this needs refinishing work — so $50-130. Could not determine: whether workshop or retail, board count on top surface fully.
not roundmodern, no antique valuesurface dirty/worn — buyer pays for sanding
Comparables used
| Photo | Comparable | Price | AUD |
|---|
no img | Teak coffee table 93x70 — generic retro coffee table benchmark | 220 ≈A$220 | A$220 |
no img | 1970s Parker teak low side table 76cm — branded retro low table at $120 | 120 ≈A$120 | A$120 |
no img | Octagonal inlaid coffee table — 'antique-look' coffee tables bottom at $100 | 100 ≈A$100 | A$100 |
Verdict: Fair. Hermes appraiser subagent (photo-first), 21 Sep 2026
Coffee table solid wood
out of scope — not a round tableFairconfidence: medium
⇄
My fair market value
A$30–A$80 (pt A$50)
Out of scope: not round — flagged by the appraiser; the keyword search also caught non-table items.
Identification
- Form
- low rectangular coffee table with frieze drawer and end shelf (NOT round)
- Period
- c.1990s–2000s mass-market 'country style'
- Timber
- walnut-brown stained plantation timber (species indeterminate)
- Marks
- none visible
- Construction features visible
- multi-board top with visible joints
- straight square legs
- one drawer with metal cup pull
- open shelf at one end
- heavily scratched dusty satin finish
Why — the visual evidence
From the pixels: machine-made rectangular coffee table, square legs, cup-pull drawer, scratched satin finish — late-20th-century 'country' catalogue furniture, not antique and not mid-century. The seller's 'structurally perfect, needs a good clean' reads honest for once: there is no split or wobble visible, just a tired surface. Nothing about it supports any collector value; it is worth exactly the $50 asked as a utility table.
Evidence notes
Drove the number: retro/modern mass-market furniture floor in AU auction results (small coffee tables bottom out ~$100 at Leonard Joel even when genuinely old; a 1990s repro sits below that). Could not determine: underside, species. Not round — flagged.
not roundnot antique — 1990s reproductionsurface scratched, would need refinish
Comparables used
| Photo | Comparable | Price | AUD |
|---|
no img | Teak coffee table 50cm H — generic retro coffee tables sell ~$220 AU | 220 ≈A$220 | A$220 |
no img | Octagonal mahogany & glass-inset coffee table — small 'antique-look' coffee tables bottom at $100 | 100 ≈A$100 | A$100 |
no img | 1970s Parker teak low side table — branded retro still only $120 | 120 ≈A$120 | A$120 |
Verdict: Fair. Hermes appraiser subagent (photo-first), 21 Sep 2026
Koala Living Pedestal Dining Table
out of scope — not a round tableOverpricedconfidence: medium
⇄
My fair market value
A$350–A$600 (pt A$450)
Out of scope: not round — flagged by the appraiser; the keyword search also caught non-table items.
Identification
- Form
- rectangular 2.2m dining table (NOT round)
- Period
- contemporary (Koala Living, current AU retailer)
- Timber
- espresso/black-stained hardwood (species hidden by stain)
- Marks
- Koala Living brand (seller-stated)
- Construction features visible
- thick top
- frieze with applied dentil/Greek-key moulding
- double vase-turned pedestals on plank feet
- modern retail reproduction of Georgian pedestal style
- surface appears unmarked as claimed
Why — the visual evidence
Seller calls it 'like new' — the photos agree on condition, but the object is a big modern retail reproduction of a Georgian double-pedestal dining table: applied dentil moulding, uniform espresso stain, machine-turned pedestals, and it is rectangular, not round. Current-retail resale of large modern dining tables in Brisbane is notoriously weak; $800 is close to what the piece would have been discounted to in a sale, so the second-hand value sits well below the ask.
Evidence notes
Driven by: applied (not carved) moulding, stain, retail brand = zero antique value; size works against resale (hard to shift, few buyers). Auction analogue: modern/retro dining sets estimate only 150-600. Could not determine: exact new price, material of top core (veneer over MDF possible — photos don't show edge construction at resolution).
not roundmodern reproduction, no antique valueapplied moulding, stain hides specieslarge size hurts resaleask near retail clearance level
Comparables used
| Photo | Comparable | Price | AUD |
|---|
no img | Nine-piece Parker dining setting w/ extension table — AU auction est only 400-600 | 400 ≈A$500 | A$500 |
no img | George IV mahogany 3-pedestal dining table, provenance — the REAL thing this imitates: US$8,500 | 8500 ≈A$12,900 | A$12,900 |
no img | 1960s glass-top retro round low table PASSED at est 400-600 — big anonymous tables don't even sell | 400 ≈— | — |
Second opinions — adversarial review & blind re-check
These are later, independent tests of the appraisal above. Where they disagree, the disagreement is shown side by side — the original verdict text is kept intact so you can see exactly what changed.
Adversarial review
Original verdictOverpriced · point A$450
Reviewer verdictupheld by adversarial review
Corrected rangeA$350–A$600
Pixel test'rectangular not round' CONFIRMED; applied dentil moulding and uniform espresso stain CONFIRMED (no patina, no figure visible through stain). Modern-repro ID stands.
WhyTest: is 'overpriced at A$800' too harsh for a 2.2m contemporary hardwood-look dining table? Pixels confirm the appraiser's ID entirely: rectangular (not round — out of scope), applied dentil/Greek-key frieze moulding, uniform espresso stain hiding species, contemporary retail product. The only real counter-evidence points UPWARD, not downward: Leonard Joel's published results page shows a large anonymous oak farmhouse dining table sold A$1,000 (est 500-700) and a Nicholas Dattner hardwood dining table sold A$750 — so solid-hardwood big tables CAN clear near the ask. But those are solid oak/designer pieces; Koala Living is volume retail reproduction stock and the piece's own resale market is discount furniture, where 350-600 is honest. The 'overpriced' verdict holds; I flag the LJ anchors as upside risk to the band rather than breaking the claim.
New evidence- Leonard Joel results: 'A LARGE OAK FARMHOUSE DINING TABLE' est $500-700 SOLD $1,000; 'Australian hardwood dining table by Nicholas Dattner' est $500-700 SOLD $750 — upside anchors for solid-wood big tables (this piece is veneer-core retail repro, so discount applies) (A$875) Leonard Joel (realised) ↗
Verdict: Overpriced. Hermes appraiser subagent (photo-first), 21 Sep 2026
Antique Bentwood bistrochair
out of scope — not a round tableOverpricedconfidence: low
⇄
My fair market value
A$80–A$150 (pt A$110)
Out of scope: no table in the listing — out of scope for table buyers — flagged by the appraiser; the keyword search also caught non-table items.
Identification
- Form
- single bentwood side chair — no table pictured
- Period
- later 20th-c bentwood (c.1960s-80s), possibly Italian; not 19th-c Thonet
- Timber
- beech bentwood, honey varnish; stencilled/transfer floral on back slat; punched/decorated seat
- Marks
- none readable (stencil no. of a maker's mark not visible)
- Construction features visible
- continuous bent-wood hoop back
- stencil-floral decorated slat
- metal-seat ring
- one rear stay visibly misaligned/off-square
Why — the visual evidence
The listing title says 'chair' and the pixels agree: it is a single bentwood chair — no table appears in any photo (one photo even shows car leaf-springs, unrelated). The stencilled floral and punched seat look like a 1960s-80s Continental reproduction decorative treatment rather than genuine antique Thonet; a rear stay is off-square, suggesting a loose or repaired joint.
Evidence notes
Honest gap: the auction evidence files contain no bentwood-chair rows, so this number comes from AU used-market reality (repro bentwood chairs trade $60-150 each; genuine Thonet numbers would sit higher, and cannot be established from these photos). Ask $200 for one repro chair with a joint question → overpriced. Confidence low: no comparable rows, seat underside and joint integrity not visible.
no table in the listing — out of scope for table buyersrepro, not antique Thonetrear stay misaligned: joint issueno comparable rows exist in evidence for bentwood chairs
Comparables used
| Photo | Comparable | Price | AUD |
|---|
 | 1970s teak low side table by Parker, 43cm H x 76 dia — used-proxy only: anonymous retro furniture clears ~$120 — same ceiling applies to repro seating | 120 ≈A$120 | A$120 |
 | Chiswell teak wine-bar storage side table — branded retro asking $790 — brand/designer is what lifts used prices; this chair shows none | 790 ≈A$790 | A$790 |
 | 1960s Australian glass-topped hardwood circular table, 53H x 145 dia (passed, est 400-600) — demand reality for anonymous retro: passed at $400-600 | 400 ≈— | — |
Verdict: Overpriced. Hermes appraiser subagent (photo-first), 2026-09-21
Vintage 8-legged Recycled Coffee Table 3
out of scope — not a round tableOverpricedconfidence: medium
⇄
My fair market value
A$70–A$150 (pt A$110)
Out of scope: Rectangular, not round — out of brief scope — flagged by the appraiser; the keyword search also caught non-table items.
Identification
- Form
- RECTANGULAR coffee table (not round as the search list implies): a reclaimed door/panel top laid flat on a white-painted 8-leg base — a DIY 'recycled' assemblage
- Period
- Top boards: aged softwood/hardwood, possibly a 19th-early 20th C door (central lock-mortise cut-out visible); base: c.1980s French-Provincial repro table parts, painted
- Timber
- Top: 6-7 Tongued-and-grooved boards, heavy orange-brown stain over old patina, visible board joints and the rectangular lock-mortise hole in the middle; base: white/limed-painted apron with scalloped (bourdron-ish) edge and 8 tapered legs with pad feet
- Marks
- None visible
- Construction features visible
- Door top simply laid/screwed onto a shortened painted table frame; eight turned-taper legs (double-ended so 8 read at once); paint is distressed/shabby, satin poly over top
Why — the visual evidence
Seller text ('gorgeous low set 8-legged, recycled barn door and cabinet, fused from 2 vintage pieces') is honest and matches the pixels — it IS two salvaged pieces fused. But: (a) the top is rectangular, so it is not a round table at all; (b) the painted base is 1980s provincial-rep parts (identical repeated taper legs, pressed scalloped apron), and shabby-chalk paint 'sells as décor, ~$50-150' per the playbook damage table; (c) the door top is attractive but stained and sanded, with the lock hole showing. AU realised anchors for real antique occasional tables ($120-360 at LJ) set the CEILING for salvaged-part assemblages, which clear below them: $70-150. The $250 ask is above what second-hand rustic-DIEM décor realises locally.
Evidence notes
Driven by: photo 2 close view — seven boards with T&G joints, central lock-mortise cut, uneven stain; eight white tapered legs, scalloped painted apron, concrete + corrugated iron setting showing ~110x60cm footprint, ~40cm high. Could NOT determine: actual species of door (huon/pine/hardwood?), whether top is fixed or loose, underside joinery, whether the '8 legs' are original to one base or two bases spliced.
Rectangular, not round — out of brief scopeDIY assemblage, not a period piece; zero collector demandShabby white paint destroys any antique value in the baseStained/varnished door top with visible hardware mortiseAsk $250 exceeds realised comps for real retro tables
Comparables used
| Photo | Comparable | Price | AUD |
|---|
no img | Retro teak coffee table 50H — REALISED A$220 (a designer retro piece — still the ceiling here) | 220 ≈A$220 | A$220 |
 | 1970s Parker teak low side table — REALISED A$120: what genuine retro coffee-height tables fetch | 120 ≈A$120 | A$120 |
no img | Playbook: chalk/shabby paint 'sells as décor, ~$50-150' | 50 ≈A$100 | A$100 |
Verdict: Overpriced. appraiser-child part3 (photo-first, indices 18-26)
Antique Vintage Radio
out of scope — not a round tableInsufficient evidenceconfidence: low
⇄
My fair market value
A$200–A$600 (pt A$400)
Out of scope: not a round table — out of scope for this report — flagged by the appraiser; the keyword search also caught non-table items.
ℹ Adversarial review: could not verify from the evidence.
Identification
- Form
- NOT a table — circular-dial Bakelite table radio (EKCO 'Round' family per seller); the round timber surface in the photos is only the surface it stands on
- Period
- 1930s-50s British Bakelite radio (seller claims 1934 Ekco AD76, Wells Coates design)
- Timber
- n/a (radio); sits on an unlisted dark timber surface
- Marks
- no dial/badge/back-panel maker mark legible in the photos
- Construction features visible
- circular dial face, dark brown/black moulded case, speaker grille and knobs visible; working order untested
Why — the visual evidence
Photo-first, the item is a radio, not a round table — it is out of scope for this appraisal and no comparable in the three evidence files covers radios, so any number would be an unsourced guess. The round dial and dark Bakelite case are consistent with an EKCO circular radio; the specific AD76 claim cannot be confirmed from these photos (dial detail illegible). Value band shown is a deliberately wide, unanchored placeholder for a second-hand collectible radio of this look; do not treat it as an appraisal.
Evidence notes
Drove the verdict: every photo shows a circular dial radio, no table for sale. Could NOT determine: exact model, whether it powers on, dial lamp, case cracks, back-panel labels. No radio comparables exist in auction-evidence.md, appraisal-playbook.md or comparables-manifest.json — citing none rather than inventing any.
not a round table — out of scope for this reportmodel claim (Ekco AD76) unverifiable from photosno comparables in evidence files; value band is a placeholder, not an appraisalworking condition untested
Comparables used
| Photo | Comparable | Price | AUD |
|---|
no img | (no comparable available) n/a | — | — |
Second opinions — adversarial review & blind re-check
These are later, independent tests of the appraisal above. Where they disagree, the disagreement is shown side by side — the original verdict text is kept intact so you can see exactly what changed.
Adversarial review
Original verdictInsufficient evidence · point A$400
Reviewer verdictcannot verify from the evidence
Corrected rangeA$400–A$950
Pixel testModel marking ILLEGIBLE in all photos — Ekco AD76 claim unverifiable (appraiser said so). Round Bakelite case plausible; condition (knobs/grille) not confirmable. Radio, not a table: out of scope, honestly flagged.
WhyThe appraiser honestly declared this out-of-scope (it is a radio, not a table) and refused to anchor the A$400 point — the correct move, and I cannot break a claim that was never made. My independent check: the dial/model marking is not legible in any of the three photos, so the Ekco AD76 attribution remains unverifiable from pixels. I did find realised results for the Ekco 'Round'/AD65 family IF the piece were one: £260 (Easy Live, Apr 2025 ≈ A$489), £500 (Wotton, Dec 2020 ≈ A$940), £1,600 hammer with original stand (Henry Adams 2017 ≈ A$3,006), £720 (Bonhams 2008). Those span and exceed the placeholder band, but applying them requires a model confirmation the photos cannot give. Verdict cannot-verify; value only meaningful (400-950) if the dial is photographed legibly and confirms Ekco AD-series.
New evidence- Ekco AD65 Bakelite radio, realised £260 (Apr 2025) ≈ A$489 (A$489) Easy Live Auction (realised) ↗
- Ekco AD65 circular Bakelite radio, realised £500 (Dec 2020) ≈ A$940 (A$940) Wotton Auction Rooms (realised) ↗
- Ekco AD65 on original stand, £1,600 hammer (2017) ≈ A$3,006 — top-of-family outlier, not a base case (A$3,006) Henry Adams Auctions (realised hammer) ↗
- Bonhams 2008: Ekco AD65, chassis fully restored, sold £720 inc. premium ≈ A$1,353 (A$1,353) Bonhams (realised) ↗
Verdict: Insufficient evidence. appraiser-child part4 (photo-first, indices 27-34)
Large VINTAGE Timber Table
out of scope — not a round tableInsufficient evidenceconfidence: low
⇄
My fair market value
A$100–A$250 (pt A$150)
Out of scope: NOT round — rectangular top — flagged by the appraiser; the keyword search also caught non-table items.
Identification
- Form
- large rectangular/rounded-corner trestle table — NOT round
- Period
- claimed 'vintage, refurbished'; photos read as a newer shabby-chic repro
- Timber
- painted (sage-green chalk/distressed) over hardwood/pine, grain not legible
- Marks
- none
- Construction features visible
- single plank-look painted top with eased corners
- trestle/Pedestal block base
- artificial distressing on edges
Why — the visual evidence
Two things the pixels contradict: (1) despite the round-table search and title, the top is rectangular ~1825×905, not round; (2) the three 'listing' photos are staged retailer/marketing images (styled props, even lighting, plant styling) rather than phone photos of a specific second-hand item — that plus the even chalk-green distressing points to a new or recently-made reproduction sold on, not a refurbished antique. What the buyer actually receives cannot be confirmed.
Evidence notes
Because the photos may not depict the real item, this is 'insufficient-evidence'. If the item matches the image, a 1.8 m painted trestle is worth its cheap-new-equivalent minus used discount: ~100-250, point 150 vs ask 150. Realised auction anchors for genuine vintage tables of this size (Vickhoad pad-foot $380, Austin tilt-top $645, Fonsie Mealy flip-top ~A$250-420 est.) bracket how much less a repro should fetch. Underside, actual condition and whether it even exists as pictured are unverifiable.
NOT round — rectangular topstaged marketing photos, item identity unverifiedprobable new reproduction, distressing looks artificialno condition report possible
Comparables used
| Photo | Comparable | Price | AUD |
|---|
 | Georgian English pad-foot tilt-top tea table, 71cm H x 71cm dia — genuine Georgian tilt-top realised A$380 — a painted repro must sit below this | 380 ≈A$380 | A$380 |
 | Rustic French Provincial tilt-top wine tasting table, 19th C, 40in dia, sold $425 +BP — solid rustic genuine $645 (US, freight-discounted) | 425 ≈A$645 | A$645 |
 | Irish Georgian mahogany flip-top table, bulbous pillar, 80cm dia — genuine Irish Georgian flip-top estimated only ~A$250-420 in UK/Irish trade | 150 ≈— | — |
 | Early Australian cedar round dining, 120cm dia, restored — dealer asking $550 for real cedar round — asking ≠ paid | 550 ≈A$550 | A$550 |
 | Vintage Regency-style leather-top round drum table with drawers (Bazaa Sydney) — retail asking ceiling $702 for vintage-style drum table | 702 ≈A$702 | A$702 |
Verdict: Insufficient evidence. Hermes appraiser subagent (photo-first), 2026-09-21
Colorful Vintage Large Ceramic Elephant Plant Stand, Boho Glazed Brown, Blue Hand Painted Side Table
out of scope — not a round tableInsufficient evidenceconfidence: low
⇄
My fair market value
A$80–A$180 (pt A$130)
Out of scope: not a round table at all — flagged by the appraiser; the keyword search also caught non-table items.
Identification
- Form
- ceramic elephant sculpture used as plant stand / faux side table; flat saddle platform on the back is roughly round and could take a tray, but there is NO actual round table in the photos
- Period
- late 20th century decorative import (1980s-2000s boho), not antique
- Timber
- none — glazed earthenware
- Marks
- none visible
- Construction features visible
- hollow-cast ceramic body, painted and glazed in layered brown/ochre/teal tones; base unmarked in photos
Why — the visual evidence
Photo-first: all three photos show only a ceramic elephant on a patio; the title's 'plant stand / boho side table' is decorative language, not furniture. Glaze is thick and uniform with crisp transfer-like decoration and no age-related crazing visible at this resolution; reads as a modern import rather than antique Asian export ware. The evidence files contain no ceramics comparables, so my range is trade intuition for second-hand decorative ceramics in SE-Queensland, NOT auction-anchored — hence insufficient-evidence.
Evidence notes
Drove: object is not a table; condition good (no trunk/ear chips visible in the 3 views); size looks ~60-70cm tall against the pot beside it. Could NOT determine: base markings, weight, hairline cracks, or whether the saddle takes a removable round tray.
not a round table at allno auction comparables for ceramics in evidence setvalue unanchored — trade intuition onlyglaze/finish suggests modern import, not antique
Comparables used
| Photo | Comparable | Price | AUD |
|---|
no img | (no comparables available) n/a | — | — |
Verdict: Insufficient evidence. Hermes dealer-appraiser child (photo-first), session 2026-09-21
Antique Vintage Jug/Vase
out of scope — not a round tableInsufficient evidenceconfidence: low
⇄
My fair market value
A$30–A$100 (pt A$60)
Out of scope: not a round table — out of scope — flagged by the appraiser; the keyword search also caught non-table items.
Identification
- Form
- NOT a table — cream/white footed ceramic vessel (jug/vase/urn on a splayed pedestal foot) photographed on a workbench; the footed form superficially echoes a pedestal table but it is pottery
- Period
- indeterminate; looks 20th-century decorative, not antique
- Timber
- n/a
- Marks
- none readable
- Construction features visible
- glazed ceramic, flared circular foot, no marks legible
Why — the visual evidence
The pixels show a ceramic vessel, not a round table; it is out of scope and the evidence files contain no ceramics comparables. The seller's own title ('Jug/Vase') matches what is visible — no contradiction to resolve, but there is no table to appraise and no sourced comp to price the pottery, so the band is a wide placeholder.
Evidence notes
Drove the verdict: three views of a glazed footed jug/vase on a potting bench; no furniture offered. Could NOT determine: material (earthenware vs stoneware vs porcelain), size, maker, chips/hairlines. Citing no comparables because none in the manifest cover ceramics.
not a round table — out of scopeno comparables in evidence files; placeholder band onlysize and maker unverifiable from photos
Comparables used
| Photo | Comparable | Price | AUD |
|---|
no img | (no comparable available) n/a | — | — |
Verdict: Insufficient evidence. appraiser-child part4 (photo-first, indices 27-34)
Vintage 80's White Swan 20cm ceramic Taiwan retro vases 3
out of scope — not a round tableInsufficient evidenceconfidence: low
⇄
My fair market value
A$15–A$40 (pt A$25)
Out of scope: NOT A TABLE — misclassified listing — flagged by the appraiser; the keyword search also caught non-table items.
Identification
- Form
- NOT A TABLE — a pair of moulded white-glaze ceramic swan-form vases (tail-plume vessels with red-painted beaks), circa 1980s Taiwanese export ware
- Period
- c.1980s ('Made in Taiwan' paper label, not occupation-era)
- Timber
- n/a — ceramic
- Marks
- 'MADE IN TAIWAN' paper/foil label on base (photo 3)
- Construction features visible
- Slip-cast hollow bodies, fluted opened-tail mouths; seller states ~20cm; one with chipped rim per text, crazing visible in glaze
Why — the visual evidence
This listing is a category error in the crawl — the photos show two ceramic vases and no table of any kind. Against the round-table brief it cannot be appraised as furniture. Judged honestly on its own terms: matching-pair 1980s Taiwanese swan vases are common retro décor; Brisbane op-shop/Marketplace trade puts such pairs at $15-40, so the $20 ask is roughly its retail. I set verdict 'insufficient-evidence' rather than 'fair' because no comparable in the supplied evidence files covers ceramics and I will not invent one; the $15-40 band is general second-hand trade reality, explicitly not sourced from the auction evidence.
Evidence notes
Driven by: photo 1 (pair of white swan vases, red beaks, scalloped tail mouths, one rim chip visible top-left), photo 3 (Made-in-Taiwan label). No table appears in any photo. Could NOT determine: maker, exact height, whether chip is on the display-facing rim edge.
NOT A TABLE — misclassified listing; no round-table value existsSeller text (chipped rim, crazing) matches pixelsNo comparable exists in the evidence corpus for 1980s Taiwanese ceramics — band is unsourced general trade, hence low confidence
Comparables used
No comparable sold/asking results — value rests on form/period judgement alone.
Verdict: Insufficient evidence. appraiser-child part3 (photo-first, indices 18-26)
Vintage African table mats
out of scope — not a round tableInsufficient evidenceconfidence: low
⇄
My fair market value
A$15–A$35 (pt A$25)
Out of scope: not furniture — no table included in sale — flagged by the appraiser; the keyword search also caught non-table items.
Identification
- Form
- pair of coiled-woven raffia/grass trays or shallow baskets photographed ON a round table covered in a creased vinyl tablecloth; the table is scenery, not the item for sale
- Period
- contemporary / late 20th c African coiled handicraft
- Timber
- n/a — plant fibre
- Marks
- none
- Construction features visible
- spiral-coiled sedge/raffia with dyed dark-brown geometric motifs; stitched construction
Why — the visual evidence
The seller's words say '100% cotton, hand crocheted mats', the pixels say otherwise: these are coiled woven (not crocheted) grass/raffia trays with natural-and-dark-brown spiral patterns, a classic African market-handicraft type. Photo 3 is only 225px and adds nothing. The round table under them has a wrinkled vinyl cover and is clearly not part of the sale. No textiles comparables exist in the evidence files; at $30 for two trays this is near normal retail for this craft type, so no bargain either way.
Evidence notes
Drove: fibre (not yarn), coil-and-stitch construction visible in photo 2, two items not four. Could NOT determine: exact count for sale (photos show 2, text claims 4), diameters, or condition of the unseen mats; third photo too small (225px) to judge.
not furniture — no table included in saleseller's 'crocheted cotton' contradicted by coiled raffia in pixelsphotos show 2 mats, listing says set of 4third image 225px, unusable
Comparables used
| Photo | Comparable | Price | AUD |
|---|
no img | (no comparables available) n/a | — | — |
Verdict: Insufficient evidence. Hermes dealer-appraiser child (photo-first), session 2026-09-21
Handcrafted solid Australian red cedar wood grazing boards $80 each
out of scope — not a round tableInsufficient evidenceconfidence: high
⇄
My fair market value
not valued
Out of scope: not a table at all — flagged by the appraiser; the keyword search also caught non-table items.
Identification
- Form
- NOT A TABLE — rectangular grazing/charcutery boards with chalkboard panels; plus a live-edge circular timber offcut
- Period
- contemporary, 2020s
- Timber
- oiled softwood palisade (hoop-pine look), NOT Queensland red cedar
- Marks
- none visible
- Construction features visible
- biscuit-joined end-grain palisade boards
- applied frame
- attached chalkboard slate
- olive-oil sheen
- live edge on offcut
Why — the visual evidence
Photo-first: every photo shows grazing boards, never a table — no legs, apron or top structure anywhere. The biscuit-joined end-grain palisade under oil, with orange sapwood banding, is softwood (hoop-pine style), contradicting the seller's 'solid Australian red cedar'. The one round object is a live-edge platter offcut. This listing is off-category for a round-table appraisal; the boards themselves are $40-80 homewares, but as a table its value is nil, so no value range is assigned.
Evidence notes
Drove the verdict: total absence of a table in 3 photos. Could not determine: exact species (needs macro end-grain), board dimensions. Seller text relied on only to note the contradiction.
not a table at allspecies claim contradicted by photos (softwood palisade, not red cedar)off-category for this survey
Comparables used
| Photo | Comparable | Price | AUD |
|---|
no img | Victorian Australian cedar round dining table 120cm dia — what a real cedar round clears at AU auction | 200 ≈A$200 | A$200 |
no img | Colonial NSW cedar Regency supper table c.1835, 124cm dia — top-end of genuine cedar rounds | 1800 ≈A$1,800 | A$1,800 |
no img | Victorian mahogany breakfast/centre table 117cm dia — the AU trade floor for anonymous rounds | 120 ≈A$120 | A$120 |
Verdict: Insufficient evidence. Hermes appraiser subagent (photo-first), 21 Sep 2026
Floor Rug Round
out of scope — not a round tableInsufficient evidenceconfidence: low
⇄
My fair market value
not valued
Out of scope: not a table at all — flagged by the appraiser; the keyword search also caught non-table items.
Identification
- Form
- not a table — round machine-made printed rug
- Period
- contemporary
- Timber
- n/a
- Marks
- n/a
- Construction features visible
- round low-pile machine-made rug, distressed 'boho' print (grey/teal/coral medallion)
Why — the visual evidence
All three photos show only a round printed floor rug on carpet — no table of any kind is offered. The title says 'Floor Rug Round'. It is in this result set by shape word only.
Evidence notes
The comparable library contains no rug rows, and appraising a rug is outside this report's scope; therefore no value figures are given rather than inventing any. Verdict: insufficient-evidence / out of scope for a round-table appraisal.
not a table at allno comparable evidence for rugs in the evidence filesout of scope — buyer list should exclude
Comparables used
No comparable sold/asking results — value rests on form/period judgement alone.
Verdict: Insufficient evidence. Hermes appraiser subagent (photo-first), 2026-09-21
4. Methodology & evidence
Photo-first appraisal. Each item was appraised from the listing photographs before the seller's description was read; the text was then tested against what the pixels actually show, and every contradiction (repainted surfaces, veneer sold as solid, reproductions sold as antique, wrong shapes) is recorded in the item's flags.
- Radius verification: every location text was checked and the straight-line distance to Ipswich QLD recomputed — all 35 listings sit within 10 km (range 0.4-9.76 km).
- Valuation anchoring: each value range is anchored to the comparables shown on the card (auction results and asking prices from the evidence library) and adjusted for condition, surface loss and resale friction visible in the photos.
- Evidence grading: confidence is high/medium/low according to what the photos could and could not show. Items whose photos are too small, irrelevant, or missing an underside were left at low confidence or an insufficient-evidence verdict; none were upgraded.
- Scope honesty: listings the appraisers identified as not round tables keep their own flagged reasons and are grouped separately (see the scope note).
5. What I could not verify
- Undersides and construction could not be inspected on any item — dovetails, dowels, screw blocks, and original vs replacement fittings are inferred from photos where visible, else not determined.
- Maker's marks and labels were legible on almost nothing; attributions stated as such are form/period judgements, not signed evidence.
- Board counts (single-board vs joined vs veneered- MDF cores) are visible on only a few tops; where stated they are photo reads, not inspections.
- Some photos were too small or irrelevant (225-443 px thumbnails, meme shots, staged renders) — those items are held at low confidence or insufficient-evidence.
- Prices are desktop estimates for the Brisbane/Ipswich second-hand trade in the observed condition; they are opinions, not guarantees of sale, and exclude delivery, restoration and sale costs.
- No item was physically inspected; no test for wobble, joint looseness or mechanism function was possible.
6. Comparables library & sources
| Photo | Comparable | Price | AUD |
|---|
 | Georgian English pad-foot tilt-top tea table, 71cm H x 71cm dia | 380 ≈A$380 | A$380 |
 | George III mahogany circular tilt-top occasional table, 75cm dia, passed at est 300-500 | est 300-500 ≈— | — |
 | William IV rosewood circular breakfast table, 138cm dia | 1200 ≈A$1,200 | A$1,200 |
 | Rustic Australian cedar centre/side/wine table, tripod, carved legs, c.1880 | 750 ≈A$750 | A$750 |
 | Australian cedar tilt-top round dining, c.1840, 132cm dia, SOLD | 4495 ≈A$4,495 | A$4,495 |
 | Early Australian cedar round dining, 120cm dia, restored | 550 ≈A$550 | A$550 |
 | George II mahogany tripod tilt-top tea table c.1740, birdcage, 86cm dia | 600 ≈A$1,200 | A$1,200 |
 | 19th-c mahogany tilt-top tea table, tripod | est 300-500 ≈— | — |
 | George IV mahogany three-pedestal dining table, Hyde Park provenance | 8500 ≈A$12,900 | A$12,900 |
 | Victorian rosewood Sutherland table | 129 ≈A$260 | A$260 |
 | Victorian mahogany Sutherland, 73x86cm | 30 ≈A$60 | A$60 |
 | Victorian mahogany double-gate Sutherland, 121cm extended | 70 ≈A$140 | A$140 |
 | Victorian figured walnut Sutherland table (dup) | 250 ≈A$215 | A$215 |
 | George III mahogany Hepplewhite card table | 1035 ≈A$1,580 | A$1,580 |
 | Oak gateleg table, 17th-c style, chip-carved, 140cm | 60 ≈A$120 | A$120 |
 | Victorian Australian cedar dining table, 75H x 120 DIA | 200 ≈A$200 | A$200 |
 | Continental marquetry card table, 73cm wide | 75 ≈A$150 | A$150 |
 | 1970s teak low side table by Parker, 43cm H x 76 dia | 120 ≈A$120 | A$120 |
 | 1960s Australian glass-topped hardwood circular table, 53H x 145 dia (passed, est 400-600) | est 400-600 ≈— | — |
 | Charles & Ray Eames for Herman Miller circular table, 71H x 140 dia | 480 ≈A$480 | A$480 |
 | Victorian mahogany breakfast/centre table (a/f), 73H x 117 dia | 120 ≈A$120 | A$120 |
 | Victorian rosewood Sutherland, 104x106x71cm | 240 ≈A$475 | A$475 |
 | Rare Philadelphia William & Mary walnut gateleg, ca.1700, Schiffer provenance | 12000 ≈A$18,200 | A$18,200 |
 | Irish Georgian mahogany flip-top table, bulbous pillar, 80cm dia | est 150-250 ≈— | — |
 | Round mahogany side table, embossed leather top (list $1,450, now $1,250) | 1250 ≈A$1,755 | A$1,755 |
 | Baker Furniture Georgian carved mahogany tilt-top pedestal tea table, 1980s (sale from $2,595) | 1435 ≈A$2,015 | A$2,015 |
 | Baker Furniture Georgian banded mahogany pedestal tea/centre table, USA 1980s | 2595 ≈A$3,645 | A$3,645 |
 | Vintage Ethan Allen mahogany round pedestal table, starburst inlay + drawer, 1980s, 38in | 799 ≈A$1,122 | A$1,122 |
 | 19th c continental walnut centre table (a/f), 80H x 130 | 240 ≈A$240 | A$240 |
 | Victorian figured mahogany centre table, c.1850 | 1650 ≈A$1,650 | A$1,650 |
 | Parker teak round extendable dining, 1970s, refinished | 1290 ≈A$1,290 | A$1,290 |
 | Chiswell teak wine-bar storage side table | 790 ≈A$790 | A$790 |
 | Australian Art Deco circular occasional table, silky oak, QLD c.1930, 50cm H x 55cm dia [hammer price behind Carter's subscription wall; image is the sold-lot photo] | — | — |
 | Antique turned silky oak pedestal table, Queensland, early 20th C [hammer price behind Carter's subscription wall; image is the sold-lot photo] | — | — |
 | Silky oak side table with carved legs, 72 x 40 x 42 cm, Albion Antique Auction Centre | est 10-40 ≈A$25 | A$25 |
 | Rustic French Provincial tilt-top wine tasting table, 19th C, 40in dia, sold $425 +BP | 425 ≈A$645 | A$645 |
 | Mahogany tilt-top tea/card table attributed John Goddard Newport c.1765, realized $22,800 | 22800 ≈A$34,500 | A$34,500 |
 | Vintage Regency-style leather-top round drum table with drawers (Bazaa Sydney) | 702 ≈A$702 | A$702 |
 | Anglo-Indian rosewood elephant-leg tripod circular table, 60cm dia, 19th C [hammer price behind Carter's subscription wall; image is the sold-lot photo] | — | — |
 | Victorian rosewood round loo/breakfast table, 1870, 135cm dia (Camden Antiques via Chairish) | 1896 ≈A$2,900 | A$2,900 |
 | Round rosewood-veneered pedestal table, 19th C, 128cm dia (Il Ponte, Italy) | 800 ≈A$1,350 | A$1,350 |
 | 1stDibs drum table category leather-top round drum | 135 ≈A$210 | A$210 |
Sources
- Vickhoad, Bowral, lot 1035
- Vickhoad lot 1006
- Vickhoad lot 1038
- Moonee Ponds Antiques (Melbourne)
- Antiques & Collectables (South Perth)
- Marlborough Antiques
- Sworders, Fine Interiors lot 434
- Bonhams (Skinner) lot 400
- Brunk Auctions
- Bonhams County Sale lot 17
- Denhams lot 1054
- Denhams lot 921
- Cordys Auckland lot 0585
- Case Antiques lot 306
- Sworders timed sale
- Leonard Joel lot 1097
- EasyLiveAuction two-day sale lot 1023 (19 Dec 2024)
- Leonard Joel lot 1217 (13 Feb 2025)
- Leonard Joel lot 1201
- Leonard Joel lot 1129 (13 Nov 2025)
- Bonhams London lot 30 (9 Mar 2010)
- Pook & Pook (Apr 2026) via Bidsquare
- Fonsie Mealy lot 1145 (Chatsworth sale)
- 1stDibs
- Chairish
- Chairish
- Chairish
- Bazaa (Melbourne)
- Retro Bay (Sydney)
- Retro Bay (Sydney)
- Carter's, Melbourne (subscriber price band; sold)
- Carter's, Melbourne (sold price behind subscription; est)
- Invaluable / Albion Antique Auction Centre, QLD
- Austin Auction Gallery, TX (Oct 2025)
- Nadeau's Auction Gallery
- Bazaa, Sydney
- Carter's, Melbourne (sold; subscriber price)
- Chairish
- Invaluable / Il Ponte Casa d'Aste
- 1stDibs