Condition & Valuation Report — Desktop Study

Round & Dining Tables — Ipswich Marketplace Appraisal

22 September 2026 · 129 harvested · 72 visually screened · 52 appraised (1 BUY / 31 CONSIDER / 20 PASS) · 60 screened-not-appraised · Ipswich & West Brisbane, SEQ QLD, 20 km radius.
129 listings harvested, 72 visually screened, 52 fully appraised against 103 comparables Every appraisal was made photo-first: the identification and valuation rest on the listing photographs alone. Data compiled 2026-09-22T00:46:03Z (UTC).

The Verdict

52 listings were appraised in depth: 1 BUY, 31 CONSIDER, 20 PASS.

The BUY list — where the photographs support a value clearly above the ask:

  • Antique dining room table — [price: search card A$150 vs detail page A$14,000 — card price used; $14,000 figure treated as the known scrape artefact and never adopted] — The best photos in this batch, and the only real candidate. What the pictures show: an oval-topped extension table on genuine cabriole legs with pad feet and a thin moulded apron, light satin walnut/hardwood tone, stored in a shed WITH its two loose inserts stacked on the top — the seller's 'two timber inserts' claim is visible, unlike 89. The crank/windlass mechanism itself is not shown working, but the form (cabriole + windlass + inserts) is the classic interwar extension design, and this finish reads a careful old polish or a sympathetic light refinish rather than a botch. At the card price of $150 this is worth a phone call before anyone else's; note the detail page shows A$14,000 — treat as scrape artefact and transact at the card price. (A$500)

Key Numbers

129
listings harvested
72
listings visually screened
52
listings fully appraised
103
comparables rows in evidence
68
comparable evidence images used
1
BUY verdicts
A$800
largest estimated upside

The Listings (52)

#001 4 chair round table

A$200
Brisbane, QLD · Listed a week ago in Brisbane, QLD · View listing

Modern light-timber round 4-seater with knock-down legs and 4 black moulded chairs; scuffed top, pen marks admitted. Ordinary flat-pack-grade furniture at an ordinary price — ask sits above realistic value.

PASSroundmedium
4 chair round table photo4 chair round table photo4 chair round table photo

Identification & condition

Form
round
Maker or style
unbranded modern round dining set (IKEA/Fantastic-class knock-down)
Material
light timber-look top (bamboo-look slat pattern or pale oak veneer) over engineered core; black plastic/leatherette chairs
Period
2010s-2020s
Construction
Photo 001-03 shows a thin top with a simple eased edge and surface scuffs/dings; seller says top and legs come apart (bolted/knock-down fittings, no mortise-and-tenon visible). No antique joinery anywhere in the photos.
Dimensions (est.)
round top ~90-100 cm, 4-seat class, ~75 cm high
Condition grade
fair

Visible in photos: Top close-up shows multiple scuffs/dings and marks in the finish (pen marks per seller, consistent with what is visible); chairs look intact; nothing structural wrong visible.

Can't see from these photos: underside and leg attachment hardware / whether top is solid timber, veneer or laminate at a chip point / stability once assembled / chair seat integrity under load

Photo limits: Underside and leg fixings, core material at any edge chip, and assembled stability are not shown; but enough is visible to be sure this is modern flat-pack furniture, not vintage.

Appraisal confidence: medium

Ask versus value

Estimated value: A$120 – A$220 (mid A$160) · refs ds-022 / ds-021

Basis: Modern flat-pack round 4-seaters with chairs clear far below the ask on local marketplace comps; scuffed top discounts further.

Ask A$200 → upside A$−40 (value mid − ask)

If resold: private net A$130 · auction net A$85 · retail asking A$240

Adjustments
  • marketplace-asking comps taken at x0.85-0.9 to clear (method 3.3)
  • C_cond 0.75 for scuffs/pen marks and knock-down wear
  • C_channel 1.0 (already local private sale)
Verdict: PASS · upside A$−40 vs the A$200 ask · confidence medium
Comparable evidence
no image
ds-022 · Gumtree Australia · A$150
'Ashton' round 4-seater marketplace ask $150 — near-identical market segment; clears ~$130 after ask-discount
no image
ds-021 · Gumtree Australia · A$80
round table + 2 chairs sold at $80 — sets the floor for unbranded round sets with chairs

#003 Dining table

A$150
Brisbane, QLD · Listed Sep 2026 in QLD · View listing

1990s deep-red gloss 'cherry' laminate-look oval table on a crossed-panel base with 4 white Tolix-look metal chairs; one photo shows a different (light-timber) table, so the set photographed is ambiguous. Modern mass-market, value at or below the ask.

PASSovallow
Dining table photoDining table photoDining table photo

Identification & condition

Form
oval
Maker or style
unbranded 1990s high-gloss 'cherry' dining table; Tolix-clone metal chairs
Material
glossy red-brown laminate/veneer top over panel core (mirror-like sheen with no board joints); painted metal chairs
Period
1990s-2000s
Construction
Photo 003-02 shows the high-gloss top reflecting vertical blinds (laminate sheen, not lacquered timber), and a crossed plywood-panel base in matching red; chairs are pressed-sheet metal with welded tube frames.
Dimensions (est.)
~120-140 x 80-90 cm oval, 4-seat, ~74 cm high
Condition grade
fair

Visible in photos: Top looks unscratched under indoor light; chairs show used condition/chips consistent with the seller's own description.

Can't see from these photos: underside/core of top / base joint integrity / photo 003-03 shows a light-timber table that may be a different piece — what exactly is included in the sale / edge condition at close range

Photo limits: The photos are internally inconsistent (two different-looking tables across panels 003-02 and 003-03) and the underside is never shown, so material and even the true subject of the listing can't be pinned down — this inconsistency alone kills any buy case.

Appraisal confidence: low

Ask versus value

Estimated value: A$90 – A$180 (mid A$140) · refs ds-022 / ds-021

Basis: Ordinary modern gloss-laminate table + used metal chairs sits in the flat-pack clearing band; ask equals value.

Ask A$150 → upside A$−10 (value mid − ask)

If resold: private net A$115 · auction net A$75 · retail asking A$200

Adjustments
  • asking comps x0.85-0.9 to clearing (method 3.3)
  • no antique/designer uplift: laminate top + panel base = ordinary tier
  • C_complete 1.0 but chairs are the commodity kind
Verdict: PASS · upside A$−10 vs the A$150 ask · confidence low
Comparable evidence
no image
ds-022 · Gumtree Australia · A$150
modern round 4-seater marketplace ask $150 — same unbranded modern tier
no image
ds-021 · Gumtree Australia · A$80
table + chairs sold $80 — floor for mixed unbranded sets

#007 Dining table

A$80
Brisbane, QLD · Just listed · View listing

Big 8-seater rectangular table in honey/reddish mid-timber with chunky straight legs and a thick polyurethane gloss; photos show solid-looking board construction and a rounded solid edge, but with blotchy filler repairs and water-worn zones. Genuinely useful size at a near-free ask — the best of this batch, though its margin misses the BUY rule.

CONSIDERrectangularmedium
Dining table photoDining table photoDining table photo

Identification & condition

Form
rectangular
Maker or style
1980s-90s Australian solid-timber farmhouse-style dining table (hoop pine / hardwood class)
Material
solid timber boards (wide-board figure, continuous grain over a rounded solid edge-lipping, no edge-band line); heavy gloss poly finish
Period
c. 1985-2000
Construction
Top photographed flat on a garage floor shows plank-board figure with several darker filled/repair patches and dull water-worn areas under the gloss; legs are thick square-section with splayed feet; no veneer edge-band visible at the measured edge.
Dimensions (est.)
tape in photos: length ~1.8-2.1 m, width ~70-75 cm, ~75 cm high — true 8-seater
Condition grade
fair

Visible in photos: Filler/repair patches and water-worn dull zones on the top; gloss build uneven; structure and legs look sound in the shots shown.

Can't see from these photos: apron and leg joinery (underside never photographed) / wobble/racking once assembled / whether the top is solid through its thickness or veneer over a board core / full extent of finish failure

Photo limits: Underside joinery and assembled stability are unphotographed; timber species unconfirmed. Net at the BUY rule (0.95 x 180 − 80 = $91) falls short of the max(0.3V, $150) margin, so CONSIDER, not BUY — worth a re-inspection only.

Appraisal confidence: medium

Adversarial review · agree · arithmetic: sound · recomputed margin: A$75 · comp support: strong · ask integrity: ok (audit live price = adopted ask) · biggest downside: Genuine Ercol-family but refinished; resale may sit at 120 not 180 — CONSIDER only, no money at risk, $0 if wrong · · cost if wrong A$0 ·

Arithmetic ok (155-80=75 < max(0.3*180,150)=150 so correctly NOT a BUY). mc-023 is a real UK hammer $102.5 teak drop-leaf, probative for the band.

Ask versus value

Estimated value: A$130 – A$250 (mid A$180) · refs mc-023 / aus-024

Basis: Solid-timber 8-seater in need of finish work anchors to the low end of local solid-wood table comps after condition and size discounts.

Ask A$80 → upside A$100 (value mid − ask)

If resold: private net A$155 · auction net A$100 · retail asking A$300

Adjustments
  • C_cond 0.75 (visible repairs/water marks; a strip-and-repoly would cost $250-500 — more than V, so value stays at as-is level)
  • C_size 0.9 (>=140 cm 8-seaters shift slowly)
  • eBay ask x0.85-0.9 to clearing
Verdict: CONSIDER · upside A$100 vs the A$80 ask · confidence medium
Comparable evidence
no image
mc-023 · Arthur Johnson & Sons (UK, easyliveauction) · A$102
teak drop-leaf table hammer $102.50 — the realistic clearing price for a used solid-wood table needing work
no image
aus-024 · eBay Australia · A$210
colonial cedar table eBay ask $210.49 — an ask-side ceiling for solid domestic tables, discounted for venue

#018 Large VINTAGE Timber Table

A$150
Brisbane, QLD · Listed Sep 2026 in QLD · View listing

The listing photos are dealer marketing images — a styled room shot and black-background product cutouts of a sage-green painted serpentine-trestle 'shabby chic' refectory table with dark-stained top and biscuit toggles — not photos of a real item in a real home. Nothing here supports 'vintage'; the design is a 1990s-2000s reproduction form, and the top edge shows a light bamboo-tone lipping over a flat panel.

CONSIDERrectangularlow
Large VINTAGE Timber Table photoLarge VINTAGE Timber Table photoLarge VINTAGE Timber Table photo

Identification & condition

Form
rectangular
Maker or style
'shabby chic'/French-farmhouse reproduction refectory table (import decor line)
Material
sage-green painted base, dark-stained top that reads as veneer/MDF panel with contrasting edge-lipping
Period
reproduction, c. 1995-2015; the 'vintage' claim is unsupported
Construction
Panel 018-02 shows S-scroll cut trestle ends, a flat stretcher, and turned biscuit toggles; panel 018-03 (leaning top, possibly the only real photo) shows a featureless flat back and a light-coloured edge band — no board cupping, no old tool marks anywhere.
Dimensions (est.)
seller-stated 1825 x 905 x 760 mm (not independently verifiable from photos)
Condition grade
unknown

Visible in photos: Only marketing renders/styled photos are supplied; paint finish looks flawless because the images are not of the actual item. No honest read of condition is possible.

Can't see from these photos: the actual item at all / joinery, underside, hardware / paint quality and damage on the real piece / whether the seller possesses the photographed table

Photo limits: Everything that matters — the actual item. The listing uses dealer marketing imagery (styled room + cut-out product shots), so material, age and condition are unverifiable; the 'vintage' claim is not merely unsupported but contradicted by the reproduction styling shown.

Appraisal confidence: low

Ask versus value

Estimated value: A$150 – A$300 (mid A$220) · refs aus-024 / sp-023

Basis: Painted reproduction refectory tables retail new overseas at USD 1,000+ (oliveateliersshop.shop refectory listing, USD 978-2,795) but with the 0.55-0.7 local channel discount and zero originality, the local private band is modest.

Ask A$150 → upside A$70 (value mid − ask)

If resold: private net A$180 · auction net A$110 · retail asking A$380

Adjustments
  • C_orig 0.55 (painted-over, reproduction, decor-grade)
  • international retail discounted x0.55-0.7 per method 3.2 C_channel
  • stock-photo listing penalises resale confidence (buyers discount unseen pieces)
Verdict: CONSIDER · upside A$70 vs the A$150 ask · confidence low
Comparable evidence
no image
aus-024 · eBay Australia · A$210
genuine colonial cedar table eBay ask $210.49 — a real antique clearing barely above this reproduction's ask
no image
sp-023 · Antiques Plus / Antiques Design Online (Carrum Downs VIC) · A$365
Edwardian oak tiled-top table retail ask $365 — painted/renovated period-look tables cap near there locally

#020 Retro table

A$80
Brisbane, QLD · Listed Sep 2026 in QLD · View listing

Genuine 1960s-70s laminate dining table: oval top with the era's cream/beige marbled 'formica', rounded bullnose edge over a light substrate edge, slim dark legs. Charming and cheap, but it is coated chipboard, not timber, so the retro look alone does not beat the BUY margin.

CONSIDERovalmedium
Retro table photoRetro table photoRetro table photo

Identification & condition

Form
oval
Maker or style
unbranded Australian 1960s-70s laminate dining table ('marbled' retro formica class)
Material
marbled cream/gold HPL laminate over chipboard/MDF core; slim timber or metal legs
Period
c. 1965-1978
Construction
Photos show a continuous printed marble swirl under high gloss and a rounded rolled edge where the laminate wraps; the exposed edge in 020-03 reads light-coloured substrate; legs are plain tapered/dowel type, no visible era joinery.
Dimensions (est.)
~120-130 x 75-80 cm oval, ~73 cm high
Condition grade
good

Visible in photos: Laminate surface looks intact and glossy in the photos; no chips at the visible edges; legs look sound.

Can't see from these photos: underside (core material, leg fixings, possible warp) / edge chips at close range / leg thread/bracket wear

Photo limits: Underside and leg fixings; warp can't be ruled out from top-only photos. Net at the BUY rule (0.95 x 150 − 80 = $63) is well under the $150 minimum margin.

Appraisal confidence: medium

Ask versus value

Estimated value: A$100 – A$200 (mid A$150) · refs sp-018 / mc-023

Basis: Retro laminate tables trade on style, not material — anchored between used solid-wood hammer prices and vintage-look marketplace asks.

Ask A$80 → upside A$70 (value mid − ask)

If resold: private net A$125 · auction net A$80 · retail asking A$260

Adjustments
  • sp-018 ask discounted x0.85-0.9 then x0.5 (it is stone-look premium over plain HPL)
  • C_depth 0.85 (non-extending, narrow buyer pool)
  • no material premium: laminate over chipboard
Verdict: CONSIDER · upside A$70 vs the A$80 ask · confidence medium
Comparable evidence
no image
sp-018 · eBay Australia listings (search snapshot) · A$450
vintage 70s/80s 'travertine marble' look table marketplace ask $450 — shows the retro-pattern ceiling, tempered by venue discount
no image
mc-023 · Arthur Johnson & Sons (UK, easyliveauction) · A$102
teak drop-leaf hammer $102.50 — floor for genuinely retro but non-designer dining tables

#022 Solid Timber Dinning Table and 6 Chairs

A$400
Brisbane, QLD · Listed Sep 2026 in QLD · View listing

The 'solid oak' claim survives the photo test at plank level: golden-honey timber, visible butt-joints between boards, square solid edges, moulded apron and chunky turned/tapered legs, with a matching 6-chair set in light microfiber. But it is a 1990s matching set with a long scratch/finish-wear zone on the top, and $500 is full clearing price — no room under the BUY rule.

CONSIDERrectangularmedium
Solid Timber Dinning Table and 6 Chairs photoSolid Timber Dinning Table and 6 Chairs photoSolid Timber Dinning Table and 6 Chairs photoSolid Timber Dinning Table and 6 Chairs photoSolid Timber Dinning Table and 6 Chairs photoSolid Timber Dinning Table and 6 Chairs photo

Identification & condition

Form
rectangular
Maker or style
unmarked Australian 1990s solid-oak refectory-style table with matching chairs
Material
solid oak (board butt-joints and grain running over the edge support this); light microfiber/fabric chair upholstery
Period
c. 1990-2005
Construction
Tape-measure photos read ~149-180 cm down the top with plank seams across it (leaf seam possible); apron has a moulded profile; legs chunky turned/tapered; edges square and solid-reading, not edge-banded laminate.
Dimensions (est.)
~180 x 90-95 cm top, 76 cm high; 6 chairs
Condition grade
good

Visible in photos: A long pale scratch/finish-wear zone on the right third of the top and small white flecks; otherwise satin finish intact; chairs look used but sound.

Can't see from these photos: underside, drawbore or peg joinery / maker's brand/label / leaf/extension mechanism if present / chair frame joints and webbing

Photo limits: Underside joinery, possible maker label, and the chair frames. Value mid equals the ask; even haggle-to-own nets nothing against the $150 minimum margin. Only interesting if the seller drops to ~$350.

Appraisal confidence: medium

Ask versus value

Estimated value: A$400 – A$600 (mid A$500) · refs sp-028 / mc-014

Basis: Local solid-wood 6-chair suites clear around the mid-$400s-$500s privately; this is a clean, genuinely solid example minus designer cachet.

Ask A$400 → upside A$100 (value mid − ask)

If resold: private net A$450 · auction net A$300 · retail asking A$750

Adjustments
  • sp-028 retail ask x0.6 (dealer-to-private channel)
  • C_cond 0.9 (one long scratch zone, minor flecks)
  • no maker premium: unbranded 1990s
Verdict: CONSIDER · upside A$100 vs the A$400 ask · confidence medium
Comparable evidence
comparable sp-028
sp-028 · Nord Modern (Brunswick, Melbourne vintage dealer) · A$850
Queensland walnut extension table retail ask $850 — dealer-asking ceiling for quality QLD solid suites; private clears well under
comparable mc-014
mc-014 · Anderson & Garland (UK) · A$574
Nathan teak dining suite auction result $574 — hammer benchmark for a real named 6-piece suite; this set is unbranded, so below it

#024 Dining Table and Chairs

A$200
Brisbane, QLD · Listed Sep 2026 in QLD · View listing

1990s dark-walnut-stain extending set: slab-leg table with centre seam and an apron drawer that houses the leaf, top shows a printed/veneer grain with plank-line pattern and an edge-band line (not clearly solid), and the 6 cream microfiber high-backs are heavily grey-soiled as the seller admits. Dated style, tired chairs, ask near value.

PASSsquaremedium
Dining Table and Chairs photoDining Table and Chairs photoDining Table and Chairs photoDining Table and Chairs photoDining Table and Chairs photoDining Table and Chairs photo

Identification & condition

Form
square
Maker or style
unbranded 1990s 'American style' extending dining suite (walnut-stain table, suede-fabric high-backs)
Material
walnut-stained top — veneer/laminate with printed plank lines and edge banding over a panel core (solid timber not demonstrated); cream microfiber/suede chairs on timber frames
Period
c. 1990-2005
Construction
024-03 shows a centre seam with a small drawer/handle box in the apron = hidden-centre-leaf mechanism; edges show a distinct band line; 024-01 shows plain slab/panel legs; chair backs in 024-05 show large grey staining patches.
Dimensions (est.)
seller-stated 139 x 139 cm square (extended); 76 cm high; 6 chairs
Condition grade
fair

Visible in photos: Chair upholstery visibly soiled/grey-stained in broad patches; top has surface scratches and swirl in the sheen (024-03/04); mechanism present but untested in photos.

Can't see from these photos: underside and core at any chip / whether the leaf is present and the runner works / chair frame joint condition / effectiveness of any upholstery clean

Photo limits: Leaf presence/mechanism, top core, chair frames. Even crediting the full set, net (0.95 x 220 − 200 = $9) is nowhere near the margin rule; the chairs need work the price doesn't leave room for.

Appraisal confidence: medium

Ask versus value

Estimated value: A$150 – A$300 (mid A$220) · refs sp-012 / ds-023

Basis: Complete matching 90s suites with soiled fabric clear just over the table-alone comps; cleaning cost and dated style cap it.

Ask A$200 → upside A$20 (value mid − ask)

If resold: private net A$185 · auction net A$120 · retail asking A$320

Adjustments
  • ds-023 ask x0.85-0.9 (method 3.3), x0.7 for 1990s vs current look
  • C_complete 1.0 (6 chairs + leaf) offset by C_cond 0.75 (soiled upholstery, scratched top; clean + top refresh ~$100-200)
  • square 139 cm = 6-8 seats, workable size (C_size 1.0)
Verdict: PASS · upside A$20 vs the A$200 ask · confidence medium
Comparable evidence
comparable sp-012
sp-012 · MM Furniture (Sunshine Coast QLD dealer) · A$300
cane honeymoon table+chairs set sold $300 — benchmark for a complete unbranded matching suite
no image
ds-023 · Gumtree Australia (PriceWorth Rocklea) · A$399
walnut-veneer round table ask $399 (table alone) — veneer-tier pricing ceiling; discounted for venue and the needing-clean chairs here

#025 Dining table ( No chairs)

A$150
Brisbane, QLD · — · View listing

Staged photos of a current Japandi slat-cone round table; near-new mass-market piece asking near its used value, so no dealer margin.

CONSIDERroundmedium
Dining table ( No chairs) photoDining table ( No chairs) photoDining table ( No chairs) photo

Identification & condition

Form
round
Maker or style
Contemporary Japandi 'wabi-sabi' round pedestal, slatted conical drum base (unbranded retail, Amazon/Fantastic-class)
Material
Light-oak-tone printed/foil or veneered top over engineered core; slat base in solid or finger-jointed timber with clear coat
Period
c. 2022-2026
Construction
Rounded bullnose top edge, repeating cathedral grain (printed-repeat pattern, not boards); cone of vertical slats as column; no mouldings, no hardware shown
Dimensions (est.)
~90 cm dia, ~74 cm H (tape measures in photos suggest ~90 across)
Condition grade
good

Visible in photos: Near-new: no visible rings, scratches or dents in the 3 shots; styled room-set with non-matching boucle chairs and a tape measure draped over the top.

Can't see from these photos: underside and fixings / edge banding detail at close range / brand label or receipt / true dimensions (tape partly obscured)

Photo limits: Underside, actual edge construction and any label are not shown; tape measures in the photos are partially obscured so dimensions are estimated. The staging (styled room, matching props) hints at a reseller, which usually means the ask holds.

Appraisal confidence: medium

Ask versus value

Estimated value: A$120 – A$250 (mid A$170) · refs ds-022 / ds-021 / ds-024

Basis: Modern mass-market round on local asking comps; these clear at or under ask in SEQ private sales.

Ask A$150 → upside A$20 (value mid − ask)

If resold: private net A$150 · auction net A$60 · retail asking A$320

Adjustments
  • ×0.85-0.9 on marketplace asking comps per method §3.3 (asks clear below sticker)
  • No antique/designer credit: printed-repeat grain and staged shots say retail-new, not vintage
Verdict: CONSIDER · upside A$20 vs the A$150 ask · confidence medium
Comparable evidence
no image
ds-022 · Gumtree Australia · A$150
'Ashton' 4-seater black round, Southport QLD, ask A$150 — same retail class and same asking level
no image
ds-021 · Gumtree Australia · A$80
Fantastic Furniture round + 2 chairs, QLD, ask A$80 — sets the floor for this tier
no image
ds-024 · Amazon Australia · A$162
Round glass-top set sold A$161.60 — what comparable new-looking rounds actually achieve

#026 6 seater wooden dining table no chairs

A$50
Brisbane, QLD · Listed Just listed in Brisbane, QLD · View listing

Vintage trestle drop-leaf, orange-poly refinish; real but common, and $50 ask still leaves less than our $150 minimum margin.

CONSIDERovalmedium
6 seater wooden dining table no chairs photo6 seater wooden dining table no chairs photo

Identification & condition

Form
oval
Maker or style
20th-c Australian trestle drop-leaf ('Sutherland style') — turned trestle posts with splayed cleat feet
Material
Appears solid softwood/hardwood with orange-toned polyurethane (refinished or 1970s varnish); rounded moulded edges
Period
mid-20th century copy of an antique form
Construction
Single-centre trestle with turned stretcher; hinged wings fold down; top view shows seams at leaf lines
Dimensions (est.)
wings down reads oval ~110-120 × 90; open likely ~150-170 × 90-100 (not measured)
Condition grade
fair

Visible in photos: Even orange gloss consistent with a full refinish; no major damage visible in the 2 photos; feet and mouldings intact as far as shown.

Can't see from these photos: underside, hinges and leaf supports / whether both leaves/wings are present and work / water damage inside the leaf seams / exact size

Photo limits: Two photos only; the underside, leaf mechanism and hinge condition are invisible, and we cannot confirm the piece seats six with leaves in place. Identification of form is clear but any hidden rot or missing leaf support would halve the value.

Appraisal confidence: medium

Ask versus value

Estimated value: A$100 – A$250 (mid A$160) · refs aus-019 / aus-014

Basis: Anchor to a sold antique Sutherland heavily discounted for being a common reproduction in refinished condition.

Ask A$50 → upside A$110 (value mid − ask)

If resold: private net A$150 · auction net A$70 · retail asking A$300

Adjustments
  • ×0.55 originality (orange-poly refinish, reproduction form)
  • ×0.85 regional private channel
  • bulk: needs a van and two people; subtract handling effort
Verdict: CONSIDER · upside A$110 vs the A$50 ask · confidence medium
Comparable evidence
no image
aus-019 · South Perth Antiques & Collectables · A$995
Victorian burr walnut Sutherland sold A$995 — genuine antique benchmark; ours is a later copy, refinished
no image
aus-014 · Bonhams Australia (Colonial Sale, Sydney) · A$1,037
Cedar/blackwood kitchen table A$1,037 shows even real colonial workhorses are low; ours is a fraction of that

#028 6 seater dining table

A$250
Brisbane, QLD · — · View listing

Seller's own screenshots identify it exactly: furniture.com.au 'Bridge' oak-look flat-pack, bought new ~A$329 five months ago; ask is above used value.

PASSrectangularhigh
6 seater dining table photo6 seater dining table photo6 seater dining table photo6 seater dining table photo6 seater dining table photo

Identification & condition

Form
rectangular
Maker or style
furniture.com.au 'Bridge 6 Seater Oak Rectangle Dining Table' (identified from the seller's own product-page screenshot in photo 5)
Material
Oak-tone melamine/laminate wood-grain print top with edge banding; black powder-coated square-section steel frame
Period
Modern flat-pack, purchased c. 2026
Construction
~2 cm thin top with sharp banded edge; repetitive printed grain, satin sheen; trapezoid/U-channel steel end frames; bolts down for transport
Dimensions (est.)
~180 × 90 × 74 cm (6-seater standard)
Condition grade
excellent

Visible in photos: Near-new: claimed wiped daily, no marks or dents; photos show clean surface and frame; one photo is literally a phone screenshot of the listing and another the retailer product page at $329 (RRP ~$429).

Can't see from these photos: hairline scratches at close range / frame welds/feet underside

Photo limits: Nothing material is missing — the seller's product screenshot nails the identity. The only unknown is undisclosed surface damage not visible at photo resolution.

Appraisal confidence: high

Ask versus value

Estimated value: A$100 – A$200 (mid A$150) · refs ds-021 / ds-022

Basis: Flat-pack band of the method: used value of a sub-A$350 melamine table bought months ago.

Ask A$250 → upside A$−100 (value mid − ask)

If resold: private net A$140 · auction net A$40 · retail asking A$220

Adjustments
  • retail $329 fresh → used flat-pack loses 40-55% immediately
  • ×0.85 asking haircut: expect to clear ~A$130-160
Verdict: PASS · upside A$−100 vs the A$250 ask · confidence high
Comparable evidence
no image
ds-021 · Gumtree Australia · A$80
Fantastic Furniture round, QLD ask A$80 — same discount-tier flat-pack class
no image
ds-022 · Gumtree Australia · A$150
'Ashton' round ask A$150 — the level comparable new-but-used flat-packs are asking, before the ask haircut

#029 COLONIAL CEDAR EXTENSION DINING TABLE, 2X LEAF D ends

A$400
Brisbane, QLD · — · View listing

Victorian-style bulb-turned extension on bun feet; cedar/colonial-original claim NOT supported by photos, claimed Victorian; photos show the style, the refinish obscures patina evidence. Condition good: Six photos: bulb turning on bun feet, high-gloss poly over dark stain, two stored D-leaves a shade off from the top; no underside, no windlass, no label ever photographed Style-correct bulb-turned extension at the A$400 corrected ask: private net A$660 beats ask by A$260, past the A$100/25% margin, even with authenticity unproven Form recorded on the card as square (rectangular with both D-leaves fitted); classified square per SCHEMA enum.

CONSIDERsquarelow
COLONIAL CEDAR EXTENSION DINING TABLE, 2X LEAF D ends photoCOLONIAL CEDAR EXTENSION DINING TABLE, 2X LEAF D ends photoCOLONIAL CEDAR EXTENSION DINING TABLE, 2X LEAF D ends photoCOLONIAL CEDAR EXTENSION DINING TABLE, 2X LEAF D ends photoCOLONIAL CEDAR EXTENSION DINING TABLE, 2X LEAF D ends photoCOLONIAL CEDAR EXTENSION DINING TABLE, 2X LEAF D ends photo

Identification & condition

Form
square
Maker or style
Victorian-style bulb-turned extension on bun feet; cedar/colonial-original claim NOT supported by photos
Material
dark-stained hardwood (claimed cedar, unproven); uniform high-gloss poly refinish
Period
claimed Victorian; photos show the style, the refinish obscures patina evidence
Construction
bulb-turned legs, bun feet, two loose 400 mm D-leaves with colour drift from main top
Dimensions (est.)
0.90 x 1.20 m closed, 1.20 x 2.00 m with both leaves (listed)
Condition grade
good

Visible in photos: Six photos: bulb turning on bun feet, high-gloss poly over dark stain, two stored D-leaves a shade off from the top; no underside, no windlass, no label ever photographed

Can't see from these photos: s / p / e / c / i / e / s / , / / u / n / d / e / r / s / i / d / e / , / / w / i / n / d / l / a / s / s / , / / m / a / k / e / r / / l / a / b / e / l

Photo limits: ['species (cedar claim)', 'underside construction', 'windlass/iron', 'maker label', 'leaf fit when installed']

Appraisal confidence: low

Adversarial review · DISSENT · arithmetic: sound · recomputed margin: A$260 · comp support: weak · ask integrity: ok (audit: live A$400; A$14,000 detail value is the known scrape artefact) · biggest downside: Stained-softwood repro (vision: machine-perfect repetition, 2mm leaf gaps, poly film, no cedar hue) — resale ~$330, you lose ~$70-300 plus transport · · cost if wrong A$300 ·

DISSENT: V=1,200 means §3.4's LOW-confidence BUY exception is unavailable (requires V < $1,000), and even if usable the margin 660-400=260 fails max(0.5V,$300)=$600. Cited MC-01/05/06 don't match library mc-001/005/006 prices ($4,500/$2,990/$1,400) and the mid was anchored to an ask band. Ask integrity IS good here: audit settles A$400 (A$14,000 was the known scrape artefact). Correct verdict: CONSIDER pending in-person species/windlass check.

Ask versus value

Estimated value: A$600 – A$2,400 (mid A$1,200) · refs aus-008 / aus-007 / aus-024 / aus-025

Basis: Style-correct bulb-turned extension at the A$400 corrected ask: private net A$660 beats ask by A$260, past the A$100/25% margin, even with authenticity unproven.

Ask A$400 → upside A$800 (value mid − ask)

If resold: private net A$660 · auction net A$360 · retail asking A$1,600

Adjustments
  • minus: poly refinish, colour drift between leaves and top
  • minus: unproven species - if it is stained pine/repro, value collapses to the A$600 low
  • verify in person: species (cedar vs mahogany vs stained softwood), windlass and iron, underside pegs/dowels, any maker label, leaf fit - if windlass/label/cedar all confirm, revalue to the A$2,000+ band
  • BUY despite unproven authenticity because at A$400 the margin survives even the repro-case low (A$600 net ~A$330 is at ask; confirm in person before paying)
Verdict: CONSIDER · upside A$800 vs the A$400 ask · confidence low
Comparable evidence
comparable aus-008
aus-008 · Antiques Reporter (Gowans Auctions) · A$5,226
Genuine colonial cedar 2-leaf D-end extension, auction hammer A$5,226 for the exact form in original condition; library ref note: poly-refinished surfaces lose the patina premium 5-10x, discounting to ~A$520-1,045 private net, the band low-to-mid. [comp basis] Like-for-like: real Victorian/colonial cedar D-end extension rows; band reached from genuine-hammer benchmarks via the library's documented 5-10x refinished-surface discount.
comparable aus-007
aus-007 · Antiques Reporter (Gowans Auctions) · A$6,820
Cedar 4-leaf D-end extension hammer A$6,820 - benchmark for large D-end extensions in working order; same 5-10x refinish/private discount places it ~A$680-1,364, spanning the A$1,200 mid and explaining the basis's A$660 private-net claim.
no image
aus-024 · eBay Australia · A$210
Floor contrast: unremarkable genuine colonial cedar table asks only A$210 online (eBay AU), the bottom of the asking market - shows the A$600 band low already prices this piece above commodity cedar, defensible only on its style-correct bulb-turn D-end form.
no image
aus-025 · Murphy's Antiques and Restorations · A$390
Band-level: dealer-retail A$390 for restored/commercial period pedestal tables, the library's evidence that refinished period-look pieces clear retail money, not auction-colonial money; dealer asking discounts 2-3x to private, near the band floor. [comp mismatch] Band high 2400 exceeds every discounted comp (5-10x off genuine hammers gives ~520-1360) and is only reachable if the Victorian cedar attribution stands; photos show uniform poly refinish, so the comp-anchored zone is band low-to-mid. Value NOT changed.

#030 Timber & cane dining table

A$150
Brisbane, QLD · — · View listing

1990s-2000s espresso-stained reproduction with a woven-cane panel inset in the top and a glass sheet; a style that clears slowly and below ask.

PASSrectangularmedium
Timber & cane dining table photoTimber & cane dining table photo

Identification & condition

Form
rectangular
Maker or style
Reproduction 'colonial-look' dining table (1990s-2000s retail), cane-inlay top
Material
Espresso-stained hardwood or veneered frame; natural woven cane panel inset in the top field; loose glass top present (reflection in photo 2)
Period
late 20th / early 21st century — not antique
Construction
Square tapered legs with reeded/fluted corner blocks, machine-cut; wide stained border framing the cane panel; no moulded antique detailing
Dimensions (est.)
~180 × 90 × 74 cm (seller's claim; proportion consistent in photos)
Condition grade
good

Visible in photos: Cane panel intact, no visible breaks or perishing; some light scuffs on the stained rails; glass top present and clear.

Can't see from these photos: solid timber vs veneer at the edges (resolution) / underside and fixings / cane condition under the glass edges / whether glass is included or the reflection is the finish

Photo limits: Photos are two wide shots only; we cannot tell solid from veneer, confirm the glass is included, or see the underside. Identification of era/class is confident, which is enough at this price level.

Appraisal confidence: medium

Ask versus value

Estimated value: A$60 – A$220 (mid A$120) · refs sp-009 / aus-024

Basis: Reproduction cane-top tables have no collector market; private clearance is well under ask.

Ask A$150 → upside A$−30 (value mid − ask)

If resold: private net A$110 · auction net A$40 · retail asking A$260

Adjustments
  • reproduction not antique: no C_orig credit at all
  • ×0.85 regional asking haircut
  • cane-in-top is a liability (stains, tears under glass): buyer pool small
Verdict: PASS · upside A$−30 vs the A$150 ask · confidence medium
Comparable evidence
comparable sp-009
sp-009 · Antiques Reporter (auction record) · A$1,680
A six-piece CANE setting hammered A$1,680 only because it is genuine colonial cane work — this is the modern reproduction opposite
no image
aus-024 · eBay Australia · A$210
Regional online asking for 'colonial-style' tables that are unremarkable sits at ~A$210 and clears lower

#033 6 seat dining table and chairs

A$100 (table + 6 chairs)
Brisbane, QLD · — · View listing

Matching mid-2000s laminate suite in a garage; the $100 is for seven pieces and the table's share leaves no margin.

CONSIDERrectangularmedium
6 seat dining table and chairs photo6 seat dining table and chairs photo6 seat dining table and chairs photo6 seat dining table and chairs photo

Identification & condition

Form
rectangular
Maker or style
Matching dining suite, walnut-tone melamine top with grey fabric chairs (Fantastic/Amart-class, mid-2000s-2010s)
Material
Laminate wood-grain-print rectangular top, dark stained legs; grey woven-fabric upholstered chairs on timber legs
Period
modern flat-pack suite
Construction
Flat banded laminate top, simple tapered square legs; chairs are the matching retail design; photo 1 shows chairs stacked in a garage
Dimensions (est.)
~150-160 × 90 cm table (6-place setting in photos)
Condition grade
fair

Visible in photos: Table surface clean-ish in garage light; chairs show pad wear/sag on a couple of seats; no dramatic damage visible.

Can't see from these photos: rip or foam collapse detail on seat fabric / table edge chipping at close range / leg joints tightness

Photo limits: Garage photos at bad light: fabric condition on all six chairs, edge chipping and joint tightness are unverifiable. Since the ask covers the whole suite, table-only value may understate what the bundle fetches — but even the whole suite nets under our margin floor.

Appraisal confidence: medium

Ask versus value

Estimated value: A$60 – A$170 (mid A$110) · refs ds-021 / ds-023

Basis: Whole 7-piece suite clears around A$150-250; the table's allocated share is ~A$110.

Ask A$100 → upside A$10 (value mid − ask)

If resold: private net A$100 · auction net A$30 · retail asking A$200

Adjustments
  • ×0.85 asking haircut; 7-piece bundles move for the whole price, not per piece
  • chairs inflate the deal but we value the table alone
Verdict: CONSIDER · upside A$10 vs the A$100 ask · confidence medium
Comparable evidence
no image
ds-021 · Gumtree Australia · A$80
QLD flat-pack suite ask A$80 for 3 pieces — same retail tier and clearance dynamics
no image
ds-023 · Gumtree Australia (PriceWorth Rocklea) · A$399
Gordon walnut-veneer round TRADE ask A$399 shows what even real veneer gets from dealers; melamine gets far less

#035 Round dining table

A$120
Brisbane, QLD · — · View listing

The only photo is a retailer spec render, not the item; we are being asked to buy an unseen box.

CONSIDERroundlow
Round dining table photo

Identification & condition

Form
round
Maker or style
Import 'marble-look' round with black intersecting-square steel base (Amazon/online-marketplace spec graphic)
Material
Claimed 'marble like wooden' — i.e. printed laminate/MDF top on powder-coated steel frame; real stone is contradicted by the 1.5 cm rim in the render
Period
new, current import catalogue
Construction
Per the render: thin round top, base of two interlocking square steel hoops, 72 cm base footprint
Dimensions (est.)
112 cm dia, 74-75 cm H (dimensions printed in the render)
Condition grade
unknown

Visible in photos: Nothing of the actual item is visible: one image only, a white-background product drawing with dimensions.

Can't see from these photos: whether the physical table exists, is unboxed, or matches the render / top material (stone vs laminate) in person / frame finish and welds / packaging/box condition / any brand or receipt

Photo limits: One product-render photo proves nothing about the physical item — no box, no tabletop, no label, no base. Value is inferred from the claimed spec only; the honest read is 'unseen import, could be anything from pristine to assembled-and-returned'.

Appraisal confidence: low

Ask versus value

Estimated value: A$100 – A$260 (mid A$160) · refs ds-025 / ds-022

Basis: New-in-box import rounds of this class resell privately just above the ask, not far above.

Ask A$120 → upside A$40 (value mid − ask)

If resold: private net A$150 · auction net A$50 · retail asking A$260

Adjustments
  • ×0.85 haircut and no premium for 'new': unverified box contents carry LOW confidence
  • if genuine sealed new it may fetch the top of the band, but we cannot see it
Verdict: CONSIDER · upside A$40 vs the A$120 ask · confidence low
Comparable evidence
no image
ds-025 · eBay Australia · A$300
Round extendable sintered-stone 110 cm retail ask A$299.90 — new-price ceiling for the whole look
no image
ds-022 · Gumtree Australia · A$150
'Ashton' black round ask A$150 — what similar new-ish rounds sit unsold at

#036 Dinning Table

A$250
Ipswich, QLD · Listed 5 days ago in Brisbane, QLD · View listing

Branded-but-ordinary glass-top on X-trestle legs with heavy leg-edge chipping; asking price is the full private value — no margin.

PASSrectangularmedium
Dinning Table photoDinning Table photoDinning Table photoDinning Table photoDinning Table photo

Identification & condition

Form
rectangular
Maker or style
Claimed Nick Scali “Xavier”; no label in photos, but the mocha X-cross trestle under a clear glass top is consistent with Nick Scali glass/X-base designs of the 2010s
Material
Clear float glass top; dark mocha-finish timber legs — close-ups show pale substrate under the finish at the chips, i.e. stained/coated solid frame, not a premium hardwood
Period
c. 2010–2020
Construction
Two X-shaped trestle supports joined by a chrome-bar stretcher, chrome end caps; glass sits on pads; flat-sawn leg members with squared edges
Dimensions (est.)
approx. 180–200 × 90–100 × 75 cm, seats 6
Condition grade
fair

Visible in photos: Glass top clear with no visible scratches or chips in five photos; photos 04–05 are seller close-ups of the lower leg members showing extensive edge chipping/gouging along both feet with pale substrate exposed; floor-contact scuffs; structure looks square and stable on tiled floor

Can't see from these photos: underside and any maker label / glass thickness / joint tightness/wobble / full perimeter of both legs

Photo limits: No underside or label photo, so the “Xavier” model name is unverified (it does not change the value band); glass thickness and leg joint tightness unknown.

Appraisal confidence: medium

Ask versus value

Estimated value: A$150 – A$350 (mid A$250) · refs ds-023 / ds-022 / ds-021

Basis: Ordinary modern brand glass table band; used branded retail tables clear $150–400 privately in SEQ, and the leg damage sits us at the middle of that.

Ask A$250 → upside A$0 (value mid − ask)

If resold: private net A$220 · auction net A$120 · retail asking A$380

Adjustments
  • Branded (Nick Scali) recognition vs unbranded: +$50–100 over the ds-021/22 floor
  • Heavy edge chipping on both legs (photos 04–05): −20% — buyer will see the close-ups the seller kindly posted
  • Chairs not included: priced as table only
Verdict: PASS · upside A$0 vs the A$250 ask · confidence medium
Comparable evidence
no image
ds-023 · Gumtree Australia (PriceWorth Rocklea) · A$399
Trade-sale walnut-veneer branded round at $399 is the ceiling of used branded-retail tables; ours is glass with visible damage, well under it
no image
ds-022 · Gumtree Australia · A$150
Ashton 4-seater marketplace $150 sets the floor for ordinary modern brand tables; ours is larger and branded Nick Scali, so above it
no image
ds-021 · Gumtree Australia · A$80
Fantastic Furniture set sold at $80 — confirms the bottom of the modern-bracket band

#037 Victorian Dining Suite

A$1,000
Karalee, near Ipswich, QLD · — · View listing

Claimed 1860–1880 suite: photos show a refinished, uniformly glossy suite with reproduction character — at best an early-20th-century/late-repro table whose regional resale sits below the A$1,000 ask.

PASSrectangularlow
Victorian Dining Suite photoVictorian Dining Suite photoVictorian Dining Suite photo

Identification & condition

Form
rectangular
Maker or style
Claimed Victorian mahogany suite; what the photos support is an extending baluster-turned table with two carvers and six slip-seat style chairs, carved scrolled crest rails — a matched-looking set in the Victorian manner
Material
Mahogany or mahogany-veneer hardwood under a heavy, even reddish gloss coat that reads as re-varnished/poly rather than broken old patina; olive-green velvet upholstery, faded and crush-marked
Period
Claimed c. 1860–1880 — not supported by the photos; the uniform stain, glossy refinsh and crisp machine-evident turnery read as early 20th C or a late-20th C reproduction (c. 1900–1990; period bracket unresolvable from 3 photos)
Construction
Baluster-turned legs with pad feet (not claw-and-ball), moulded rounded top edge, centre seam with extension panel per seller; apron plain-to-lightly-moulded; no castors visible; no underside, joinery or marks photographed
Dimensions (est.)
Stated 1850 × 1160 × 720 mm — plausible against room scale in photo 1
Condition grade
fair

Visible in photos: Three photos: table surface glossy with soft reflections, no obvious cracks or water flooding visible; velvet faded/crushed, carvers flagged by seller as needing reupholstery; finish is a single uniform gloss suggesting a full refinish

Can't see from these photos: Underside: no marks, stamps, screw vs peg joinery, hand-tooling — the rung that would settle 1860s vs 1970s / Extension panels and their matching grain / Chair frames under the skirts (replacement tells) / True colour vs camera cast on the timber

Photo limits: The decisive evidence — underside joinery, marks, leaf grain-match — is not photographed. If an in-person check finds hand-cut mortise-tenons, old-nail repair and true patina under the poly, this becomes a genuine Victorian and the band jumps to $1,500–3,000 for the table+chairs regionally; only that inspection justifies an offer, and even then cap at ~$600.

Appraisal confidence: low

Adversarial review · agree · arithmetic: sound · recomputed margin: A$−400 · comp support: strong · ask integrity: ok (audit live price = adopted ask) · biggest downside: If it is true Victorian cedar the value is $3k+ and you missed a bargain — that risk is explicitly flagged for in-person check · · cost if wrong A$0 ·

PASS spot-check #1: audit live $1,000 = card. Even the high band ($1,200) nets ~$1,140 before delivery/furniture-strip discount — margin never turns positive at ask. Chair-count rule (bare table + $50-150/chair) applied correctly instead of auction 14-piece prices. PASS stands.

Ask versus value

Estimated value: A$350 – A$1,200 (mid A$650) · refs sp-008 / sp-028 / ds-018

Basis: Regional bare-table ladder for ordinary Edwardian/extension tables (sp-008 dealer ask $1,250, sp-028 $850 needs-refinish) discounted for the refinished/reproduction character the photos show, with chairs added at the mismatched-chair rate per the chair-count rule.

Ask A$1,000 → upside A$−350 (value mid − ask)

If resold: private net A$600 · auction net A$420 · retail asking A$1,400

Adjustments
  • Chair-count rule: Marketplace “8-chair suite” claims are valued as bare table + $50–150 per chair, not the 14-piece auction numbers (matching-period sets would 1.5–2× the table — unproven here)
  • Refinished/poly coat: −20–30% against a good-original example
  • Upholstery in the carvers needs replacing: −$150
  • Style-matched chairs and D-end scale: + over a lone repro table
Verdict: PASS · upside A$−350 vs the A$1,000 ask · confidence low
Comparable evidence
comparable sp-008
sp-008 · Moonee Ponds Antiques (Melbourne dealer) · A$1,250
Australian Edwardian extension table at $1,250 dealer-asking is the ceiling for this quality level regionally; photos suggest refinished/repro, so apply the marketplace-ask discount ×0.87 and a reproduction haircut
comparable sp-028
sp-028 · Nord Modern (Brunswick, Melbourne vintage dealer) · A$850
QLD-walnut extension needing refinish, retail ask $850 — the honest regional level for a refinished extending table
no image
ds-018 · Antique Mahogany (AU retailer) · A$990
Reproduction antique band (new repro $990 retail → used $150–500) applies if the piece is a 1970s–90s import as the uniform gloss suggests

#040 Solid Wooden Super Table

A$100
Fernvale, QLD · Listed a week ago in Fernvale, QLD · View listing

Chunky handmade-looking solid-timber slab-leg table at near-free money; plausible small flip but one photo gives us little to stand on.

CONSIDERrectangularlow
Solid Wooden Super Table photo

Identification & condition

Form
rectangular
Maker or style
Unbranded heavy rustic/house-made style — plank-panel top on two solid slab panel legs; not an old farm table (edge too crisp, finish too even), not a modern IKEA-style piece
Material
Reddish mid-brown timber under a thick satin/gloss varnish; plank/slab construction reads solid; species indeterminate (spotted gum / hoop-pine-stained / imported hardwood all possible from this photo)
Period
Probable late 20th C (c. 1970–2000)
Construction
Massive squared top edge, slab panel feet; no turnery, no hardware cues; seller's “very heavy” consistent with solid panel construction; underside and fixings not shown
Dimensions (est.)
approx. 150–180 × 75–85 × 74 cm (from speaker/stereo scale on top)
Condition grade
good

Visible in photos: One photo, stored-room setting: top shows an even gloss with light surface scratches and a few marks, no visible cracks, splits or water rings at the resolution available; legs clean; the object on the top is a stock whip, unrelated

Can't see from these photos: Underside — solid vs veneer core vs laminate over MDF is unproven / Stability/wobble of the panel feet / Full perimeter — the single angle hides the far edge / True colour under the varnish

Photo limits: Everything that would confirm substance: underside, core at any chip, weight, wobble, second angle. A tap-test photo and an underside photo are the required follow-up before an offer; at $100 the downside is one ute trip.

Appraisal confidence: low

Adversarial review · agree · arithmetic: sound · recomputed margin: A$100 · comp support: strong · ask integrity: ok (audit live price = adopted ask) · biggest downside: Chipboard-look veneer under wear; resale 150 — CONSIDER, no exposure · · cost if wrong A$0 ·

sp-012 (sold $300 cane set) and ds-023 (trade ask $399 walnut veneer) both exist and genuinely bracket the band; discount from sold/asking to private net is applied. 100 < 150 floor so correctly not a BUY.

Ask versus value

Estimated value: A$120 – A$350 (mid A$220) · refs sp-012 / ds-023

Basis: Solid tradie/Australian casual hardwood band ($100–450 in the method's tier table); with no proof of species or solid core we sit at the low-middle.

Ask A$100 → upside A$120 (value mid − ask)

If resold: private net A$200 · auction net A$110 · retail asking A$380

Adjustments
  • Unknown species/solid core: value the honest low end until proven
  • Heavy and hard to move (seller's own warning): reduces buyer pool, −$30–50
  • If it is a genuine old slab hardwood: band top $350+; unverifiable from one photo
Verdict: CONSIDER · upside A$120 vs the A$100 ask · confidence low
Comparable evidence
comparable sp-012
sp-012 · MM Furniture (Sunshine Coast QLD dealer) · A$300
Sold Brisbane-by-night cane table+chairs set at $300 — the realistic private ceiling for unbranded solid casual furniture here
no image
ds-023 · Gumtree Australia (PriceWorth Rocklea) · A$399
Branded veneer round that fetched $399 trade-sale; our piece has no brand, so it must price under this even if solid

#041 Dining Table with Marble Top

A$750
Brisbane, QLD · Listed a week ago in Brisbane, QLD · View listing

The stone tests read REAL — solid eased slab edge about 2–3 cm and polished depth, not an edge band — but it is a big, old-fashioned, 300-plus kg unbranded marble table, and A$750 is already full retail-private for that.

PASSrectangularmedium
Dining Table with Marble Top photoDining Table with Marble Top photoDining Table with Marble Top photoDining Table with Marble Top photoDining Table with Marble Top photoDining Table with Marble Top photo

Identification & condition

Form
rectangular
Maker or style
Unbranded classic/1990s–2000s marble-top dining table; substantial dark-stained timber trestle/pedestal-style base with cross stretcher
Material
Top: beige/crema marble-surfaced slab — veining with depth, mirror window-reflection, no repeat pattern; edge photos show a solid eased stone edge ~2–3 cm thick, so real stone rather than marble-look laminate. Base: dark-stained solid timber
Period
c. 1990–2010
Construction
Slab rests on timber frame/apron; bolted stretcher visible; chairs in shots sold separately; seller's “heavy, 2–3 people” consistent with a real slab
Dimensions (est.)
approx. 200–220 × 100–110 × 75 cm, 8-seater
Condition grade
good

Visible in photos: Six photos: no visible chips, cracks or etch-clouding on the slab; gloss even; base shows some light scuffs at floor level; chairs removed cleanly

Can't see from these photos: Underside of slab — reinforcement mesh, substrate at the edge, any hairline crack from below / Stone thickness by measure (photo estimate 2–3 cm) / Wobble of the base joints / Etching from acids — a close test needs raking light on site

Photo limits: Underside of the slab (cracks, mesh, exact thickness) and base joint tightness. Real-stone conclusion is from the edge profile and gloss in photos 02/05; a magnetic/tap test on site would confirm. Even on the optimistic read it is worth ~$650, so the ceiling counter is ~$450.

Appraisal confidence: medium

Adversarial review · agree · arithmetic: sound · recomputed margin: A$−150 · comp support: strong · ask integrity: ok (audit live price = adopted ask) · biggest downside: If the slab is book-matched figured marble it is worth more, but photos show ordinary crema; the only cost is a missed ~$100-150 flip · · cost if wrong A$150 ·

PASS spot-check #2: audit live $750 = card; ds-016/sp-018/sp-019 all exist and honestly bracket (new $2,159 -> used 35% under ask -> imitation floor $450). My own vision re-read: real ~25mm slab, generic stained base, and it judged $600-650 'reasonable to slightly optimistic' — if anything the PASS is understated, never overstated, so no inflated market view.

Ask versus value

Estimated value: A$450 – A$900 (mid A$650) · refs ds-016 / sp-018 / sp-019

Basis: Real stone but zero provenance: anchored to the used stone-top band — new Castlery travertine at $2,159 retail (clears ~$1,450) discounted ~50% for age/style/unbranded, floored by the $450 marketplace ‘marble-effect’ band since the slab is genuinely thicker than that.

Ask A$750 → upside A$−100 (value mid − ask)

If resold: private net A$600 · auction net A$400 · retail asking A$1,100

Adjustments
  • Real stone vs laminate: +40% over the imitation band (edge/gloss tests passed)
  • Market depth: a ~300–400 kg table buyers must collect on foot — ×0.7, only a narrow pool wants this size and style
  • 8-seater size (≥140 cm class): ×0.9, hard to shift
  • No designer attribution: the premium rule applies — the money sits in the base, and this base is generic stained timber
Verdict: PASS · upside A$−100 vs the A$750 ask · confidence medium
Comparable evidence
comparable ds-016
ds-016 · Castlery AU · A$2,159
Castlery Belmont travertine round, new retail $2,159: a current stone-top table clears ~35% under ask privately; our 1990s unbranded style takes a further ~50% age/style haircut
no image
sp-018 · eBay Australia listings (search snapshot) · A$450
Vintage 70s/80s ‘travertine-effect’ marketplace table asking $450 — the imitation floor; our slab is real and bigger, so value sits above it
no image
sp-019 · Nick Scali (nickscali.com.au) · A$1,790
Nick Scali new marble-veneer rounds from ~$1,790: even new branded stone-veneer stock is near this ask, which caps a used unbranded piece well below the asking price

#042 Round extendable wooden table

A$250 (listings capture; detail page captured “A$14,000” — almost certainly a scrape artefact, both readings still give the same verdict)
Brisbane, QLD · Listed 3 weeks ago in Brisbane, QLD · View listing

Solid softwood country extending round + six slat-backs: honest family furniture with water marks and finish wear; even at A$250 the resale equals the ask.

PASSroundmedium
Round extendable wooden table photoRound extendable wooden table photoRound extendable wooden table photoRound extendable wooden table photo

Identification & condition

Form
round
Maker or style
Unbranded country/farmhouse extending round, 1970s–90s build; matching hoop slat-back chairs; no stamp or label visible — not Ercol (no steam-bent hoop frames, no shield mark in photos), not Danish teak
Material
Honey-finished softwood — knots and plank seams visible under the finish read as pine rather than teak or oak
Period
c. 1975–1995
Construction
Central pillar base with splayed turned feet; top converts round→oval via a leaf seam across the middle (mechanism type not visible — butterfly vs loose leaf unconfirmed); chairs: slat-back with shaped crest
Dimensions (est.)
round Ø approx. 105–115 cm, oval approx. 140–150 × 105–115 cm
Condition grade
fair

Visible in photos: Four photos: water marks/rings and a cloudy patch on the top, scratches and finish wear consistent with “normal family use”, chair seats with scuffs; structure looks sound and square

Can't see from these photos: Whether the leaf is present and which mechanism it uses / Underside joint condition / Chair joints under wear / Whether the rings go into the timber or sit in the finish

Photo limits: Leaf presence/mechanism and underside joints — the two things that would decide whether the top of the band applies. Neither lifts value above the ask.

Appraisal confidence: medium

Ask versus value

Estimated value: A$150 – A$400 (mid A$250) · refs mc-011 / sp-012 / ds-024

Basis: Unbranded solid-softwood casual set: sits under every named-maker equivalent in the library and level with the sold unbranded sets.

Ask A$250 → upside A$0 (value mid − ask)

If resold: private net A$230 · auction net A$140 · retail asking A$420

Adjustments
  • Condition: rings/wear C_cond 0.75
  • Round form headwind, but working leaf keeps full utility
  • 6 matching chairs included: +$100–150 over table alone
  • Price capture conflict (A$250 vs A$14,000): judged at A$250; at A$14,000 it is an instant PASS regardless
Verdict: PASS · upside A$0 vs the A$250 ask · confidence medium
Comparable evidence
no image
mc-011 · Arthur Johnson & Sons (UK, easyliveauction) · A$512
G-Plan Fresco teak oval extending + 6 chairs at A$512 auction is the quality above this (teak, named); pine with water rings must clear well under
comparable sp-012
sp-012 · MM Furniture (Sunshine Coast QLD dealer) · A$300
Sold set at $300 Brisbane-by-night is the realistic private clearing level for a full unbranded casual set
no image
ds-024 · Amazon Australia · A$162
Sold 4-piece leaf-table set $161 — the floor for unbranded extending rounds; ours has 6 chairs and solid timber, so above it

#065 Dining Table + 6 Chairs

A$150
Forest Lake, QLD · — · View listing

Painted flatpack country set at end of life — chipped top edge, stained seat fabric, seller admits it needs a repaint; the ask is the value, so there is nothing here.

PASSrectangularmedium
Dining Table + 6 Chairs photoDining Table + 6 Chairs photoDining Table + 6 Chairs photoDining Table + 6 Chairs photo

Identification & condition

Form
rectangular
Maker or style
Painted flatpack-style country set; seller says “believes IKEA”. The rectangular plank-style top and X-back chairs read as a generic white-washed pine flatpack of the Melltorp/Ingatorp family rather than a specific current model — attribution unconfirmed and irrelevant to value
Material
Painted/washed softwood (pine) top showing plank seams under the white wash; chairs painted with grey fabric seat pads
Period
c. 2000–2015
Construction
Square-section legs, screw/bolt flatpack fixings (seller: “some screws missing”); X-cross chair backs; top has visible plank joints and a chamfered edge
Dimensions (est.)
approx. 170–180 × 85–90 × 75 cm, 6-seater
Condition grade
poor

Visible in photos: Four photos: heavy paint chipping and wear along the top edge and corners (photo 4 is a close-up of the abraded edge with the wash worn through), stain and wear on the grey chair seat pads, scuffed legs; overall structurally upright but cosmetically tired

Can't see from these photos: Missing screws / joint tightness / Underside and any IKEA marking / Chair leg wear at floor level on all six / Whether the top is solid planks or laminate over board (plank seams suggest solid)

Photo limits: Underside label (would only confirm/kill the IKEA theory, changing nothing), joint tightness with the missing screws. Photos are clear; the verdict is not a confidence problem, the piece simply has no margin.

Appraisal confidence: medium

Ask versus value

Estimated value: A$80 – A$250 (mid A$150) · refs ds-021 / ds-022

Basis: Ordinary flat-pack tier ($0–250, modal $50–150 in the method bands); a repaint of $100–200 is required before it photographs well, and the chairs need new seat pads.

Ask A$150 → upside A$0 (value mid − ask)

If resold: private net A$140 · auction net A$50 · retail asking A$280

Adjustments
  • Repaint + seat pads needed: −$150–200 against a clean example
  • 6 chairs included: +$50–100, but painted-pine chairs fetch little
  • Missing screws noted by seller: minor
Verdict: PASS · upside A$0 vs the A$150 ask · confidence medium
Comparable evidence
no image
ds-021 · Gumtree Australia · A$80
Fantastic Furniture table+2 chairs marketplace at $80 — the realistic clearing point for painted flatpack with damage
no image
ds-022 · Gumtree Australia · A$150
'Ashton' 4-seater at $150 ask is the ceiling for ordinary flatpack sets, and ours needs work against that one's clean finish

#067 Dining set

A$350
Brisbane, QLD · — · View listing

Photos show a contemporary light-oak-look rectangular table with six grey fabric chairslaid-back — a mass-market retail set (Harvey Norman class as claimed is plausible; no label visible). Clean and complete, but this exact look floods Marketplace and clears far under the ask of $350.

PASSrectangularmedium
Dining set photoDining set photoDining set photo

Identification & condition

Form
rectangular
Maker or style
unbranded modern light-timber dining set, 6 chairs (Harvey Norman-class retail, claim not verifiable — no label in photos)
Material
pale oak-look top (veneer or laminate over engineered board; plank-look pattern), grey woven fabric on chair seats, light tapered legs
Period
2015-2025
Construction
Chunky square-section legs and apron, eased square top edge, slipcover-less fabric chair shells; nothing traditional or solid-timber joinery visible
Dimensions (est.)
claimed 1.0 x 1.8 m; photos consistent with a 180 x 90-100 cm 6-seater
Condition grade
good

Visible in photos: Top clean with even sheen, no visible chips; chair fabric uniform, no visible stains or tears in the three photos; staged-room lighting flatters but nothing overtly wrong

Can't see from these photos: underside — cannot confirm veneer vs solid / frame hardware/glides / chair seat foam condition under fabric / any actual Harvey Norman label

Photo limits: ['No label visible to confirm the Harvey Norman claim', 'top build (veneer vs solid) unverifiable from the three staged photos']

Appraisal confidence: medium

Ask versus value

Estimated value: A$180 – A$400 (mid A$280) · refs ds-022 / ds-023

Basis: Near-new modern flat-pack-class 6-chair sets clear in the low hundreds locally; clean condition keeps it at the top of that band, still under the ask.

Ask A$350 → upside A$−70 (value mid − ask)

If resold: private net A$235 · auction net A$130 · retail asking A$380

Adjustments
  • asking-marketplace comps discounted x0.85 to clear (method 3.3)
  • no brand label visible — retail-name premium not supportable
  • 6 chairs adds volume but grey fabric is the modal (least differentiated) look
Verdict: PASS · upside A$−70 vs the A$350 ask · confidence medium
Comparable evidence
no image
ds-022 · Gumtree Australia · A$150
Near-new flat-pack 4-seater asked $150 and loses 60-70% vs new — same depreciation curve applies here, scaled for 6 chairs
no image
ds-023 · Gumtree Australia (PriceWorth Rocklea) · A$399
Trade seller asking $399 for a veneer round set shows the ask-side ceiling for this class; private clearing sits well under

#069 Dining table + 8 chairs

A$60
Brisbane, QLD · — · View listing

Single snapshot of a light flat-pack rectangular table with 8 chairs in a garage-style shot. Matches the seller's own account of paying ~$400 new — a budget kit set. Even at the card ask of $60 the resale net is only modestly above it, and the detail-page price capture disagreed with the card, so there is no demonstrable edge.

CONSIDERrectangularlow
Dining table + 8 chairs photo

Identification & condition

Form
rectangular
Maker or style
unbranded modern flat-pack 8-chair set (Fantastic-Furniture class)
Material
pale timber-look laminate/veneer top, slim light legs, fabric or vinyl seat chairs
Period
2020s (bought ~4 months ago per seller)
Construction
Thin top with simple edge banding; knock-down fittings implied by the flat-pack look; no traditional joinery anywhere in the single photo
Dimensions (est.)
approx 140-160 x 80-90 cm from room proportions; single photo only
Condition grade
fair

Visible in photos: One only photo: set complete-ish (8 chairs claimed, most visible), top appears unmarked at snapshot distance, nothing structural obviously wrong — but one low-quality photo cannot support a better grade

Can't see from these photos: almost everything: top edges, underside, chair fabric detail, any damage or wobble

Photo limits: ['Card price A$60 and detail-page price A$150 disagree by more than 20 percent — card price used per rule; the real ask is unresolved', 'One photo only: cannot verify top material, mechanism of damage-free claim, or the full chair count']

Appraisal confidence: low

Ask versus value

Estimated value: A$100 – A$220 (mid A$150) · refs ds-022 / ds-021

Basis: 8-chair flat-pack kits that cost ~$400 new resell at a fraction of cost; one photo and rushed sale signal confirm the bottom tier.

Ask A$60 → upside A$90 (value mid − ask)

If resold: private net A$125 · auction net A$60 · retail asking A$200

Adjustments
  • asking comps x0.85 to clear
  • single-photo discount on confidence, not on price
  • urgent-seller wording ('gone by Monday') supports buying at or under ask
Verdict: CONSIDER · upside A$90 vs the A$60 ask · confidence low
Comparable evidence
no image
ds-022 · Gumtree Australia · A$150
Near-new flat-pack set at $150 ask defines the clearing band; this is older, larger-table variant
no image
ds-021 · Gumtree Australia · A$80
$80 sold floor for a small round set — this has 8 chairs so sits above the absolute floor but in the same class

#078 Beautifuly restored extendable dining table

A$700
Brisbane, QLD · — · View listing

One photo of a honey-toned timber-top table on a gloss-white painted pedestal-style base. The restoration narrative is half-supported: the finish is genuinely new and sprayed, but it is a new finish on an ordinary vintage/repro extendable (76 high, 120>180 as stated) — labour does not lift resale, and $700 is roughly double what the resale channels return.

PASSrectangularlow
Beautifuly restored extendable dining table photo

Identification & condition

Form
rectangular
Maker or style
restorer-flip extendable ('Bell restoration' per seller, unverified trade name)
Material
open-grain honey-toned top (reads as oak-look; solid vs veneer not determinable from one photo) over a painted softwood base
Period
late 20th-c base/top, 2020s refinish
Construction
Sprayed gloss-white base (4 coats claimed — plausible given the even film), clear-gloss top; extendable 120>180 cm per seller; no mechanism visible in the single photo
Dimensions (est.)
76 cm high; 120 cm closed to 180 cm extended (seller-stated, not checkable)
Condition grade
good

Visible in photos: Finish is fresh and even in the one photo; top clean and highly reflective; base paint appears professionally sprayed; no visible damage at this resolution

Can't see from these photos: extension mechanism and leaf condition / underside / top edges for veneer vs solid / grain detail to settle timber species

Photo limits: ['Only one photo — mechanism, leaves, underside and top edge are unverified', 'Cannot tell whether the top is solid oak, oak-veneer or a stained softwood; that alone swings value 2x']

Appraisal confidence: low

Ask versus value

Estimated value: A$250 – A$550 (mid A$400) · refs ds-018 / ds-023 / mc-023

Basis: A new painted-finish look on a commodity extendable, one photo, no brand: refinished reproduction tables clear in the low hundreds, not at restoration-labour prices.

Ask A$700 → upside A$−300 (value mid − ask)

If resold: private net A$340 · auction net A$180 · retail asking A$550

Adjustments
  • white-painted finish narrows the buyer pool (trend-dependent) x0.8
  • single photo, unverified mechanism: confidence-driven wide band
  • restoration labour is a cost to the seller, not value to a reseller
Verdict: PASS · upside A$−300 vs the A$700 ask · confidence low
Comparable evidence
no image
ds-018 · Antique Mahogany (AU retailer) · A$990
A brand-new solid-mahogany repro round retails at $990 — a used unbranded refinished repro must sit far below new-repro retail
no image
ds-023 · Gumtree Australia (PriceWorth Rocklea) · A$399
Trade Marketplace asks of ~$399 for veneer sets are the realistic ceiling for refinished commodity tables
no image
mc-023 · Arthur Johnson & Sons (UK, easyliveauction) · A$102
Unbranded drop-leaf/extension commodity hammers ~$100 at auction — floor signal for the no-label case

#079 Dining Table -Extendable

A$250
Brisbane, QLD · Just listed · View listing

Five well-lit photos of a honey/oak-toned rectangular extendable with turned-tapered legs and a loose leaf shown out. It is a serviceable late-20th-c colonial-style extendable — the 'solid timber' claim looks plausible from the leaf edges, but it is the modal form that floods Marketplace, the acknowledged pink ink transfer is visible on one end, and resale nets land at the ask, not above it.

PASSrectangularmedium
Dining Table -Extendable photoDining Table -Extendable photoDining Table -Extendable photoDining Table -Extendable photoDining Table -Extendable photo

Identification & condition

Form
rectangular
Maker or style
unbranded Australian colonial-style extendable (Victorian-ash/oak-look)
Material
solid-looking light timber top and leaf (grain runs through edges), sprayed satin finish
Period
c. 1980s-1990s
Construction
Loose extension leaf shown separately in the set; turned-tapered legs on a straight rail frame; no visible traditional mortise detailing or maker mark
Dimensions (est.)
approx 150-165 cm closed to 8-seat extended, standard 74-76 cm height (photos vs chairs)
Condition grade
fair

Visible in photos: Gloss/deep satin top with light use marks; pink/reddish ink transfer visible on one end as the seller admits; otherwise no structural damage across five photos; finish looks factory-sprayed, fairly sound

Can't see from these photos: underside and leaf storage method / whether top is solid or veneer over board (edge grain suggests solid but not proven) / stability/rattle of extension fit

Photo limits: ['Veneer vs solid not decidable from the five photos (no underside or chip point)', 'Leaf fit and mechanism condition unseen']

Appraisal confidence: medium

Ask versus value

Estimated value: A$180 – A$380 (mid A$280) · refs sp-028 / mc-019 / ds-021

Basis: Modal colonial extendable with a visible ink stain: private clearing for unbranded versions of this form sits $200-400 before condition discount.

Ask A$250 → upside A$30 (value mid − ask)

If resold: private net A$240 · auction net A$140 · retail asking A$380

Adjustments
  • C_cond ~0.85 for the ink transfer (buyer will price the stain visible in the ad)
  • unbranded + round-adjacent oversupplied form: x0.8 demand discount
  • solid-timber plausibility keeps it off the laminate floor
Verdict: PASS · upside A$30 vs the A$250 ask · confidence medium
Comparable evidence
comparable sp-028
sp-028 · Nord Modern (Brunswick, Melbourne vintage dealer) · A$850
QLD walnut extension retails at $850 — used unbranded equivalents clear around a third of retail
comparable mc-019
mc-019 · Fabiano Antiques (photo of Fler 64 teak extension table) · A$410
Auction estimate $360-460 is for branded Danish teak; an unbranded 1990s colonial sits under that floor
no image
ds-021 · Gumtree Australia · A$80
$80 sold floor marks the bottom of the commodity-dining class

#080 1950 dining table & chairs

A$200
Brisbane, QLD · — · View listing

Six photos of a brown-stained rectangular top on a panel-trestle base with bracketed feet, plus six matching chairs re-covered in a cream patterned fabric. The 1950s claim is consistent with what the photos show — trestle-and-shoe construction and stained-timber mouldings are period, not repro — and at $200 for a complete 6-chair set the private resale net clears the BUY margin.

CONSIDERrectangularlow
1950 dining table & chairs photo1950 dining table & chairs photo1950 dining table & chairs photo1950 dining table & chairs photo1950 dining table & chairs photo1950 dining table & chairs photo

Identification & condition

Form
rectangular
Maker or style
Australian retro/1950s dining suite, unlabelled (wartime-utility lineage)
Material
brown-stained timber (reads as stained oak or fruitwood-look) top with solid lipped edge; timber chairs with fabric slip seats
Period
c. 1945-1955, refurbished/upholstered 1999 (fabric looks 1990s, consistent)
Construction
Rectangular top on single panel trestle ends with cross-rail and metal-shod feet; contrasting light lipping/edge band visible; matching arm + side chairs; no label photographed
Dimensions (est.)
seller-stated 1650 x 930 x 780 mm; proportions in photos agree; chairs 920 mm high
Condition grade
good

Visible in photos: Top shows an even satin finish with light surface marks; fabric on seats looks clean and taut in the photos; feet brackets intact; edge lipping has a darker repair/colour break visible in photo 1 (present, not hidden)

Can't see from these photos: underside for labels, worm holes or repairs / frame joints/rattle of the six chairs / whether top is solid or veneer over the core / true age without hardware inspection

Photo limits: ['Woodworm, underside repairs and joint integrity cannot be excluded from photos — pre-purchase inspection needed', 'No maker label photographed; period attribution is style-based']

Appraisal confidence: low

Adversarial review · DISSENT · arithmetic: sound · recomputed margin: A$165 · comp support: strong · ask integrity: no audit row (card A$200 adopted) · biggest downside: Woodworm holes in photo 3 = walk-away piece, or wobbling top needs $300+ carpentry; you sink $200+refurb · · cost if wrong A$500 ·

DISSENT on the verdict only: comps are real and probative (mc-011 hammer $512, sp-027 ask $900, ds-014 sold $1,150) and channel discounting is correctly applied. But confidence is LOW and §3.4 requires margin >= max(0.5*430,$300)=$300; margin is 365-200=165. Correct verdict: CONSIDER (re-test as BUY only if in-person check lifts confidence to medium).

Ask versus value

Estimated value: A$300 – A$600 (mid A$430) · refs mc-011 / sp-027 / ds-014

Basis: Complete matching 6-chair 1950s suites in honest order clear around $400-500 in the current vintage-dining pull; ask is barely half the mid.

Ask A$200 → upside A$230 (value mid − ask)

If resold: private net A$365 · auction net A$215 · retail asking A$550

Adjustments
  • unbranded vs designer/branded: x0.35-0.45 of ds-014, ~x0.85 of the Fresco hammer
  • 1999 fabric is dated but sound — no re-cover cost assumed, x0.95
  • 6 chairs matching raises value over table-only comps
Verdict: CONSIDER · upside A$230 vs the A$200 ask · confidence low
Comparable evidence
no image
mc-011 · Arthur Johnson & Sons (UK, easyliveauction) · A$512
Branded G-Plan teak 6-chair suite hammers ~A$500 equivalent; an unbranded AU retro suite sits just under that ceiling
no image
sp-027 · eBay Australia listings (search snapshot) · A$900
Named AU laminate suites are asked up to $900 — genuine timber vintage must hold above the laminate asking band when complete
no image
ds-014 · Mrs Secondhand · A$1,150
Designer Fler 1950 sold at $1,150 — confirms the 1950s category has real demand; unbranded example takes a large discount from that

#083 Dining table

A$150
Brisbane, QLD · — · View listing

Five photos of a large octagonal high-gloss dark-reddish table on an octagonal plinth column. The 'solid wood' claim is unproven — the deep even gloss and mirror-like surface read as sprayed veneer/laminate over a board core in the 1970s plinth idiom — and a big plinth octagon is heavy, dated and slow-selling; net resale lands roughly at the $150 ask.

CONSIDERroundmedium
Dining table photoDining table photoDining table photoDining table photoDining table photo

Identification & condition

Form
round
Maker or style
unbranded 1970s-80s octagonal plinth dining table
Material
dark reddish-brown (mahogany/walnut-look) high-gloss surface over what the photos suggest is a veneered engineered top; plinth base
Period
c. 1970-1985
Construction
Eight-facet top on a faceted column plinth; tape measure in photo 2 runs across the top (roughly 1.7-1.9 m class); no extension seam or leaves visible in any photo, despite the roomy top
Dimensions (est.)
approx 150-170 cm across flats from tape/room scale; seats 6-8
Condition grade
fair

Visible in photos: Close-ups show the gloss is scratched/hazed in places (fine hairline scratching across the surface), no chips or lifting edges visible at the corners; sun glare limits read

Can't see from these photos: underside — cannot confirm veneer vs solid despite the 'solid' claim / plinth base for water damage on floor / any leaf/extension provision

Photo limits: ['Solid vs veneer cannot be settled from any of the five photos', 'Tape measure length not readable precisely; only approximate size', 'Underside never photographed']

Appraisal confidence: medium

Ask versus value

Estimated value: A$120 – A$320 (mid A$220) · refs ds-021 / ds-023

Basis: Large glossy plinth octagons are the modal 'unsold' furniture on Marketplace: cheap while listed, slower than round, and the scratched PU film caps the top of the band.

Ask A$150 → upside A$70 (value mid − ask)

If resold: private net A$185 · auction net A$100 · retail asking A$300

Adjustments
  • asking comps x0.5-0.6 to private-clear (method 3.3)
  • large plinth = freight/buyer-mobility penalty x0.8
  • 'solid' claim unsupported: valued at veneer-class prices
  • octagonal form is a demand headwind vs round
Verdict: CONSIDER · upside A$70 vs the A$150 ask · confidence medium
Comparable evidence
no image
ds-021 · Gumtree Australia · A$80
$80 sold floor for commodity dining — this is larger and timber-look so sits above it
no image
ds-023 · Gumtree Australia (PriceWorth Rocklea) · A$399
$399 is a trade asking for veneer sets; private clearing of the same class halves, putting mid near $220

#084 Antique classic solid wood round Pedestal Dining Table.

A$250
Brisbane, QLD · — · View listing

Four photos, unusually including the underside. A 124 cm round top on a turned pedestal with four splayed feet, dark warm finish. What the photos support: an old, heavy, well-worn piece (condition field even says Fair) with ring and scratch wear. What they do not support: 'antique cedar' — the finish reads as a later dark poly/stain, and no hand-worked jointing, tilt mechanism or segmented-top detail is legible to confirm 19th-century colonial pedigree. Priced at the trade floor of the unremarkable-colonial band ($150-250 refs) with upside only if inspection proves cedar.

CONSIDERroundlow
Antique classic solid wood round Pedestal Dining Table. photoAntique classic solid wood round Pedestal Dining Table. photoAntique classic solid wood round Pedestal Dining Table. photoAntique classic solid wood round Pedestal Dining Table. photo

Identification & condition

Form
round
Maker or style
Australian colonial-style pedestal round table (cedar claim unproven; could be later stained hardwood or a 20th-c reproduction)
Material
timber throughout incl. underside; top shows no clear seam/segment lines in photos; finish is a later dark film, not French polish
Period
claimed 19th c; photos support 'old' but cannot date past c.1880-1930
Construction
Centre turned column, four splayed turned feet; underside shows old construction with iron bracketry/strap fixing to the top; no tilt mechanism visible — appears a fixed round
Dimensions (est.)
124 cm diameter as stated; photos consistent against adjacent chair height
Condition grade
fair

Visible in photos: Surface rings, scratches and finish wear consistent with the seller's own 'Fair'; heavy dust/age on the underside (genuinely old-looking); no missing parts; top edges look intact in the close-ups

Can't see from these photos: timber species — cedar vs stained pine/hardwood is undecidable in photos / whether the top is solid segmented planks or a later board/veneer replacement / joint integrity of pedestal-to-base and any worm

Photo limits: ['Species (cedar?) not verifiable from photos — the single biggest value swing', 'No legible label, pencil mark or dovetail detail visible to date it', 'Underside photos show age but resolution too low to separate hand-cut from early-machine joinery']

Appraisal confidence: low

Adversarial review · agree_with_caveat · arithmetic: sound · recomputed margin: A$20 · comp support: strong · ask integrity: no audit row (card A$250 adopted) · biggest downside: Woodworm is a walk-away; even without it the net margin is $20 — this is a keep-an-eye-on-it, not a purchase · · cost if wrong A$250 ·

Arithmetic ok and all four comps exist (aus-011 $1,495 hammer, aus-016 $1,500 retail, etc.) with dealer prices properly discounted. Caveat: with net-ask = $20, CONSIDER is the most generous reading; woodworm holes in photo 2 make PASS equally defensible.

Ask versus value

Estimated value: A$180 – A$600 (mid A$320) · refs aus-018 / aus-024 / aus-016 / aus-011

Basis: An unmarked, worn pedestal round with unproven age prices off the trade floor band, not the five-figure museum cedars; the wide band is exactly the difference between 'later commercial table' and 'genuine cedar colonial'.

Ask A$250 → upside A$70 (value mid − ask)

If resold: private net A$270 · auction net A$170 · retail asking A$500

Adjustments
  • retail-asking comps x0.55-0.6 to private net (method 3.3)
  • C_cond ~0.8 for Fair-grade wear and later poly finish
  • antique claim unverified: band straddles repro floor (~$200) and genuine-cedar ceiling (~$600)
  • fixed (non-tilt) round discounts vs tilt-top comps
Verdict: CONSIDER · upside A$70 vs the A$250 ask · confidence low
Comparable evidence
no image
aus-018 · Theodore Bruce Auctions · A$200
Direct signal: mahogany circular tilt-top on 3-foot pedestal — trade estimate only $150-250, passed; this piece's floor unless proven better
no image
aus-024 · eBay Australia · A$210
eBay ask of $210 obo is the bottom of the online asking market for unremarkable colonial cedar tables
no image
aus-016 · Ipswich Antique Centre (QLD) · A$1,500
Ipswich dealer asking $1,500 for a comparable round colonial — retail-asking ceiling; x0.55 private-adjusted because ours lacks inlay/provenance and is Fair grade
comparable aus-011
aus-011 · Antiques Reporter (Davidson Auctions) · A$1,495
Plain cedar table hammered $1,495 (2008) — confirms real cedar with any decorative merit outperforms, the upside case for this one

#085 Antique dining table

A$150
Brisbane, QLD · Listed 2 days ago in Brisbane, QLD · View listing

Seller's 'very heavy solid table' reads true from the photos — solid timber top and a colonial-revival base — but he also volunteers it is scratched and needs sanding, and the images show just that: light honey timber, a thin worn film finish, and surface scratches. Photos support neither 'antique' nor a particular maker: cabriole legs with pad feet are a style revived throughout the 20th century. Value as a solid project table only; at $150 ask the refinish cost (~$300-500) exceeds the margin the piece could carry.

CONSIDERrectangularlow
Antique dining table photoAntique dining table photo

Identification & condition

Form
rectangular
Maker or style
Colonial-revival dining table, maker unknown
Material
Solid timber — light honey colour suggests light-stained hardwood or pine; oak NOT supported by photos (no fleck, wrong colour)
Period
Mid-20th century reproduction most likely; pre-1920 not excluded
Construction
Rectangular top, rounded corners, thin moulded apron, cabriole legs with pad feet
Dimensions (est.)
1800 × 1050 mm (seller-stated, plausible)
Condition grade
fair

Visible in photos: Obvious surface scratches and finish wear; structurally appears sound and heavy

Can't see from these photos: U / n / d / e / r / s / i / d / e / / / j / o / i / n / t / s / , / / l / e / a / f / / p / r / e / s / e / n / c / e / , / / w / o / b / b / l / e / , / / t / r / u / e / / t / i / m / b / e / r / / I / D

Photo limits: Underside and joint type; whether 'solid' claim is top-only or base too; true timber species.

Appraisal confidence: low

Ask versus value

Estimated value: A$120 – A$280 (mid A$180) · refs aus-018 / ds-023

Basis: Plain refinish-project colonial-revival table: dealer-band low comp $200 cut ~10% for condition and channel

Ask A$150 → upside A$30 (value mid − ask)

If resold: private net A$150 · auction net A$80 · retail asking A$260

Adjustments
  • C_cond 0.55 (needs full refinish — seller says so)
  • C_orig 0.75 (worn film finish, timber unproven)
  • C_channel ×0.75 (private SEQ resale, bulky flat-packing only for a car)
  • −10% vs dealer comp for buyer's refinish burden
Verdict: CONSIDER · upside A$30 vs the A$150 ask · confidence low
Comparable evidence
no image
aus-018 · Theodore Bruce Auctions · A$200
Plain old table at dealer ask; note says plain colonial-style reads $50–$250 — this needs a $300+ refinish, so low end
no image
ds-023 · Gumtree Australia (PriceWorth Rocklea) · A$399
Local intact 105cm table clearing $399; this is bigger but far worse condition — cut to 45%

#087 Antique English Oak Dining Table — [price: search card A$200 vs detail page A$14,000 — card price used; detail figure treated as a scrape artefact]

A$200
Brisbane, QLD · Listed 6 weeks ago in Brisbane, QLD · View listing

Photos do NOT support 'Antique English Oak'. What they show is a single-board round top on a turned pedestal with four splayed pad-foot legs and a horizontal strap rail — a 19th-C American tavern/pedestal FORM — in dark, evenly stained timber with a fresh satin poly film; no pale quarter-sawn oak fleck, no aged patina, no radial plank seams or wedge marks. Either refinished softwood/other hardwood, or a reproduction; the $200 ask is only interesting if it is genuinely old, which the pictures cannot establish. Chairs in the shots are mismatched modern pieces.

CONSIDERroundmedium
Antique English Oak Dining Table — [price: search card A$200 vs detail page A$14,000 — card price used; detail figure treated as a scrape artefact] photoAntique English Oak Dining Table — [price: search card A$200 vs detail page A$14,000 — card price used; detail figure treated as a scrape artefact] photoAntique English Oak Dining Table — [price: search card A$200 vs detail page A$14,000 — card price used; detail figure treated as a scrape artefact] photoAntique English Oak Dining Table — [price: search card A$200 vs detail page A$14,000 — card price used; detail figure treated as a scrape artefact] photoAntique English Oak Dining Table — [price: search card A$200 vs detail page A$14,000 — card price used; detail figure treated as a scrape artefact] photoAntique English Oak Dining Table — [price: search card A$200 vs detail page A$14,000 — card price used; detail figure treated as a scrape artefact] photo

Identification & condition

Form
round
Maker or style
American-style pedestal/tavern table form; claimed 'English oak' unconfirmed
Material
Dark-stained timber — photos show uniform stain and new poly, not quarter-sawn English oak; possibly refinished oak, possibly softwood
Period
Form suggests 19th-C origin IF old; photos consistent with 20th-C reproduction or refinish
Construction
Single-panel round top, turned pedestal, four splayed legs, strap rail; metal strap under top likely a later tie-rod repair
Dimensions (est.)
1500 × 1000 mm (seller-stated, matches)
Condition grade
moderate

Visible in photos: Fresh satin film finish over dark stain; light wear; no dramatic damage; metal tie-rod suggests past top movement/repair

Can't see from these photos: U / n / d / e / r / s / i / d / e / , / / a / n / y / / s / t / a / m / p / s / , / / t / i / m / b / e / r / / a / t / / a / n / / u / n / s / t / a / i / n / e / d / / c / h / i / p / , / / j / o / i / n / t / / t / y / p / e

Photo limits: Underside construction and any labels; timber species at an unstained edge; whether the base is original to the top.

Appraisal confidence: medium

Adversarial review · agree · arithmetic: sound · recomputed margin: A$20 · comp support: weak · ask integrity: suspect (no audit row; card A$200 adopted over A$14,000 artefact) · biggest downside: Not oak at all (softwood) — resale ~$120, loss ~$80 if you actually buy · · cost if wrong A$80 ·

Correctly NOT a BUY (20 << 150). aus-025 ($390 dealer pedestal) and aus-018 ($200 ref, estimate passed) exist; the -35% channel and -20% refinish cuts are visible in the adjustments. The unproven 'English oak' claim is flagged, not priced.

Ask versus value

Estimated value: A$150 – A$400 (mid A$250) · refs aus-025 / aus-018

Basis: Unmarkable, refinished-looking pedestal table: dealer band $200–$390 discounted to private market

Ask A$200 → upside A$50 (value mid − ask)

If resold: private net A$220 · auction net A$110 · retail asking A$350

Adjustments
  • C_orig 0.6 (refinished/new poly; 'English oak' claim unsupported)
  • C_cond 0.9 (light wear)
  • C_channel ×0.7 (internet/dealer comp → local private)
  • −15% for suspected tie-rod repair under top
Verdict: CONSIDER · upside A$50 vs the A$200 ask · confidence medium
Comparable evidence
no image
aus-025 · Murphy's Antiques and Restorations · A$390
Closest form comp (pedestal, 1830s format) at dealer ask; −35% channel/ask discount and −20% because our piece is refinished and its timber claim fails the photo test
no image
aus-018 · Theodore Bruce Auctions · A$200
Floor for a plain old table with no provenance in a thin market

#088 Antique dining table and matching imported chairs

A$350
Brisbane, QLD · Listed 15 weeks ago in Brisbane, QLD · View listing

rustic country-style 7-piece suite; seller claims Australian-made 100+ yr table + Asian hardwood/cane chairs; single photo looks more like a 20th-c 'Old English' reproduction than an antique, disputed: seller says 100+ years; photos consistent with c.1970s reproduction. Condition fair: surface looks sound and lightly used in the one photo; cane intact; no photo of legs' underside, feet, or top detail THREE-PRICE DISPUTE: card A$350 vs detail-page A$150 vs seller's own text 'Asking $600'. Adopted A$350: the description's $600 is self-stated but the listing is 15 weeks old (prices fall, text usually not updated); the A$150 detail capture used the first-direct-text-A$ method, carries no second-source cross-check for this seq (unlike siblings), and the same scraper is known to have produced a bogus A$14,000 elsewhere - lowest, least-corroborated number discounted. The card A$350 is an independently captured structured price and is mid-range of the three - most likely live. SENSITIVITY: at A$150 verdict BUY (A$430 net = 2.9x); at A$350 verdict CONSIDER (needs A$455 at the 1.30 margin, short); at A$600 verdict PASS (negative). Value basis: photo shows rectangular honey-timber table with heavy turned (barley-twist/bun) legs plus 6 cane-back hardwood chairs; reads a rustic 'country-style' 7-piece suite, likely late-20th-c reproduction, not the 100+yr antique the seller claims; 1 photo only

CONSIDERrectangularlow
Antique dining table and matching imported chairs photo

Identification & condition

Form
rectangular
Maker or style
rustic country-style 7-piece suite; seller claims Australian-made 100+ yr table + Asian hardwood/cane chairs; single photo looks more like a 20th-c 'Old English' reproduction than an antique
Material
honey-stained hardwood table, barley-twist/bun-turned legs; 6 chairs with cane backs and cane seats
Period
disputed: seller says 100+ years; photos consistent with c.1970s reproduction
Construction
thick apron, heavy turned legs, chamfered top corners; chairs are matching-cane imported type (seller says so)
Dimensions (est.)
~150-170 x 90 cm, est. from chair scale
Condition grade
fair

Visible in photos: surface looks sound and lightly used in the one photo; cane intact; no photo of legs' underside, feet, or top detail

Can't see from these photos: a / g / e / / m / a / r / k / e / r / s / / ( / h / a / n / d / - / c / u / t / / j / o / i / n / t / s / , / / s / c / r / e / w / / t / y / p / e / , / / p / a / t / i / n / a / / u / n / d / e / r / / f / i / n / i / s / h / ) / , / / a / n / y / / d / a / m / a / g / e / , / / c / h / a / i / r / - / t / o / - / t / a / b / l / e / / a / g / e / / m / a / t / c / h

Photo limits: live asking price is unresolved (A$150 card-no/detail-A$150/text-A$600 analysis in basis; verdict BUY at 150, CONSIDER at 350, PASS at 600); underside/joinery to date the table; second photos of top and chairs

Appraisal confidence: low

Adversarial review · agree · arithmetic: sound · recomputed margin: A$80 · comp support: weak · ask integrity: suspect (no audit row; A$350 adopted by judgment; 150/350/600 sensitivity stated) · biggest downside: If the seller's $600 text is the live price the verdict flips to PASS; single photo makes the whole identification shaky · · cost if wrong A$450 ·

Three-price sensitivity IS explicitly stated (BUY at $150 / CONSIDER at $350 / PASS at $600) as required. No audit row exists for 88, so the adopted $350 is an argued judgment, correctly labelled. 430-350=80 < 150 floor -> CONSIDER, not BUY, follows.

Ask versus value

Estimated value: A$300 – A$650 (mid A$450) · refs sp-009 / sp-012

Basis: THREE-PRICE DISPUTE: card A$350 vs detail-page A$150 vs seller's own text 'Asking $600'. Adopted A$350: the description's $600 is self-stated but the listing is 15 weeks old (prices fall, text usually not updated); the A$150 detail capture used the first-direct-text-A$ method, carries no second-source cross-check for this seq (unlike siblings), and the same scraper is known to have produced a bogus A$14,000 elsewhere - lowest, least-corroborated number discounted. The card A$350 is an independently captured structured price and is mid-range of the three - most likely live. SENSITIVITY: at A$150 verdict BUY (A$430 net = 2.9x); at A$350 verdict CONSIDER (needs A$455 at the 1.30 margin, short); at A$600 verdict PASS (negative). Value basis: photo shows rectangular honey-timber table with heavy turned (barley-twist/bun) legs plus 6 cane-back hardwood chairs; reads a rustic 'country-style' 7-piece suite, likely late-20th-c reproduction, not the 100+yr antique the seller claims; 1 photo only.

Ask A$350 → upside A$100 (value mid − ask)

If resold: private net A$430 · auction net A$180 · retail asking A$700

Adjustments
  • -only one photo; authenticity of 'antique' claim untestable
  • -chairs stated imported, so not a true antique matched suite
  • -price itself unreliable (3 conflicting figures)
Verdict: CONSIDER · upside A$100 vs the A$350 ask · confidence low
Comparable evidence
comparable sp-009
sp-009 · Antiques Reporter (auction record) · A$1,680
auction A$1,680 for a matching six-piece cane setting; here the chairs are imported and don't match the table's claimed age and the table reads rustic/repro -> ~70% discount -> mid A$450 private
comparable sp-012
sp-012 · MM Furniture (Sunshine Coast QLD dealer) · A$300
cane table+chairs set sold A$300 - floor support for mismatched cane suites

#089 Antique dining table and 6 chairs

A$150
Brisbane, QLD · Listed 23 weeks ago in Brisbane, QLD · View listing

Seller says 'antique' and the photos say: a painted-over, marker-scribbled, scratched matching set needing full restoration. Legs are straight and tapering, apron plain, chairs the matching side type — a colonial-style suite, painted finish destroying any figure underneath. No positive age evidence in the photos (no patina visible, no joint or underside view), so 'antique' is unproven; whether C1900 or 1950, painted-plus-abused sets clear in the low hundreds here, and the extension leaf claim is not visible in either photo.

CONSIDERrectangularlow
Antique dining table and 6 chairs photoAntique dining table and 6 chairs photo

Identification & condition

Form
rectangular
Maker or style
Colonial-style dining suite, painted, maker unknown
Material
Timber under paint (species unreadable); possibly cedar, possibly pine — photos cannot say
Period
Unresolved: 1890s–1960s; style colonial-revival
Construction
Rectangular top, plain apron, straight tapered legs; claimed extension leaf not visible
Dimensions (est.)
~1500 × 900 mm (inferred; seller gives none)
Condition grade
poor

Visible in photos: Faded paint, scratches, marker pen, chair wear; needs full strip/refinish and likely reglue

Can't see from these photos: U / n / d / e / r / s / i / d / e / , / / l / e / a / f / , / / j / o / i / n / t / s / , / / w / o / b / b / l / e / , / / w / h / e / t / h / e / r / / t / i / m / b / e / r / / u / n / d / e / r / / p / a / i / n / t / / i / s / / f / i / g / u / r / e / d / / / c / e / d / a / r

Photo limits: Leaf presence, timber under paint, underside/joints, extent of structural damage.

Appraisal confidence: low

Ask versus value

Estimated value: A$120 – A$350 (mid A$220) · refs sp-012 / aus-015

Basis: Painted, marker-damaged project suite: value = salvage of a 7-piece set after ~$600 restoration spend

Ask A$150 → upside A$70 (value mid − ask)

If resold: private net A$190 · auction net A$90 · retail asking A$350

Adjustments
  • C_cond 0.55 (needs restoration)
  • C_orig 0.55 (paint over timber)
  • C_complete 0.85 (leaf claimed but not visible)
  • C_channel ×0.7 (1stDibs comp)
  • −10% local market thinness for painted sets
Verdict: CONSIDER · upside A$70 vs the A$150 ask · confidence low
Comparable evidence
comparable sp-012
sp-012 · MM Furniture (Sunshine Coast QLD dealer) · A$300
Intact cane set cleared $300; ours is bigger but in far worse cosmetic state — −25%
no image
aus-015 · Bonhams Australia (Colonial Sale, Sydney) · A$2,500
Ceiling for a refinished cedar colonial — ours must be cut ~80% for paint, damage, no provenance and internet-channel discount

#090 Antique dining room table — [price: search card A$150 vs detail page A$14,000 — card price used; $14,000 figure treated as the known scrape artefact and never adopted]

A$150
Brisbane, QLD · Listed in Brisbane, QLD · View listing

The best photos in this batch, and the only real candidate. What the pictures show: an oval-topped extension table on genuine cabriole legs with pad feet and a thin moulded apron, light satin walnut/hardwood tone, stored in a shed WITH its two loose inserts stacked on the top — the seller's 'two timber inserts' claim is visible, unlike 89. The crank/windlass mechanism itself is not shown working, but the form (cabriole + windlass + inserts) is the classic interwar extension design, and this finish reads a careful old polish or a sympathetic light refinish rather than a botch. At the card price of $150 this is worth a phone call before anyone else's; note the detail page shows A$14,000 — treat as scrape artefact and transact at the card price.

BUYroundmedium
Antique dining room table — [price: search card A$150 vs detail page A$14,000 — card price used; $14,000 figure treated as the known scrape artefact and never adopted] photoAntique dining room table — [price: search card A$150 vs detail page A$14,000 — card price used; $14,000 figure treated as the known scrape artefact and never adopted] photoAntique dining room table — [price: search card A$150 vs detail page A$14,000 — card price used; $14,000 figure treated as the known scrape artefact and never adopted] photoAntique dining room table — [price: search card A$150 vs detail page A$14,000 — card price used; $14,000 figure treated as the known scrape artefact and never adopted] photoAntique dining room table — [price: search card A$150 vs detail page A$14,000 — card price used; $14,000 figure treated as the known scrape artefact and never adopted] photo

Identification & condition

Form
round
Maker or style
Interwar/Edwardian-style windlass extension dining table
Material
Likely satin walnut / light hardwood (mahogany possible); photos do not support cedar
Period
c.1920–1960; not pre-1900
Construction
Oval top, moulded edge, cabriole legs with pad feet; two loose inserts present on top; crank/windlass extension claimed, mechanism not visible
Dimensions (est.)
1660 × 1140 mm + 2×300 mm inserts (seller-stated, consistent)
Condition grade
good

Visible in photos: Light even patina, some apron scuffs/finish wear near the rails; inserts present; nothing broken visible

Can't see from these photos: W / i / n / d / l / a / s / s / / m / e / c / h / a / n / i / s / m / , / / u / n / d / e / r / s / i / d / e / , / / l / e / a / f / / g / r / o / o / v / e / s / / m / a / t / c / h / , / / w / o / b / b / l / e

Photo limits: Crank mechanism condition, underside joints, leaf groove wear, exact species, wobble.

Appraisal confidence: medium

Adversarial review · agree_with_caveat · arithmetic: sound · recomputed margin: A$430 · comp support: strong · ask integrity: suspect (no audit row; card A$150 adopted; A$14,000 artefact in title needs in-person confirmation) · biggest downside: Leaves/rails are never actually shown and mechanism unverified; worst case it is a plain 1930s interwar extension in lesser timber — net ~$360-450, still above ask · · cost if wrong A$220 ·

This is the strongest BUY in the set: 580-150=430 >= max(0.30*650,$150)=$195 at medium confidence, comps exist and the ×0.85×0.7 dealer-to-private discount arithmetic checks out exactly (1,250→744→~650). Caveats: my photo re-check could not see the leaves that the 0.8 completeness factor assumes, and the ask is the card price (no audit row) with a known A$14,000 detail artefact — confirm price and leaves in person before paying.

Ask versus value

Estimated value: A$400 – A$950 (mid A$650) · refs sp-008 / sp-028 / aus-008

Basis: Working windlass extension with both inserts: dealer asking comps for Edwardian extensions discounted hard to local private, then cut for unverified mechanism and unproven species

Ask A$150 → upside A$500 (value mid − ask)

If resold: private net A$580 · auction net A$300 · retail asking A$950

Adjustments
  • C_complete 0.8 (inserts shown, mechanism unverified/possibly stiff)
  • C_orig 0.85 (finish may be lightly refinished; hardware not visible)
  • C_channel ×0.7 vs dealer comps
  • Species haircut vs cedar benchmarks: −55%
Verdict: BUY · upside A$500 vs the A$150 ask · confidence medium
Comparable evidence
comparable sp-008
sp-008 · Moonee Ponds Antiques (Melbourne dealer) · A$1,250
Australian Edwardian extension at dealer ask; ×0.85 ask-to-sold ×0.7 channel ≈ $740, then −12% for our lighter timber read and unverified crank
comparable sp-028
sp-028 · Nord Modern (Brunswick, Melbourne vintage dealer) · A$850
QLD walnut extension, retail asking; ×0.7 ≈ $600 — brackets our mid from below
comparable aus-008
aus-008 · Antiques Reporter (Gowans Auctions) · A$5,226
Upper bound for genuine cedar 2-leaf work — we are NOT in that class (wrong species, no proof); cited to show the discount is deliberate

#091 Antique card table

A$900
Brisbane, QLD · Listed 2 days ago in Brisbane, QLD · View listing

Appraised as the piece it actually IS: a folding card table, not dining. And the photos say reproduction, not antique: four drop-flap triangles with moulded edges and bright brass butt-hinges, a BRIGHT GREEN modern nylon-look felt (not period baize, not even a replacement in period cloth), glossy light-rosy timber with sharp machine-turned taper legs, and drilled chip-rings in the flaps. Everything reads late 20th-century 'Chippendale-style' games table, likely $150–$300 stock. $900 is 3–4× what it can return on resale. (Form enum forced to round|oval|rectangular|square — recorded as square.)

PASSsquaremedium
Antique card table photoAntique card table photo

Identification & condition

Form
square
Maker or style
Chippendale-style folding card table, reproduction, likely 1970s–90s
Material
Glossy rosy hardwood/veneer (mahogany-look); modern synthetic green felt top
Period
Late 20th century reproduction; photos show no 19th-C evidence
Construction
Four hinged drop flaps, brass butt-hinges, turned taper legs with stretchers, drilled chip wells
Dimensions (est.)
~900 mm square open, folded ~half depth (inferred)
Condition grade
good

Visible in photos: Felt appears new; finish glossy and clean; hinges bright; nothing broken

Can't see from these photos: U / n / d / e / r / s / i / d / e / / l / a / b / e / l / , / / f / r / a / m / e / / j / o / i / n / e / r / y / , / / w / h / e / t / h / e / r / / f / e / l / t / / i / s / / o / r / i / g / i / n / a / l / - / o / r / - / r / e / p / l / a / c / e / d

Photo limits: Underside marks; felt originality; exact size.

Appraisal confidence: medium

Ask versus value

Estimated value: A$150 – A$400 (mid A$250) · refs aus-018 / sp-012

Basis: Reproduction folding card tables are commodity stock: local $200 floor–$400 dealer ceiling

Ask A$900 → upside A$−650 (value mid − ask)

If resold: private net A$250 · auction net A$120 · retail asking A$400

Adjustments
  • Reproduction status: −60% vs what a genuine Georgian/Victorian card table would fetch
  • C_channel ×0.7 to private
  • No auction interest expected below $500 — auction net cut hard
Verdict: PASS · upside A$−650 vs the A$900 ask · confidence medium
Comparable evidence
no image
aus-018 · Theodore Bruce Auctions · A$200
Note: plain old tables read $50–$250 at dealer level; a reproduction card table sits at the same floor — closest available band in the library (no local card-table comps — flagged in notes)
comparable sp-012
sp-012 · MM Furniture (Sunshine Coast QLD dealer) · A$300
What SEQ private buyers actually pay for small novelty timber sets

#093 Dining table

A$175
Brisbane, QLD · Listed 6 days ago in Brisbane, QLD · View listing

Photos show exactly what the title says: a generic 1.8 m rectangular table with rounded corners, medium-stained glossy timber, turned legs, and four mismatched-looking chairs with 'love marks' as advertised. No antique or colonial claim is made and none is needed — this is 1970s–90s rustic/farmhouse stock, solid-looking, cosmetically tired. These clear cheap and slow in SEQ; nothing here beats the $175 ask by a tradeable margin, though it is the sort of set a private buyer moves easily at ~$200.

CONSIDERrectangularmedium
Dining table photoDining table photoDining table photoDining table photoDining table photo

Identification & condition

Form
rectangular
Maker or style
1970s–90s rustic/farmhouse dining set, maker unknown
Material
Solid-looking timber, medium walnut-tone stain, poly film
Period
Late 20th century
Construction
Rectangular top, rounded corners, plain apron, turned legs; 4 chairs
Dimensions (est.)
~1800 × 900 mm (seller-stated)
Condition grade
fair

Visible in photos: Surface marks and wear consistent with 'some love marks'; chairs scuffed; no breakage visible

Can't see from these photos: U / n / d / e / r / s / i / d / e / , / / j / o / i / n / t / s / , / / w / o / b / b / l / e / , / / t / r / u / e / / s / p / e / c / i / e / s

Photo limits: Underside/joints, species, chair repair history.

Appraisal confidence: medium

Ask versus value

Estimated value: A$150 – A$320 (mid A$220) · refs ds-022 / sp-012

Basis: Ordinary late-C20 set at private-market clearing level

Ask A$175 → upside A$45 (value mid − ask)

If resold: private net A$200 · auction net A$100 · retail asking A$330

Adjustments
  • C_cond 0.75 (visible wear)
  • C_channel ×1.0 (comps already private/local)
  • Size ≥1.8m: harder to shift, no premium
Verdict: CONSIDER · upside A$45 vs the A$175 ask · confidence medium
Comparable evidence
no image
ds-022 · Gumtree Australia · A$150
Local private clearing point for ordinary 4-seat sets; ours adds table size and 4 chairs — +45%
comparable sp-012
sp-012 · MM Furniture (Sunshine Coast QLD dealer) · A$300
Upper end of what a full table+chairs set has cleared privately in Brisbane

#095 Round dining table

A$100 (card price; detail page showed A$300 — >20% disagreement, card adopted)
Brassall QLD · Listed 2 weeks ago · View listing

Ordinary ~105 cm round table, decent condition but commodity resale — priced fairly, no margin.

CONSIDERroundmedium
Round dining table photoRound dining table photoRound dining table photoRound dining table photoRound dining table photo

Identification & condition

Form
round
Maker or style
Unbranded contemporary round dining table; turned four-leg base with stretchers
Material
Claims solid wood; photos show a warm mid-brown finish, edge band reads thin — solid softwood or veneered top more likely than solid hardwood; no teak figure visible
Period
2000s–2020s
Construction
Four turned legs with low stretchers; top appears flat with a simple moulded edge; no extension leaf visible in any photo
Dimensions (est.)
≈105 cm dia × 75 cm h (seller states 1055 × 750 mm; photos consistent)
Condition grade
good

Visible in photos: Five photos show a clean top, minor surface scratches as described, finish intact, no chips or water rings visible; one photo shows dark/black legs under a runner — possibly a different finish angle, ambiguous

Can't see from these photos: underside and joinery / edge banding detail (solid vs veneer) / weight/stability

Photo limits: Underside/joinery and edge construction — cannot confirm the seller's solid-wood claim or rule out a veneered top; detail-page price (A$300) disagrees with the card (A$100), card used.

Appraisal confidence: medium

Adversarial review · agree_with_caveat · arithmetic: sound · recomputed margin: A$0 · comp support: strong · ask integrity: suspect (card A$100 vs detail A$300 unresolved, no audit row) · biggest downside: If the detail page's $300 is the live price, upside is -130 and the verdict is PASS · · cost if wrong A$0 ·

Comps exist and are honest (ds-022 $150 near-new caps, ds-021 $80 floor). Caveat: unresolved card $100 vs detail $300 disagreement, no audit row — CONSIDER only holds at the card price; treat as unverified until re-checked.

Ask versus value

Estimated value: A$60 – A$150 (mid A$130) · refs ds-022 / ds-021

Basis: Anchored to local asking prices for ordinary round tables (ds-022 near-new $150; ds-021 floor $80), discounted for private resale.

Ask A$100 → upside A$30 (value mid − ask)

If resold: private net A$100 · auction net A$40 · retail asking A$180

Adjustments
  • −15% for unknown timber/veneer vs solid
  • −10% private-sale channel vs asking price
  • + modest premium over ds-021 floor for 105 cm size and clean condition
Verdict: CONSIDER · upside A$30 vs the A$100 ask · confidence medium
Comparable evidence
no image
ds-022 · Gumtree Australia · A$150
Near-new 4-seat round table asks $150 locally — used examples must sit under that
no image
ds-021 · Gumtree Australia · A$80
Sets the true Marketplace floor ($80) for unbranded round tables

#098 IKEA round table solid wood

A$50
Brisbane 4300 (cash only) · Listed 22 hours ago · View listing

Genuine IKEA GAMLARED — but it is solid PINE, not a premium solid wood; A$50 is fair price with zero resale margin. Not worth the trip unless you are already passing.

CONSIDERroundmedium
IKEA round table solid wood photo

Identification & condition

Form
round
Maker or style
IKEA GAMLARED round table, light antique stain / black-stained legs (model confirmed by seller text and matching IKEA product imagery)
Material
Solid pine with stain and acrylic lacquer (IKEA spec: 'Solid pine, Stain, Clear acrylic lacquer') — the 'solid wood' claim is TRUE but it is softwood pine, not oak/acacia
Period
2016–discontinued c.2023
Construction
Planked pine top with visible board joints and end grain (checked in zoom crop), four black-stained turned legs, dowel/screw fixings
Dimensions (est.)
85 cm dia × 75 cm h (seller's claim matches IKEA spec exactly)
Condition grade
good

Visible in photos: Single photo, zoomed: top shows some dents/scratches in soft pine and light staining consistent with age; no cracked boards, no swollen or delaminated edges (rules out particleboard); legs sound-looking

Can't see from these photos: full top in one frame (one photo only) / wobble at leg fixings / underside

Photo limits: Only one photo — cannot see the whole top, the leg fixings or the underside; the model ID rests on seller text plus IKEA's own product match, so a physical check would still be needed.

Appraisal confidence: medium

Ask versus value

Estimated value: A$40 – A$110 (mid A$70) · refs ds-022 / ds-021

Basis: Discontinued-model premium is thin: eBay asks ~A$150–350 for GAMLAREDs must be cut 20–35% per asking-price rule, then discounted to local private resale against commodity round-table comps.

Ask A$50 → upside A$20 (value mid − ask)

If resold: private net A$60 · auction net A$25 · retail asking A$110

Adjustments
  • −30% on eBay GAMLARED asks (~A$150+) per asking-price discount rule
  • + small discontinued-model bump (+A$10–20) for the name recognition
  • −15% for single-photo listing and softwood dents
Verdict: CONSIDER · upside A$20 vs the A$50 ask · confidence medium
Comparable evidence
no image
ds-022 · Gumtree Australia · A$150
A near-new round table asks $150 — an 85 cm used pine IKEA cannot beat that
no image
ds-021 · Gumtree Australia · A$80
$80 floor for table-plus-chairs locally caps a lone 85 cm pine table

#100 Round table

A$50
Riverhills QLD · Listed a week ago · View listing

Black round 110 cm table of unidentifiable make; commodity item, resale net barely matches the ask — not worth the trip.

CONSIDERroundlow
Round table photoRound table photoRound table photo

Identification & condition

Form
round
Maker or style
Unbranded contemporary black round dining table
Material
Black-painted/laminated top over a dark base; photos cannot distinguish painted solid wood, painted MDF or laminate — the dark finish hides all grain
Period
2010s–2020s
Construction
Turned/pedestal-style dark legs; smooth black top with a simple edge; no leaves visible; 'leg protectors included' per seller
Dimensions (est.)
≈110 cm dia × 74 cm h (seller claim; photos consistent)
Condition grade
fair

Visible in photos: Three photos show the black top with light scuffs/scratches typical of painted or laminate surfaces; no large chips or water damage visible at the photo resolution

Can't see from these photos: material under the black finish / edge chips at photo resolution / underside/joinery / stability

Photo limits: The black finish defeats identification entirely — no grain, no edge construction, no label visible in any of the three photos; cannot tell solid wood from painted particleboard, which is the whole value question.

Appraisal confidence: low

Ask versus value

Estimated value: A$40 – A$100 (mid A$70) · refs ds-022 / ds-021

Basis: Commodity black round tables resell at the flat-pack floor; anchored to near-new equivalent ds-022 and floor comp ds-021.

Ask A$50 → upside A$20 (value mid − ask)

If resold: private net A$60 · auction net A$25 · retail asking A$120

Adjustments
  • −20% for unknown material (painted finishes hide defects)
  • + small bump for 110 cm size vs the 90 cm comps
  • −10% private channel vs asking
Verdict: CONSIDER · upside A$20 vs the A$50 ask · confidence low
Comparable evidence
no image
ds-022 · Gumtree Australia · A$150
Near-new 4-seat black round table asks $150 — used unbranded examples clear well under that
no image
ds-021 · Gumtree Australia · A$80
Demonstrates the $80 local floor for unbranded round tables

#101 Cane honymoon dining setting

A$250 (card price; detail page showed A$32,500 — scrape artefact, card adopted)
Brisbane QLD · Listed recently · View listing

Three-piece rattan suite in sound condition — but cane is a fallen category and this is a 1970s–80s reproduction, not an antique; A$250 is above the realistic resale net.

PASSovalmedium
Cane honymoon dining setting photoCane honymoon dining setting photoCane honymoon dining setting photoCane honymoon dining setting photoCane honymoon dining setting photo

Identification & condition

Form
oval
Maker or style
Cane/rattan 'honeymoon'-style three-piece setting: oval glass-top table with lattice skirt plus two chairs (cane backs, cushioned seats)
Material
Glossy honey-finish laminated-bamboo/rattan frame with machine-woven cane panels and drop-in oval glass top
Period
1970s–1980s reproduction styling, NOT genuine c.1900–30 honeymoon antique — the photos show uniform glossy laminated bends, machined cane mesh and a cushion-and-glass configuration typical of the 70s revival
Construction
Bent laminated-cane frames with whipping at joints; drop-in glass on a fitted frame; chairs have fixed caned back panels and loose cushions
Dimensions (est.)
Table ≈ 100–110 × 55 cm oval × 70–75 cm h; chairs ≈ 68 cm h (comparable to sp-012 dimensions)
Condition grade
good

Visible in photos: Five photos: cane panels intact with no visible tears, holes or repairs; glass top present and uncracked; frames sound with no obvious breaks; cushions stained/dated but intact; stored on carpet against curtain

Can't see from these photos: looseness of frame joints (cannot rack-test from photos) / underside of table / whether cane is sun-brittle / honest colour under indoor lighting

Photo limits: Frame looseness and cane brittleness cannot be tested in photos; era call (70s reproduction) is from style and finish, not a label — but even genuine antique would change little, since the specialty notes price the whole category as styling, not antiques.

Appraisal confidence: medium

Ask versus value

Estimated value: A$100 – A$300 (mid A$200) · refs sp-012 / sp-009 / sp-011

Basis: Priced to the fallen-category private band ($300–800 only for full settings in good condition at the top end; this 3-piece 70s reproduction sits at the bottom of it, anchored to the $300 dealer-retail floor comp).

Ask A$250 → upside A$−50 (value mid − ask)

If resold: private net A$160 · auction net A$60 · retail asking A$300

Adjustments
  • −50 to −60% dealer-retail-to-private-channel discount off sp-012's $300
  • − reproduction-era discount: no antique premium applied (specialty notes: do not value cane as antique)
  • + nothing for the glass top — it is expected on this form
  • − unsold-risk allowance: Leonard Joel 2024 saw cane suites on $200–360 estimates go UNSOLD
Verdict: PASS · upside A$−50 vs the A$250 ask · confidence medium
Comparable evidence
comparable sp-012
sp-012 · MM Furniture (Sunshine Coast QLD dealer) · A$300
Near-identical small cane table-and-2-chairs set sold at $300 by a dealer — that is RETAIL; strip the dealer margin for our net
comparable sp-009
sp-009 · Antiques Reporter (auction record) · A$1,680
Even a six-piece cane setting with 112 cm round table only cleared $1,680 at a Melbourne house in 2013 — the category never held value
comparable sp-011
sp-011 · Antiques Reporter (auction record) · A$1,342
Setting-for-two at $1,342 is best-case capital-city-house auction, not a Brisbane private sale

#105 Teak table and chairs

A$300 the lot (card price; detail page showed A$32,500 — scrape artefact, card adopted)
Brisbane QLD · Listed recently · View listing

Teak claim fails visual testing: weathered pale plank top, no teak colour or figure, and the photos show mismatched chairs (black plastic in one shot, four timber chairs in another) — cannot even confirm six chairs exist. PASS.

PASSrectangularlow
Teak table and chairs photoTeak table and chairs photoTeak table and chairs photo

Identification & condition

Form
rectangular
Maker or style
Rustic plank-top extending table, possible butterfly leaf (105-02 shows an open extension gap); barley-twist/turned leg with carved frieze in one photo reads 'recycled-barn' or Gustavian reproduction styling, not Danish modern
Material
TEAK CLAIM TESTED VISUALLY AND NOT SUPPORTED: grain close-up (105-03) shows wide planks with open, coarse grain, a grey-weathered surface and no oily golden-brown tone, no tight teak figure, no two-tone heartwood/sapwood; the seller admits the finish is gone ('needs a sand'). Reads as weathered softwood (pine) or a stained hardwood, not teak — and sanding a thin veneer would destroy it if it were veneer
Period
indeterminate — rustic reproduction or genuinely old softwood country table; nothing in the photos is 1960s-teak
Construction
Planked top with visible board joints and gaps; extension with internal rails (105-02); turned legs; no maker's mark or label visible in any of the three photos
Dimensions (est.)
Table ≈ 150–180 × 85–90 cm extending; chairs 6 claimed but photos show 4 black plastic chairs in one shot and 4 timber chairs in another — never six together
Condition grade
poor

Visible in photos: Top is dry, grey, finish-worn with open plank gaps and surface scratches — consistent with the 'needs a sand' admission; chairs in 105-01 are modern black plastic (exterior type), which contradicts any matched teak-suite reading

Can't see from these photos: whether the top is solid or veneer (sanding will reveal — or ruin — it) / leg/joint stability / actual chair count and whether they belong to the set / underside, extension mechanism integrity

Photo limits: Three photos cannot identify this piece: cannot determine timber species conclusively from a weathered sanded-ready surface, cannot verify six chairs exist or that they match, cannot see the underside or extension mechanism. The whole listing rests on the word 'teak', and every visual test the photos allow (colour, grain openness, plank weathering, styling, chair mismatch) points away from mid-century teak.

Appraisal confidence: low

Ask versus value

Estimated value: A$100 – A$350 (mid A$250) · refs mc-011 / mc-012 / mc-023 / mc-025

Basis: Valued as an unmarked, weathered rustic set at the commodity end: genuine mid-century teak extending table + 6 chairs achieves ~$400–700 in AU (mc-011 hammered $512), but the photos do not establish teak, so this is priced against unmarked softwood/reproduction comps.

Ask A$300 → upside A$−50 (value mid − ask)

If resold: private net A$180 · auction net A$70 · retail asking A$400

Adjustments
  • −teak premium withheld (≈−50% of the suite value): grain/colour test failed, no mark, no 60s styling
  • −20% restoration cost allowance (full sand/refinish of a large top is a day's labour)
  • −15% because the 'six chairs' claim is not shown — worst case it is 4 plastic + 2 other
  • + small value for the extension feature if the mechanism works
Verdict: PASS · upside A$−50 vs the A$300 ask · confidence low
Comparable evidence
no image
mc-011 · Arthur Johnson & Sons (UK, easyliveauction) · A$512
Upper-bound reality check: a full branded G-Plan Fresco teak oval suite with 6 chairs hammered only ~A$512 — the best case if the claim were true, and even that is modest
no image
mc-012 · Adam Partridge Auctioneers (UK) · A$72
Poor-condition teak extension tables hammer from ~$72 — where unmarked, finish-gone tables actually land
no image
mc-023 · Arthur Johnson & Sons (UK, easyliveauction) · A$102
Unmarked drop-leaf/gateleg at $102 frames commodity rustic extending tables without a brand
no image
mc-025 · Gumtree Australia search · A$1,100
The $1,100 QLD ask for a real labelled Danish round teak shows the price gap between a CLAIM and a PROVEN teak table

#112 Dining Table with six chairs

A$150
Brisbane QLD · Listed 4 weeks ago · View listing

A complete dark-veneer table + 6 upholstered chairs at A$150 is cheap for a flip even though the 'IKEA VANGSTA' claim is false (VANGSTA is white/black laminate; this is not it) — CONSIDER, sub-margin.

CONSIDERrectangularmedium
Dining Table with six chairs photoDining Table with six chairs photoDining Table with six chairs photoDining Table with six chairs photoDining Table with six chairs photoDining Table with six chairs photo

Identification & condition

Form
rectangular
Maker or style
Unbranded contemporary rectangular extending table, dark brown veneer top on black metal frame; six taupe fabric side chairs — the seller's IKEA VANGSTA claim is CONTRADICTED: photo 1 is a VANGSTA spec diagram (stock image) but the actual table has a dark timber-look veneer, not VANGSTA's white/black laminate
Material
Dark brown wood-look veneer on a particleboard/MDF core over a black steel frame (extendable, centre gap/extra panel visible in 112-03); chairs are fabric-over-foam on timber/metal legs
Period
2010s–2020s flat-pack
Construction
Extendable top with leaf stored under the surface (open frame visible in 112-03); bolted metal legs; chairs look like a matched six-piece set in at least three photos
Dimensions (est.)
≈120–180 cm extending × 74–75 cm h (stock diagram says 120/180 × 75; treat as approximate since the diagram is a copied spec sheet)
Condition grade
good

Visible in photos: Six photos: top shows light surface wear, no obvious edge swelling or chips at this resolution; leaf present in the frame; chairs intact with fabric showing normal use shading; no structural damage visible

Can't see from these photos: edge-band swelling close-up / chair frame looseness / fabric stains at distance / whether all six chairs are the same set (one photo is a stock diagram, not evidence) / underside hardware

Photo limits: Cannot confirm chair matching or fabric stains at photo distance, cannot read the edge banding; the VANGSTA claim is already disproved so the actual make/model is unknown, which caps confidence. Upside ($50) is under the BUY margin floor of $150, so CONSIDER only.

Appraisal confidence: medium

Adversarial review · agree · arithmetic: sound · recomputed margin: A$50 · comp support: strong · ask integrity: ok (audit live price = adopted ask) · biggest downside: If fabric chairs are stained it is a $120 table with baggage; resale ~140 · · cost if wrong A$10 ·

Admirably adversarial item work: the seller's IKEA VANGSTA claim is disproved from the photos and the value is built bottom-up (table $60-80 + 6 chairs at $20-25 each) rather than from the claim. Comps exist. 50 < 150 floor, CONSIDER correct.

Ask versus value

Estimated value: A$130 – A$280 (mid A$200) · refs ds-021 / ds-022 / ds-023

Basis: Priced as a complete used 7-piece flat-pack set: the floor comps are single tables at $80–150, so the six upholstered chairs carry the value — a quick-flip private sale of a full setting lands ~$200–250.

Ask A$150 → upside A$50 (value mid − ask)

If resold: private net A$200 · auction net A$90 · retail asking A$320

Adjustments
  • +6 chairs valued ~$20–25 each used private-sale (+$120–150)
  • −20% for fabric chairs (cleaning risk, harder to sell than plastic)
  • −10% private channel vs asking
  • + small extension-mechanism bump if the leaf is present (visible in 112-03)
Verdict: CONSIDER · upside A$50 vs the A$150 ask · confidence medium
Comparable evidence
no image
ds-021 · Gumtree Australia · A$80
Shows $80 buys just a table + 2 chairs locally — the six fabric chairs must add the rest of the value
no image
ds-022 · Gumtree Australia · A$150
Near-new 4-seater at $150 caps the table alone; our table alone is worth ~$60–80 used
no image
ds-023 · Gumtree Australia (PriceWorth Rocklea) · A$399
Trade sellers ask $399 for veneer rounds, but private resale lands far below asking — discipline on the upside

#008 Solid wood table + 6 chairs

A$50
Brisbane, QLD · Listed 8 weeks ago in Brisbane, QLD · View listing

unattributed rustic "farmhouse" set; mass-produced reproduction, c.1990s-2010s reproduction, not pre-1975. Condition fair: Photos show complete 6-chair set, plank top, heavy apron, dark stain worn in patches; underside not shown Complete solid-timber 6-seat set at A$50 is a parts/chairs play even though the set is reproduction, not antique

CONSIDERrectangularlow
Solid wood table + 6 chairs photoSolid wood table + 6 chairs photoSolid wood table + 6 chairs photoSolid wood table + 6 chairs photoSolid wood table + 6 chairs photoSolid wood table + 6 chairs photoSolid wood table + 6 chairs photo

Identification & condition

Form
rectangular
Maker or style
unattributed rustic "farmhouse" set; mass-produced reproduction
Material
stained solid softwood/rush-look hardwood; plank top, machined chamfers
Period
c.1990s-2010s reproduction, not pre-1975
Construction
6 spindle-back chairs match table; plank top with battens; dark uniform stain; nothing hand-cut visible
Dimensions (est.)
1.80 x 1.00 x 0.78 m (listed, consistent with photos)
Condition grade
fair

Visible in photos: Photos show complete 6-chair set, plank top, heavy apron, dark stain worn in patches; underside not shown

Can't see from these photos: u / n / d / e / r / s / i / d / e / , / / j / o / i / n / t / s / , / / s / p / e / c / i / e / s / , / / w / o / b / b / l / e

Photo limits: ['underside construction', 'timber species', 'joint stability']

Appraisal confidence: low

Adversarial review · DISSENT · arithmetic: sound · recomputed margin: A$140 · comp support: absent · ask integrity: ok (audit live price = adopted ask) · biggest downside: It is a modern knotty-pine farmhouse set (confirmed in photos: knot cluster, machined chamfers); real flip ~$150-200, so loss ~$150-200 on buy+haul · · cost if wrong A$200 ·

DISSENT: LC-10 does not exist in any library and MC-03 ($1,850 Parker round retail) does not match the price quoted in the reason. Under VALUATION_METHOD §3.4 (BUY iff margin >= max(0.30V,$150); LOW conf needs >= max(0.5V,$300) and V<1000) the margin is 190-50=140 vs a $300 low-confidence floor. Correct verdict: CONSIDER, not BUY.

Ask versus value

Estimated value: A$150 – A$500 (mid A$350) · refs mc-011 / ds-018 / mc-023

Basis: Complete solid-timber 6-seat set at A$50 is a parts/chairs play even though the set is reproduction, not antique.

Ask A$50 → upside A$300 (value mid − ask)

If resold: private net A$190 · auction net A$105 · retail asking A$450

Adjustments
  • minus: reproduction grade, no antique premium
  • plus: 6 matching chairs included, total ask A$50
  • private net 55% of A$350 = A$192 clears the A$50 ask by A$142 > the A$100 minimum margin
Verdict: CONSIDER · upside A$300 vs the A$50 ask · confidence low
Comparable evidence
no image
mc-011 · Arthur Johnson & Sons (UK, easyliveauction) · A$512
Complete six-chair dining suite hammered A$512.50 at regional auction (teak, branded - a tier above this reproduction); realised full-set money sits at this band's ceiling, so an unbranded stained set must clear at or under A$500. [comp basis] Like-for-like on set composition: realised suite hammers and the reproduction-retail ladder bracket 150-500.
no image
ds-018 · Antique Mahogany (AU retailer) · A$990
NEW reproduction antique-look table retails A$990; used reproductions sell well under new per the library note (flat-pack/repro lose 60-70% leaving the shop), landing this worn set mid-band even with 6 chairs included.
no image
mc-023 · Arthur Johnson & Sons (UK, easyliveauction) · A$102
Regional auction hammer A$102.50 for a used unmarked solid-wood table needing work - the table-only floor; the A$150 low above it is justified by the six matching chairs being a parts/chairs play.

#012 Wooden table

A$0
Brisbane, QLD · Listed 2 days ago in Brisbane, QLD · View listing

unattributed; 1980s Australian "colonial style" reproduction, c.1980s-90s reproduction; square chamfered/fluted legs on block feet (screen-flagged profile confirmed). Condition fair: Only one photo: rectangular stained solid-timber top with rounded nosing and end-grain, fluted square legs, chipped corner; genuinely solid, not veneer Solid-timber reproduction dining table at A$0 (free): any private net beats the ask and the A$100 minimum margin

CONSIDERrectangularlow
Wooden table photoWooden table photo

Identification & condition

Form
rectangular
Maker or style
unattributed; 1980s Australian "colonial style" reproduction
Material
solid timber, dark stained (species unknown); solid boarded top edge visible in zoom
Period
c.1980s-90s reproduction; square chamfered/fluted legs on block feet (screen-flagged profile confirmed)
Construction
single photo only; top corner shows a chip through the finish; legs plinth-blocked
Dimensions (est.)
est. 1.5-1.7 x 0.85-0.9 m (no dims given)
Condition grade
fair

Visible in photos: Only one photo: rectangular stained solid-timber top with rounded nosing and end-grain, fluted square legs, chipped corner; genuinely solid, not veneer

Can't see from these photos: e / v / e / r / y / t / h / i / n / g / / e / l / s / e / : / / u / n / d / e / r / s / i / d / e / , / / s / t / r / e / t / c / h / e / r / s / , / / s / e / c / o / n / d / / c / o / r / n / e / r / , / / t / r / u / e / / s / i / z / e

Photo limits: ['species', 'underside and joinery', 'full size', 'leaf/absence of leaf', 'stability']

Appraisal confidence: low

Adversarial review · DISSENT · arithmetic: sound · recomputed margin: A$137 · comp support: absent · ask integrity: ok (audit live price = adopted ask) · biggest downside: Laminate coffee table is junk-tier, clears ~$80-100; at ask $0 the loss is only your time (~$50) · · cost if wrong A$50 ·

DISSENT: MC-01/MC-05 do not exist (library has mc-001=$4,500, mc-005=$2,990 — neither matches the claimed 'asks 800-1,200 / low band 550'), and mid was set 'just above that ask band' — a retail asking band used as private value, a channel-discipline breach. §3.4 low-conf floor is max(0.5*250,300)=$300; real margin is 137. Correct verdict: CONSIDER (free, grab-if-passing), not BUY.

Ask versus value

Estimated value: A$150 – A$400 (mid A$250) · refs aus-024 / aus-025 / mc-023

Basis: Solid-timber reproduction dining table at A$0 (free): any private net beats the ask and the A$100 minimum margin.

Ask A$0 → upside A$250 (value mid − ask)

If resold: private net A$137 · auction net A$75 · retail asking A$350

Adjustments
  • minus: chipped corner, unknown species/size
  • plus: free acquisition - resale is pure margin if it can be moved
  • private net 55% of A$250 = A$137 > A$0 + A$100 margin
Verdict: CONSIDER · upside A$250 vs the A$0 ask · confidence low
Comparable evidence
no image
aus-024 · eBay Australia · A$210
A GENUINE c.1890 cedar rectangular extension asks only A$210 online - authenticity sells for barely more than this reproduction's tier, anchoring the 150-250 core of the band for a dark-stained colonial-style table of unproven date. [comp basis] Like-for-like: local-sale-channel rows for colonial-format rectangular domestic tables.
no image
aus-025 · Murphy's Antiques and Restorations · A$390
Restored/commercial period-look table at dealer retail A$390, just above the band top; dealer asks run 2-3x private, so privately this class clears ~A$130-200 - consistent with the band and its A$250 mid.
no image
mc-023 · Arthur Johnson & Sons (UK, easyliveauction) · A$102
Used solid-wood table needing work hammered A$102.50 - the realistic floor for unmarked solid timber at regional auction, supporting the A$150 low.

#013 Solid wood table + chairs

A$100
Brisbane, QLD · Listed in Brisbane, QLD Door pickup · View listing

unattributed country-pine farmhouse table, seller says 20+ years, c.1990s country-pine; not colonial, not old-growth. Condition fair: Two photos: light-stained pine table with apron drawer and 5 chairs, honest everyday wear; reads 1990s solid-pine, not antique Solid pine table plus 5 chairs: real private resale about double the ask, but the 55% private net lands just under the BUY margin

CONSIDERrectangularlow
Solid wood table + chairs photoSolid wood table + chairs photo

Identification & condition

Form
rectangular
Maker or style
unattributed country-pine farmhouse table, seller says 20+ years
Material
stained solid pine, plank-style top, apron with drawer, simple turned-tapered legs
Period
c.1990s country-pine; not colonial, not old-growth
Construction
5 chairs included but mixed styles; drawer in apron; finish worn at edges
Dimensions (est.)
1.51 x 0.91 x 0.77 m (listed, consistent with photos)
Condition grade
fair

Visible in photos: Two photos: light-stained pine table with apron drawer and 5 chairs, honest everyday wear; reads 1990s solid-pine, not antique

Can't see from these photos: u / n / d / e / r / s / i / d / e / , / / d / r / a / w / e / r / / r / u / n / n / e / r / s / , / / c / h / a / i / r / / j / o / i / n / e / r / y

Photo limits: ['species confirmation', 'underside/joints', 'chair set consistency', 'drawer condition']

Appraisal confidence: low

Adversarial review · agree_with_caveat · arithmetic: sound · recomputed margin: A$92 · comp support: weak · ask integrity: ok (audit live price = adopted ask) · biggest downside: If softwood not oak, resale ~120; you overpaid by ~$0 (CONSIDER spends nothing) · · cost if wrong A$0 ·

Verdict follows (92 < 150 floor), but both cited comp IDs (LC-10, LC-05) do not exist in the libraries — the band is defensible from mc-021/aus rows, the citation is not.

Ask versus value

Estimated value: A$200 – A$550 (mid A$350) · refs ds-021 / ds-022 / sp-026

Basis: Solid pine table plus 5 chairs: real private resale about double the ask, but the 55% private net lands just under the BUY margin.

Ask A$100 → upside A$250 (value mid − ask)

If resold: private net A$192 · auction net A$105 · retail asking A$450

Adjustments
  • plus: 5 chairs and working apron drawer
  • minus: plain pine, worn finish, common model
  • private net 55% of A$350 = A$192 vs ask A$100: beats ask by A$92, below the A$100 minimum margin - CONSIDER, negotiate to A$70 or confirm chairs match to flip it
Verdict: CONSIDER · upside A$250 vs the A$100 ask · confidence low
Comparable evidence
no image
ds-021 · Gumtree Australia · A$80
The modal Marketplace flat-pack table: A$80 asking (MDF veneer/particleboard, QLD) sets the true floor - same material class and channel as this set; the A$200 low reflects the six-chair completeness above a bare table. [comp basis] Band-level ONLY: ordinary flat-pack floor rows plus the laminate-set dealer benchmark support the bottom and, with a damage discount, the top; no like-for-like row exists.
no image
ds-022 · Gumtree Australia · A$150
'Ashton' flat-pack round A$150 ask, near-new loses 60-70% leaving the shop - defines realistic clearing money for engineered-board sets in this exact channel.
no image
sp-026 · Sydney Morning Herald (smh.com.au) · A$1,125
Dealer benchmark: a good laminate table plus full chair set fetches A$750-1,500 only when clean and complete; this one is a damaged, chipped, unbranded private sale, so discounting the ceiling's low end to private level supports the band top, with the basis's own A$550 flagged optimistic. [comp mismatch] Realised prices for this class top out far below the band: ds-022 asks A$150 and ds-024 sold A$161.60; the A$550 high rests only on sp-026's clean-set dealer ceiling (A$750-1,500) after a private-channel and chip-damage discount, and the appraisal basis itself concedes A$350 mid is optimistic. Value NOT changed.

#014 Timber Table

A$200
Brisbane, QLD · Listed 4 weeks ago in Brisbane, QLD · View listing

unattributed turned-pedestal round table, c.1980s-90s reproduction "colonial look"; bulb turning is shallow, uniform. Condition good: Four photos: round solid top with visible band/seam (possible butterfly leaf), turned pedestal, sound surface, no major damage Sound but reproduction round pedestal table; ask A$200 (negotiable) sits above what the 55% private net supports

PASSroundmedium
Timber Table photoTimber Table photoTimber Table photoTimber Table photo

Identification & condition

Form
round
Maker or style
unattributed turned-pedestal round table
Material
solid stained timber top; segment/plank build with a leaf seam visible across the top; turned pedestal
Period
c.1980s-90s reproduction "colonial look"; bulb turning is shallow, uniform
Construction
no windlass or leaf storage visible; pedestal base; finish dark uniform
Dimensions (est.)
est. 1.1-1.2 m diameter round
Condition grade
good

Visible in photos: Four photos: round solid top with visible band/seam (possible butterfly leaf), turned pedestal, sound surface, no major damage

Can't see from these photos: u / n / d / e / r / s / i / d / e / , / / m / e / c / h / a / n / i / s / m / , / / s / p / e / c / i / e / s / , / / t / r / u / e / / d / i / a / m / e / t / e / r

Photo limits: ['underside and mechanism', 'species', 'leaf presence', 'diameter']

Appraisal confidence: medium

Ask versus value

Estimated value: A$150 – A$400 (mid A$250) · refs aus-017 / aus-018 / aus-016 / mc-023

Basis: Sound but reproduction round pedestal table; ask A$200 (negotiable) sits above what the 55% private net supports.

Ask A$200 → upside A$50 (value mid − ask)

If resold: private net A$137 · auction net A$75 · retail asking A$320

Adjustments
  • minus: reproduction grade, unproven leaf mechanism
  • note: negotiable - only worth taking at about A$120 or less, where net beats ask plus margin
Verdict: PASS · upside A$50 vs the A$200 ask · confidence medium
Comparable evidence
comparable aus-017
aus-017 · Theodore Bruce Auctions · A$700
Trade-realistic estimate A$700 for a common veneered circular tilt-top - the library's stated band where most Marketplace rounds of this class sit; private/marketplace venue discount (2-3x on trade asking) lands ~A$230-350, bracketing the A$400 high. [comp basis] Like-for-like: common veneer/later pedestal round tables in trade and local channels bracket 150-400.
no image
aus-018 · Theodore Bruce Auctions · A$200
Floor signal A$200: later/commercial mahogany circular three-foot pedestal table through trade channels - same form (circular pedestal with leaf), supporting the band mid.
no image
aus-016 · Ipswich Antique Centre (QLD) · A$1,500
Ceiling contrast: the local Ipswich dealer's A$1,500 asking for a colonial-format round went UNSOLD in 2018 - the local ceiling for unattributed rounds is soft, so an unlabelled 1980s-90s reproduction must clear well below, consistent with the A$400 cap.
no image
mc-023 · Arthur Johnson & Sons (UK, easyliveauction) · A$102
Regional hammer A$102.50 for used solid-wood needing work - auction floor for unmarked timber rounds; the A$150 low sits just above it given the intact, refinished-ready top.

#039 Custom Made \u201cArt deco\u201d style dining table

A$270
Brisbane, QLD · Listed a week ago in Brisbane, QLD · View listing

custom Australian-made "Art Deco style" pedestal, seller-dated 1970s, c.1970s-80s custom, not deco-period original. Condition good: Three photos: dark glossy round top, fluted pedestal, demountable joint; styling is a 1970s take on deco, no maker mark Attractive one-off with a narrow buyer pool; private net A$192 does not even clear the A$270 ask

PASSroundmedium
Custom Made \u201cArt deco\u201d style dining table photoCustom Made \u201cArt deco\u201d style dining table photoCustom Made \u201cArt deco\u201d style dining table photo

Identification & condition

Form
round
Maker or style
custom Australian-made "Art Deco style" pedestal, seller-dated 1970s
Material
high-gloss dark stained timber; fluted/scalloped column; top reads veneered or solid stained hardwood, unconfirmed
Period
c.1970s-80s custom, not deco-period original
Construction
comes apart for transport (spigot/column joint); fluted turned column
Dimensions (est.)
1.21 m dia x 0.75 m (listed)
Condition grade
good

Visible in photos: Three photos: dark glossy round top, fluted pedestal, demountable joint; styling is a 1970s take on deco, no maker mark

Can't see from these photos: u / n / d / e / r / s / i / d / e / , / / j / o / i / n / t / / t / y / p / e / , / / v / e / n / e / e / r / / v / s / / s / o / l / i / d / , / / t / r / u / e / / e / r / a

Photo limits: ['veneer vs solid top', 'underside and joint', 'era evidence', 'maker mark']

Appraisal confidence: medium

Ask versus value

Estimated value: A$200 – A$600 (mid A$350) · refs aus-018 / aus-017 / aus-022

Basis: Attractive one-off with a narrow buyer pool; private net A$192 does not even clear the A$270 ask.

Ask A$270 → upside A$80 (value mid − ask)

If resold: private net A$192 · auction net A$105 · retail asking A$550

Adjustments
  • minus: no designer attribution; "custom" only adds labour value
  • minus: demountable joint is a perceived-stability objection for buyers
Verdict: PASS · upside A$80 vs the A$270 ask · confidence medium
Comparable evidence
no image
aus-018 · Theodore Bruce Auctions · A$200
Later/commercial circular pedestal tilt-top, trade floor signal A$200 - same form family (circular top, turned pedestal base, leaf), anchoring the A$200 band low for an unattributed veneered round. [comp basis] Like-for-like on form/material (veneered pedestal rounds); note: the library holds no genuine Art Deco row, so the claimed 'art deco' premium itself is uncited - value rests on the common veneer-round class.
comparable aus-017
aus-017 · Theodore Bruce Auctions · A$700
Common veneered circular leaf table, trade estimate A$700 - the library's class band for Marketplace veneer rounds; private-channel discount puts realistic money at A$230-350, the band mid, before any credit for the sunburst top.
comparable aus-022
aus-022 · Antiques Reporter (Gowans Auctions) · A$2,415
Contrast ceiling: a genuine Victorian rosewood pedestal centre table hammers A$2,415 when the timber is veneered/imported rather than cedar; this c.1970-80 custom chipboard-core sunburst is a full tier below, so the A$600 cap keeps it in the common-veneer class the basis argues for, not deco-money.

#046 Freedom round dining table

A$500
Brisbane, QLD · Listed in Brisbane, QLD · View listing

Freedom Furniture branded round dining table (exact model not identified from photos), contemporary (2010s-2020s). Condition good: Six photos incl. surface close-up: light oak-look top with fine straight grain and scratch cluster, chunky mitred base; reads branded contemporary, not vintage Branded modern table priced near its own private resale: no margin at A$500

PASSroundmedium
Freedom round dining table photoFreedom round dining table photoFreedom round dining table photoFreedom round dining table photoFreedom round dining table photoFreedom round dining table photo

Identification & condition

Form
round
Maker or style
Freedom Furniture branded round dining table (exact model not identified from photos)
Material
oak-look top, fine open grain consistent with oak veneer or solid oak lamella; light scratches visible
Period
contemporary (2010s-2020s)
Construction
plain round top on solid light-timber base; no mechanism
Dimensions (est.)
1.20 m dia (listed, consistent)
Condition grade
good

Visible in photos: Six photos incl. surface close-up: light oak-look top with fine straight grain and scratch cluster, chunky mitred base; reads branded contemporary, not vintage

Can't see from these photos: u / n / d / e / r / s / i / d / e / , / / w / h / e / t / h / e / r / / t / o / p / / i / s / / v / e / n / e / e / r / / o / r / / s / o / l / i / d / , / / e / x / a / c / t / / m / o / d / e / l

Photo limits: ['exact model/new price', 'veneer vs solid', 'underside']

Appraisal confidence: medium

Ask versus value

Estimated value: A$350 – A$650 (mid A$480) · refs ds-023 / ds-022 / ds-003

Basis: Branded modern table priced near its own private resale: no margin at A$500.

Ask A$500 → upside A$−20 (value mid − ask)

If resold: private net A$264 · auction net A$145 · retail asking A$520

Adjustments
  • web check (2 lookups): Freedom oak dining tables sell new roughly A$1,000-2,500 (freedom.com.au/living-and-dining/dining-furniture/c/oak-dining-tables); model not pinned, so ceiling kept conservative
  • minus: visible scratches; unknown veneer/solid - if laminate-look veneer, low drops to ~A$250
Verdict: PASS · upside A$−20 vs the A$500 ask · confidence medium
Comparable evidence
no image
ds-023 · Gumtree Australia (PriceWorth Rocklea) · A$399
Trade asking A$399 for a 105cm walnut-veneer round - the only in-band asking, showing where trade sellers price the veneer round tier; the appraisal's basis already nets trade asking down ~10% to private, which is why the band sits below this ask. [comp basis] Band-level: no Freedom row and no photo, so only the ordinary/replica round-table ladder applies - nothing like-for-like.
no image
ds-022 · Gumtree Australia · A$150
Ordinary flat-pack round asks A$150 and clears near ask in this exact channel - the floor class; the A$350 band low assumes brand-tier (Freedom) standing above commodity flat-pack.
no image
ds-003 · Cult Furniture · A$1,544
Ceiling rule: a NEW branded Saarinen-style replica round retails A$1,544 and the library rule caps used Marketplace replicas at 50-60% of that (~A$770-930); the A$650 band high sits under this ceiling, consistent with an unverified retail copy. [comp mismatch] No realised comp supports 350-650 for an unbranded flat-pack-grade copy: the ordinary round tier asks A$150-399 and its only sale in-library is A$161.60; the band high survives only under the ds-003 used-replica rule (max ~50-60% of new-replica retail) if the piece is verifiable Freedom stock. Mismatch recorded; value NOT changed.

#060 Table- unique style

A$50
Brisbane, QLD · Listed a week ago in Brisbane, QLD · View listing

repurposed timber cable-drum top on modern hairpin steel legs (DIY industrial), top plausibly genuinely old (old-growth plank, hardware holes); legs modern. Condition fair: Four photos: plank round top with old drill/slot holes under thick varnish, slim black hairpin legs, outdoor setting; texture is the whole appeal A$50 buys a character repurposed table; resale is real but thin and niche, under the margin floor at value mid

CONSIDERroundmedium
Table- unique style photoTable- unique style photoTable- unique style photoTable- unique style photo

Identification & condition

Form
round
Maker or style
repurposed timber cable-drum top on modern hairpin steel legs (DIY industrial)
Material
old heavy planks, orange-toned heavy varnish, auger holes and centre slot from drum hardware
Period
top plausibly genuinely old (old-growth plank, hardware holes); legs modern
Construction
top is the original drum face with bolt/slot cut-outs; hairpin legs added
Dimensions (est.)
1.07 m dia (listed, consistent with tape-measure photo)
Condition grade
fair

Visible in photos: Four photos: plank round top with old drill/slot holes under thick varnish, slim black hairpin legs, outdoor setting; texture is the whole appeal

Can't see from these photos: u / n / d / e / r / s / i / d / e / , / / l / e / g / / f / i / x / i / n / g / , / / s / t / a / b / i / l / i / t / y / , / / s / p / e / c / i / e / s

Photo limits: ['stability/joints', 'underside', 'species', 'how the legs are fixed']

Appraisal confidence: medium

Adversarial review · agree_with_caveat · arithmetic: sound · recomputed margin: A$49 · comp support: weak · ask integrity: ok (audit live price = adopted ask) · biggest downside: Kitsch pine, slow seller's market; realistically moves in 3-6 months at ~$150 — exposure only if you buy · · cost if wrong A$50 ·

Verdict direction holds (CONSIDER at most), but LC-05 does not exist and the item's own upside (130) already sits under the 150 BUY floor — this is 'keep an eye on it' at best.

Ask versus value

Estimated value: A$80 – A$280 (mid A$180) · refs ds-022 / ds-024 / ds-021 / ds-010

Basis: A$50 buys a character repurposed table; resale is real but thin and niche, under the margin floor at value mid.

Ask A$50 → upside A$130 (value mid − ask)

If resold: private net A$99 · auction net A$55 · retail asking A$250

Adjustments
  • minus: cut-outs and varnish limit it to the industrial-repro market
  • note: at A$50 the numbers work only if you can move it near A$150+; treat as flip-only, CONSIDER
Verdict: CONSIDER · upside A$130 vs the A$50 ask · confidence medium
Comparable evidence
no image
ds-022 · Gumtree Australia · A$150
'Ashton' round A$150 ask is the near-identical price tier for a small unbranded round in the same channel; the drum table's 2-3 seat size and bare-top scope match this row's market position - anchors the band mid. [comp basis] Band-level: cable-drum one-off form has no like-for-like row; ordinary round-table floor/sale rows plus one designer contrast anchor support 80-280.
no image
ds-024 · Amazon Australia · A$162
Glass/chrome 4-piece round SOLD at A$161.60 - a realised (not asking) price for commodity rounds, showing ~A$160 is real clearing money at this size, bracketing the band mid-high.
no image
ds-021 · Gumtree Australia · A$80
Floor: A$80 asking for the modal ordinary round table sets the band low; the handmade timber top justifies a modest step above the flat-pack floor.
comparable ds-010
ds-010 · Mark Tuckey · A$7,495
CONTRAST ONLY, not a price anchor: new designer handmade rounds retail A$7,495 - why an unlabelled one-off cannot price on 'unique'; the A$280 band high is ~4% of that, consistent with treating the piece as a commodity round with a small handmade premium, discounted for private venue and no chairs.

#073 Dining table

A$50
Brisbane, QLD · Just listed · View listing

1970s Australian kit-style dining set (table + 4 chairs), no label visible, c.1970-75. Condition poor-fair: top scratched/water-marked across most of surface, finish dull; chairs mismatched in stain tone; seat vinyl creased photos show a worn 70s set; comparable marketplace sets with chairs ask $80-250 and sell below ask

CONSIDERrectangularmedium
Dining table photoDining table photoDining table photo

Identification & condition

Form
rectangular
Maker or style
1970s Australian kit-style dining set (table + 4 chairs), no label visible
Material
varnished timber (beech/pine tone) top; dark-stained slat-back chairs with olive vinyl seats; one chair has bare wood seat, seller says only 3 cushions
Period
c.1970-75
Construction
square-section splayed legs, simple apron; photo 3 is a hand-drawn 1200 x 750 dims note
Dimensions (est.)
~1200 x 750 x 74 cm per seller sketch (confirmed as sketch, not label)
Condition grade
poor-fair

Visible in photos: top scratched/water-marked across most of surface, finish dull; chairs mismatched in stain tone; seat vinyl creased

Can't see from these photos: u / n / d / e / r / s / i / d / e / , / / j / o / i / n / t / s / , / / w / o / b / b / l / e / , / / c / u / s / h / i / o / n / / c / o / u / n / t / / a / c / t / u / a / l / l / y / / p / r / e / s / e / n / t

Photo limits: underside/joinery, actual number of cushions, stability when loaded

Appraisal confidence: medium

Adversarial review · DISSENT · arithmetic: sound · recomputed margin: A$90 · comp support: weak · ask integrity: ok (audit live price = adopted ask) · biggest downside: Chipped/worn Formica fails the 'chip-free' condition of the sp-026 dealer reference; real net ~$80-100, loss ~$60 plus transport · · cost if wrong A$90 ·

DISSENT: §3.4 floor at V=150 is max(0.30*150,$150)=$150 — 'a $150 table needs $150+, essentially free acquisition only'. Margin is 140-50=90 (even V-ask=100). The method itself forbids this BUY. sp-026 is a $1,125 dealer-retail reference for a chip-free set — discounted, but still a stretch for a chipped lone table. Correct verdict: CONSIDER.

Ask versus value

Estimated value: A$80 – A$220 (mid A$150) · refs ds-021 / sp-026

Basis: photos show a worn 70s set; comparable marketplace sets with chairs ask $80-250 and sell below ask

Ask A$50 → upside A$100 (value mid − ask)

If resold: private net A$140 · auction net A$0 · retail asking A$250

Adjustments
  • -worn scratched top and mismatched chair finish
  • -missing cushion (1 of 4)
  • +4 chairs included at A$50 ask
Verdict: CONSIDER · upside A$100 vs the A$50 ask · confidence medium
Comparable evidence
no image
ds-021 · Gumtree Australia · A$80
marketplace asking A$80 for a round table + 2 chairs; this set adds 2 chairs and a full 1200x750 top but is more worn -> mid lands near A$150
no image
sp-026 · Sydney Morning Herald (smh.com.au) · A$1,125
retail reference A$1,125 for a GOOD formica table + full vinyl chair set; this is heavily scratched with mismatched chairs -> 85%-ish discount

#096 Small square dining table

A$30
Brisbane, QLD · Just listed · View listing

plain domestic/possibly homemade pine kitchen table, no maker evidence, c.1960-80, indeterminate. Condition fair: surface scratches, corner dings, finish worn at edges; storage-room setting around it ordinary old pine table with visible wear; ordinary retro kitchen tables ask $30-150 and sell low

CONSIDERsquarelow
Small square dining table photoSmall square dining table photoSmall square dining table photo

Identification & condition

Form
square
Maker or style
plain domestic/possibly homemade pine kitchen table, no maker evidence
Material
solid softwood (knots and open grain visible through honey varnish - reads pine)
Period
c.1960-80, indeterminate
Construction
square-section legs, simple apron, plank-type top with visible board joints; tape photo shows a ~80 cm dimension
Dimensions (est.)
~75-80 cm square top, standard height
Condition grade
fair

Visible in photos: surface scratches, corner dings, finish worn at edges; storage-room setting around it

Can't see from these photos: u / n / d / e / r / s / i / d / e / , / / j / o / i / n / t / / t / y / p / e / , / / w / o / b / b / l / e

Photo limits: exact dimensions (tape photo ambiguous), leg joinery, whether top is one plank or glued boards

Appraisal confidence: low

Adversarial review · DISSENT · arithmetic: sound · recomputed margin: A$30 · comp support: weak · ask integrity: ok (audit live price = adopted ask) · biggest downside: It is a dinged junk pine table; auction net is $0 — you can't even give it away at auction; cost is the $30 · · cost if wrong A$30 ·

DISSENT: an upside of A$40 cannot support a BUY under §3.4 by any reading (low-conf floor $300; even the medium floor is $150, and the item's own auction_net is $0). aus-024 is cited only as a discount anchor (decorative). Correct verdict: PASS.

Ask versus value

Estimated value: A$40 – A$110 (mid A$70) · refs sp-025 / aus-024

Basis: ordinary old pine table with visible wear; ordinary retro kitchen tables ask $30-150 and sell low

Ask A$30 → upside A$40 (value mid − ask)

If resold: private net A$60 · auction net A$0 · retail asking A$110

Adjustments
  • -small size, no design feature
  • -scratched/dinged top
  • +solid timber construction at trivial ask
Verdict: CONSIDER · upside A$40 vs the A$30 ask · confidence low
Comparable evidence
comparable sp-025
sp-025 · eBay Australia listings (search snapshot) · A$75
marketplace asking A$75 for a 1960s retro round kitchen table - comparable ordinary-tier asking; this is plainer timber, no feature -> A$40-110
no image
aus-024 · eBay Australia · A$210
colonial cedar table retail ask A$210; this is pine, not cedar, and small -> heavy discount to sub-A$100

#102 CLOSING DOWN SALE.! $750 New Solid Mango Wood dining table small chip

A$650
Brisbane, QLD · Listed 2 weeks ago in Brisbane, QLD · View listing

current-production solid mango oval pedestal dining table (trade/overstock stock, closing-down seller); style sold as 'Brego/Oatley-type' mango oval, current production (new/unsold stock). Condition good: small chip at one end disclosed and visible in a detail photo; surface otherwise clean; store/floor-model look equivalent NEW mango oval pedestal tables retail on sale at A$799-1,039 (LivingStyles Brego 180 sale A$799; Oatley 135 A$1,039; T&W Anika oval mango A$1,399 RRP) - private resale of a chipped, delivery-less unit must sit ~25-35% under discounted new price, so ask A$750 is above fair used value

PASSovalhigh
CLOSING DOWN SALE.! $750 New Solid Mango Wood dining table small chip photoCLOSING DOWN SALE.! $750 New Solid Mango Wood dining table small chip photoCLOSING DOWN SALE.! $750 New Solid Mango Wood dining table small chip photoCLOSING DOWN SALE.! $750 New Solid Mango Wood dining table small chip photoCLOSING DOWN SALE.! $750 New Solid Mango Wood dining table small chip photoCLOSING DOWN SALE.! $750 New Solid Mango Wood dining table small chip photo

Identification & condition

Form
oval
Maker or style
current-production solid mango oval pedestal dining table (trade/overstock stock, closing-down seller); style sold as 'Brego/Oatley-type' mango oval
Material
solid mango (mindi), honey finish
Period
current production (new/unsold stock)
Construction
thick oval top on chunky fluted twin-panel pedestal with plinth feet; seller graphic photos carry dimensions (~150 cm L, ~90 W, 74 H class)
Dimensions (est.)
~150-160 x 90 cm oval
Condition grade
good

Visible in photos: small chip at one end disclosed and visible in a detail photo; surface otherwise clean; store/floor-model look

Can't see from these photos: w / h / e / t / h / e / r / / c / h / i / p / / i / s / / m / o / r / e / / t / h / a / n / / e / d / g / e / - / d / e / e / p / , / / u / n / d / e / r / s / i / d / e / , / / a / c / t / u / a / l / / r / e / t / a / i / l / / p / r / o / v / e / n / a / n / c / e

Photo limits: chip depth, whether price includes anything else, true RRP of the exact model

Appraisal confidence: high

Ask versus value

Estimated value: A$450 – A$700 (mid A$600) · refs mc-011 / ds-025

Basis: equivalent NEW mango oval pedestal tables retail on sale at A$799-1,039 (LivingStyles Brego 180 sale A$799; Oatley 135 A$1,039; T&W Anika oval mango A$1,399 RRP) - private resale of a chipped, delivery-less unit must sit ~25-35% under discounted new price, so ask A$750 is above fair used value

Ask A$650 → upside A$−50 (value mid − ask)

If resold: private net A$550 · auction net A$300 · retail asking A$900

Adjustments
  • -disclosed chip at end
  • -no warranty/no delivery/no returns (closing-down stock)
  • -used-channel discount vs A$799-1,039 discounted-new comps
Verdict: PASS · upside A$−50 vs the A$650 ask · confidence high
Comparable evidence
no image
mc-011 · Arthur Johnson & Sons (UK, easyliveauction) · A$512
auction A$512 for a G-Plan teak oval extending table (superior timber, genuine vintage) - caps what buyers pay at auction for oval timber tables; mango is a lesser timber and this is chipped -> below that line at auction
no image
ds-025 · eBay Australia · A$300
new extendable retail asking A$300-500 class tables compete for the same buyer at similar money - A$750 buys new-with-warranty elsewhere in that tier

#104 Dining table

A$120
Brisbane, QLD · Listed 2 days ago in Brisbane, QLD · View listing

Harvey Norman (per seller) drop-side round table, 1960s-retro styling, 2000s reproduction of a 60s look (seller attributes to Harvey Norman, not a vintage maker). Condition fair: a few stains on top (seller admits, visible as blotches); finish otherwise sound photos show a retro-styled HN drop-leaf in blonde timber with stains; real 60s Ercol/G-Plan drop-leafs retail much higher but this reads reproduction - used-market value sits just above the ask

CONSIDERroundlow
Dining table photoDining table photo

Identification & condition

Form
round
Maker or style
Harvey Norman (per seller) drop-side round table, 1960s-retro styling
Material
light/blonde timber-look top (veneer or laminate over board) with splayed solid-look legs - photos show pale honey surface, darker edge banding
Period
2000s reproduction of a 60s look (seller attributes to Harvey Norman, not a vintage maker)
Construction
round drop-leaf/drop-side top claimed by seller; photos do not clearly show the leaf mechanism; splayed legs
Dimensions (est.)
~90-100 cm round closed, est.
Condition grade
fair

Visible in photos: a few stains on top (seller admits, visible as blotches); finish otherwise sound

Can't see from these photos: d / r / o / p / - / l / e / a / f / / m / e / c / h / a / n / i / s / m / / a / n / d / / i / t / s / / a / c / t / i / o / n / , / / u / n / d / e / r / s / i / d / e / , / / t / r / u / e / / t / o / p / / m / a / t / e / r / i / a / l

Photo limits: whether it truly is a Harvey Norman piece or a 60s original (no label in photos), leaf mechanism condition, top material under the finish

Appraisal confidence: low

Adversarial review · agree · arithmetic: sound · recomputed margin: A$30 · comp support: strong · ask integrity: ok (audit live price = adopted ask) · biggest downside: If it IS a genuine 60s drop-leaf rather than HN repro, you leave ~$1,000 on the table — upside foregone, not cash lost · · cost if wrong A$0 ·

Good channel discipline in reverse: real Ercol retail (mc-008 $831, mc-007 $2,300) is used as the ceiling and the repro haircut (-75-80%) is stated. 150-120=30, well under floor; CONSIDER is right.

Ask versus value

Estimated value: A$120 – A$260 (mid A$170) · refs mc-008 / mc-007

Basis: photos show a retro-styled HN drop-leaf in blonde timber with stains; real 60s Ercol/G-Plan drop-leafs retail much higher but this reads reproduction - used-market value sits just above the ask

Ask A$120 → upside A$50 (value mid − ask)

If resold: private net A$150 · auction net A$60 · retail asking A$300

Adjustments
  • -reproduction, not genuine mid-century
  • -stained top needs refinishing
  • +drop-side flexibility if mechanism works
Verdict: CONSIDER · upside A$50 vs the A$120 ask · confidence low
Comparable evidence
comparable mc-008
mc-008 · eBay UK (via search) · A$831
genuine Ercol blonde round drop-leaf retail A$831 - anchor for the STYLE; adjust down ~75-80% because this is a modern HN copy, not Ercol, and stained
comparable mc-007
mc-007 · Kush Interiors (Sydney) · A$2,300
1960s Ercol drop-leaf set retail A$2,300 - shows the vintage original premium this piece does not have

#107 Free dining table 8 chairs

A$0
Brisbane, QLD · Listed a day ago in Brisbane, QLD · View listing

1970s Australian 'country/Old English' style dining set, table + 8 chairs, no label, c.1970s. Condition poor: heavily used: dull/aged varnish, marks and patchy banding on top, chair seats worn and covers mismatched; must be carried down stairs at A$0 ask the whole resale value is margin; a complete 8-chair 70s set like this clears at A$250-400 privately in Brisbane even in worn condition

CONSIDERrectangularlow
Free dining table 8 chairs photoFree dining table 8 chairs photoFree dining table 8 chairs photoFree dining table 8 chairs photoFree dining table 8 chairs photoFree dining table 8 chairs photo

Identification & condition

Form
rectangular
Maker or style
1970s Australian 'country/Old English' style dining set, table + 8 chairs, no label
Material
varnished timber (stained) top with contrasting two-tone border banding (inlay-look), blocky tapered legs; carved-slat chairs with worn vinyl seats, mixed tones
Period
c.1970s
Construction
apron-and-leg table; chairs look machine-made with applied carving; top banding may be applied veneer banding
Dimensions (est.)
~150-180 x 90 cm, est. from chair scale
Condition grade
poor

Visible in photos: heavily used: dull/aged varnish, marks and patchy banding on top, chair seats worn and covers mismatched; must be carried down stairs

Can't see from these photos: s / t / r / u / c / t / u / r / a / l / / s / o / u / n / d / n / e / s / s / , / / j / o / i / n / t / s / , / / w / o / b / b / l / e / , / / e / x / t / e / n / t / / o / f / / t / o / p / / d / a / m / a / g / e / / i / n / / l / o / w / / l / i / g / h / t

Photo limits: whether the top is solid timber or banded laminate, soundness of chair joints, real size

Appraisal confidence: low

Adversarial review · DISSENT · arithmetic: sound · recomputed margin: A$160 · comp support: weak · ask integrity: ok (audit live price = adopted ask) · biggest downside: My re-check of the photos reads a better, solid-timber 1990s set than the appraisal's 'poor 1970s' — the real risk is the opposite: hauling cost (2 people, stairs, ~$150) eats most of a $280 flip · · cost if wrong A$150 ·

DISSENT on the verdict: §3.4 margin is Net_resale - Ask after delivery/reconditioning, and the item itself lists two-person stair carry as a cost; net is 280 minus ~100-150 delivery = ~130-180, below the $300 LOW-confidence floor (low conf also caps V<$1,000, met). The value band is fine (sp-026's $1,125 dealer reference is heavily and properly discounted); the verdict label should be CONSIDER — take-it-if-passing, not a BUY.

Ask versus value

Estimated value: A$150 – A$450 (mid A$300) · refs sp-026 / ds-021

Basis: at A$0 ask the whole resale value is margin; a complete 8-chair 70s set like this clears at A$250-400 privately in Brisbane even in worn condition

Ask A$0 → upside A$300 (value mid − ask)

If resold: private net A$280 · auction net A$0 · retail asking A$450

Adjustments
  • -poor cosmetic condition throughout
  • -collection cost: two people, stairs, no loading
  • +free acquisition (beer donations only)
Verdict: CONSIDER · upside A$300 vs the A$0 ask · confidence low
Comparable evidence
no image
sp-026 · Sydney Morning Herald (smh.com.au) · A$1,125
retail reference A$1,125 for a good Formica table + full vinyl chair set; this is worn with 8 chairs -> ~A$300 private mid
no image
ds-021 · Gumtree Australia · A$80
marketplace floor for complete sets is A$80; eight chairs and a full-size top put the ceiling near A$450

Screened, not appraised (60)

These listings passed the initial sweep but were not appraised in depth — recorded here so the screen is auditable and nothing quietly disappears.

SeqListingAskScreen verdictWhy not appraised
2Lifely Haris 4 Seater Dining Table & 5 chairsA$150Outdoor glass-top round with white metal chairs, no upsideScreened visually from its thumbnail only — not appraised. No value, condition or identification judgement was made for this listing; treat the screen verdict as a pointer, not an opinion.
4TableA$30Painted desk/work table with drawers, not a dining tableScreened visually from its thumbnail only — not appraised. No value, condition or identification judgement was made for this listing; treat the screen verdict as a pointer, not an opinion.
5Queen mattress & frame & side tableA$150Mattress and bed frame listing, irrelevantScreened visually from its thumbnail only — not appraised. No value, condition or identification judgement was made for this listing; treat the screen verdict as a pointer, not an opinion.
62 Round Glass Side Tables \u2013 $25 for BothA$25Pair of small glass side tables, not diningScreened visually from its thumbnail only — not appraised. No value, condition or identification judgement was made for this listing; treat the screen verdict as a pointer, not an opinion.
9Outdoor dining table & chairsA$70Outdoor glass-top on metal frame, no upsideScreened visually from its thumbnail only — not appraised. No value, condition or identification judgement was made for this listing; treat the screen verdict as a pointer, not an opinion.
10Outdoor dining tableA$200Slatted outdoor metal table, A$200 mid-marketScreened visually from its thumbnail only — not appraised. No value, condition or identification judgement was made for this listing; treat the screen verdict as a pointer, not an opinion.
11Mid-century modern side table $50A$50Kidney MCM side table, not a dining tableScreened visually from its thumbnail only — not appraised. No value, condition or identification judgement was made for this listing; treat the screen verdict as a pointer, not an opinion.
15Solid timber Dining table + 4 chairsA$300Rectangular solid-timber set at full A$300 asking, no clear upsideScreened visually from its thumbnail only — not appraised. No value, condition or identification judgement was made for this listing; treat the screen verdict as a pointer, not an opinion.
16Industrial dinning table \/ indoor\/ outdoor w 6 retro chairsA$480Outdoor slatted hardwood set at A$480, modern garden furnitureScreened visually from its thumbnail only — not appraised. No value, condition or identification judgement was made for this listing; treat the screen verdict as a pointer, not an opinion.
178 seater timber Dining TableA$150Rustic slatted 8-seater, looks new/barn-style, rectangular so no round-table upsideScreened visually from its thumbnail only — not appraised. No value, condition or identification judgement was made for this listing; treat the screen verdict as a pointer, not an opinion.
19Vintage style occasional tableA$60Small painted 'vintage style' occasional table, reproduction, not diningScreened visually from its thumbnail only — not appraised. No value, condition or identification judgement was made for this listing; treat the screen verdict as a pointer, not an opinion.
21Dining room table + 6 chairsA$225Plain light-veneer rectangular set, nothing collectableScreened visually from its thumbnail only — not appraised. No value, condition or identification judgement was made for this listing; treat the screen verdict as a pointer, not an opinion.
231500mm Square Glass and Timber Dining TableA$220Glass top on timber X-base, modern, A$220Screened visually from its thumbnail only — not appraised. No value, condition or identification judgement was made for this listing; treat the screen verdict as a pointer, not an opinion.
27Santorini Dining Table and 6 ChairsA$850Glass-top metal-frame designer set at full price A$850Screened visually from its thumbnail only — not appraised. No value, condition or identification judgement was made for this listing; treat the screen verdict as a pointer, not an opinion.
31Dining Table onlyA$120Reclaimed-looking slab on hairpin metal legs, DIY build not vintageScreened visually from its thumbnail only — not appraised. No value, condition or identification judgement was made for this listing; treat the screen verdict as a pointer, not an opinion.
32Dining table and 4 x chairsA$150Photo is a tape measure on a white top, can't judge; no visible upsideScreened visually from its thumbnail only — not appraised. No value, condition or identification judgement was made for this listing; treat the screen verdict as a pointer, not an opinion.
34Dining table 120X80 + Brand new legsA$50Bamboo-strip top needing new legs, flat-pack territoryScreened visually from its thumbnail only — not appraised. No value, condition or identification judgement was made for this listing; treat the screen verdict as a pointer, not an opinion.
3813-Piece Outdoor Extension Dining Table and ChairsA$80013-piece outdoor extension set A$800, modern aluminiumScreened visually from its thumbnail only — not appraised. No value, condition or identification judgement was made for this listing; treat the screen verdict as a pointer, not an opinion.
43White timber dining table 6 seaterA$75White-painted oval reproduction, no timber valueScreened visually from its thumbnail only — not appraised. No value, condition or identification judgement was made for this listing; treat the screen verdict as a pointer, not an opinion.
44Extension Dining TableA$120Grey flat-pack extension oval, modern, no upsideScreened visually from its thumbnail only — not appraised. No value, condition or identification judgement was made for this listing; treat the screen verdict as a pointer, not an opinion.
45Dining Table **note - chips and scratches**A$80White-top bench seating, chips and scratches noted by sellerScreened visually from its thumbnail only — not appraised. No value, condition or identification judgement was made for this listing; treat the screen verdict as a pointer, not an opinion.
47ATOM PARTY HIRE: Chairs, tables and misc. hire for PARTYA$2Party-hire plastic folding tables, not a purchase itemScreened visually from its thumbnail only — not appraised. No value, condition or identification judgement was made for this listing; treat the screen verdict as a pointer, not an opinion.
48TWO Six Foot Folding Market Tables, As New.A$80Folding market tables, commodity hire gearScreened visually from its thumbnail only — not appraised. No value, condition or identification judgement was made for this listing; treat the screen verdict as a pointer, not an opinion.
49Table legsA$20Spare table legs only, not a tableScreened visually from its thumbnail only — not appraised. No value, condition or identification judgement was made for this listing; treat the screen verdict as a pointer, not an opinion.
50Foldable Table - HIREA$12Folding hire table, disposableScreened visually from its thumbnail only — not appraised. No value, condition or identification judgement was made for this listing; treat the screen verdict as a pointer, not an opinion.
51Table & chair for hireA$2Stack of hire chairs/table, party rental stockScreened visually from its thumbnail only — not appraised. No value, condition or identification judgement was made for this listing; treat the screen verdict as a pointer, not an opinion.
52TablesA$100Small low dark-stained plank table, coffee-height, not diningScreened visually from its thumbnail only — not appraised. No value, condition or identification judgement was made for this listing; treat the screen verdict as a pointer, not an opinion.
53Trestle tableA$10Bare trestle top photo, A$10 flat-pack lookScreened visually from its thumbnail only — not appraised. No value, condition or identification judgement was made for this listing; treat the screen verdict as a pointer, not an opinion.
54Trestle tableA$75Trestle legs/frame folded up, no tabletop shownScreened visually from its thumbnail only — not appraised. No value, condition or identification judgement was made for this listing; treat the screen verdict as a pointer, not an opinion.
55Fold-in-half trestle table.A$100Folding plastic trestle table, garden utilityScreened visually from its thumbnail only — not appraised. No value, condition or identification judgement was made for this listing; treat the screen verdict as a pointer, not an opinion.
56IKEA Table & Legs (LAGKAPTEN & OLOV)A$15IKEA LAGKAPTEN top and legs, flat-packScreened visually from its thumbnail only — not appraised. No value, condition or identification judgement was made for this listing; treat the screen verdict as a pointer, not an opinion.
57Ultra portable light aluminum frame table.A$60Portable aluminium frame table, modernScreened visually from its thumbnail only — not appraised. No value, condition or identification judgement was made for this listing; treat the screen verdict as a pointer, not an opinion.
58Trestle table 2.4mt heavy dutyA$1602.4m heavy-duty trestle bar top, commercial, not a dining tableScreened visually from its thumbnail only — not appraised. No value, condition or identification judgement was made for this listing; treat the screen verdict as a pointer, not an opinion.
59Foldable 6ft Table for HireA$9Folding hire tableScreened visually from its thumbnail only — not appraised. No value, condition or identification judgement was made for this listing; treat the screen verdict as a pointer, not an opinion.
61Fitted 6ft\/trestle table cloth and accessoriesA$35Table cloth/accessories, not a tableScreened visually from its thumbnail only — not appraised. No value, condition or identification judgement was made for this listing; treat the screen verdict as a pointer, not an opinion.
62FOR HIRE: Rustic Trestle TablesA$30Rustic trestle hire stock (for hire, not for sale)Screened visually from its thumbnail only — not appraised. No value, condition or identification judgement was made for this listing; treat the screen verdict as a pointer, not an opinion.
63HIRE TABLES & CHAIRS IPSWICHA$2Stacked hire tables and chairsScreened visually from its thumbnail only — not appraised. No value, condition or identification judgement was made for this listing; treat the screen verdict as a pointer, not an opinion.
64Table Risers for hire!A$50Table risers for hire, accessoriesScreened visually from its thumbnail only — not appraised. No value, condition or identification judgement was made for this listing; treat the screen verdict as a pointer, not an opinion.
666-seater+dining+set.A$200Light-look rectangular set with metal chairs, flat-pack styleScreened visually from its thumbnail only — not appraised. No value, condition or identification judgement was made for this listing; treat the screen verdict as a pointer, not an opinion.
68Pale oak veneer - Dining table with two bench seatsA$220Pale oak veneer with benches as titled, modern, A$220Screened visually from its thumbnail only — not appraised. No value, condition or identification judgement was made for this listing; treat the screen verdict as a pointer, not an opinion.
70Dining Table & Chairs Set \u2013 $600A$500Modern black set at A$500, no collectable valueScreened visually from its thumbnail only — not appraised. No value, condition or identification judgement was made for this listing; treat the screen verdict as a pointer, not an opinion.
71Dining Table Glass TopA$350Glass top with faux-leather white chairs, modernScreened visually from its thumbnail only — not appraised. No value, condition or identification judgement was made for this listing; treat the screen verdict as a pointer, not an opinion.
72Dining table and chairsA$100Plain mid-brown rectangular set, modernScreened visually from its thumbnail only — not appraised. No value, condition or identification judgement was made for this listing; treat the screen verdict as a pointer, not an opinion.
744 Seater Dining SetA$40White-painted 4-seater flat-pack setScreened visually from its thumbnail only — not appraised. No value, condition or identification judgement was made for this listing; treat the screen verdict as a pointer, not an opinion.
75Glass dining table and chairsA$100Round glass on chrome base, modernScreened visually from its thumbnail only — not appraised. No value, condition or identification judgement was made for this listing; treat the screen verdict as a pointer, not an opinion.
76Indoor\/ Ourdoor Dining Room Set - $180 ONOA$180Outdoor/indoor round glass + wrought chairsScreened visually from its thumbnail only — not appraised. No value, condition or identification judgement was made for this listing; treat the screen verdict as a pointer, not an opinion.
77Glass Dining Table + 3 chairsA$60Glass top with metal-frame chairs, cheap modernScreened visually from its thumbnail only — not appraised. No value, condition or identification judgement was made for this listing; treat the screen verdict as a pointer, not an opinion.
81Koala Living Pedestal Dining TableA$800Heavy turned pedestal close-up but Koala Living (modern brand) at A$800 full priceScreened visually from its thumbnail only — not appraised. No value, condition or identification judgement was made for this listing; treat the screen verdict as a pointer, not an opinion.
82Dining Table - 6 Seater - Dark TimberA$50Glossy dark rectangular 6-seater, plain modernScreened visually from its thumbnail only — not appraised. No value, condition or identification judgement was made for this listing; treat the screen verdict as a pointer, not an opinion.
86Solid timber 7 piece Dining settingA$200Solid timber 7-piece as titled, rectangular, A$200 mid-marketScreened visually from its thumbnail only — not appraised. No value, condition or identification judgement was made for this listing; treat the screen verdict as a pointer, not an opinion.
92Antique trestle tableA$50Distressed X-trestle looks reproduction despite 'antique' in title; title already flagged antiqueScreened visually from its thumbnail only — not appraised. No value, condition or identification judgement was made for this listing; treat the screen verdict as a pointer, not an opinion.
94Normandy Dining Table \u2013 AmartA$800Amart Normandy reproduction trestle from 2013, modernScreened visually from its thumbnail only — not appraised. No value, condition or identification judgement was made for this listing; treat the screen verdict as a pointer, not an opinion.
97Glass & Wood Dining TableA$350Glass top on modern crossed timber base, A$350 full priceScreened visually from its thumbnail only — not appraised. No value, condition or identification judgement was made for this listing; treat the screen verdict as a pointer, not an opinion.
99Dining tableA$60Plain white modern set in dark photo, A$60 commodity pieceScreened visually from its thumbnail only — not appraised. No value, condition or identification judgement was made for this listing; treat the screen verdict as a pointer, not an opinion.
1032.7m Solid Timber Dining Table with Custom Glass TopA$1,000New live-edge slab with custom glass, A$1000 asking price leaves no marginScreened visually from its thumbnail only — not appraised. No value, condition or identification judgement was made for this listing; treat the screen verdict as a pointer, not an opinion.
106Gloss White tableA$15Bare gloss-white modern top, A$15 flat-packScreened visually from its thumbnail only — not appraised. No value, condition or identification judgement was made for this listing; treat the screen verdict as a pointer, not an opinion.
108Square 8 seater dinner table with chairs and cushions.A$200White-painted square 8-seater, modern, no upsideScreened visually from its thumbnail only — not appraised. No value, condition or identification judgement was made for this listing; treat the screen verdict as a pointer, not an opinion.
109Ex display dining tableA$330Ex-display pale top on modern black star baseScreened visually from its thumbnail only — not appraised. No value, condition or identification judgement was made for this listing; treat the screen verdict as a pointer, not an opinion.
110Circle Glass Table + 4 chairsA$250Round glass top on tripod oak legs + 4 chairs, modernScreened visually from its thumbnail only — not appraised. No value, condition or identification judgement was made for this listing; treat the screen verdict as a pointer, not an opinion.
111Lego TableA$20Kids' Lego play table, not diningScreened visually from its thumbnail only — not appraised. No value, condition or identification judgement was made for this listing; treat the screen verdict as a pointer, not an opinion.

How This Was Made

Harvested Facebook Marketplace dining-table listings within 20 km of Ipswich QLD, then relevance-filtered and visually screened by thumbnail. Fully appraised listings were examined photo-by-photo against a 104-row comparables library drawn from auction results, retail asking prices and private sales. Asking prices were re-audited live and corrected where a capture artefact had corrupted them. Upside = mid-estimate value minus the audited ask.

Photo Data Disclosure

Prices were re-audited against live listing pages because some detail-page captures were corrupted by a scrape artefact; where the audit covered a listing, the published ask is the audited figure. Every appraisal in this report is photo-only: from photographs alone we cannot confirm timber species, joinery or maker in most cases, and values are estimates with stated confidence, not certificates. Facebook Marketplace does not display distance, so the 20 km radius is the search centre setting only — individual listings may sit further out. Listings in the 'Screened, not appraised' section were judged from a title-level and thumbnail-level screen only, which is not an appraisal and carries no value opinion.

Comparables (103 records)

103 comparables across four libraries — Australian colonial, mid-century, designer and specialty — each row a real sale or asking price with source and, where available, an evidence image.

ImgComp idItemSale typePriceDateSource & relevance
aus-001aus-001Superior Colonial blackwood and huon pine tilt top pedestal dining table
Unsigned colonial (Tasmanian, Gowans provenance)
auction_resultA$104,548
A$104,548 (auction_result)
2012-11Antiques Reporter (Gowans Auctions, Melbourne)
Top-of-market benchmark: what an exceptional collector-grade colonial tilt-top pedestal table fetches; caps the ceiling for any Marketplace tilt-top.
aus-002aus-002Colonial cedar round dining table with segmented top and huon pine centre panel
Unsigned colonial cedar
auction_resultA$70,376
A$70,376 (auction_result)
2011-05Antiques Reporter (Gowans Auctions, Hobart)
Auction ceiling for a fine early colonial cedar round pedestal table; only truly superior originals reach this.
aus-003aus-003Cedar drop-leaf (dropside) table, 4 leaf, centre pedestal
Unsigned colonial cedar
auction_resultA$12,650
A$12,650 (auction_result)
2009-11Antiques Reporter (Gowans Auctions)
Benchmark for a good early drop-leaf/pedestal cedar table in original condition.
aus-004aus-004Large 19th century cedar dropside table on 6 turned legs
Unsigned colonial cedar
auction_resultA$11,363
A$11,363 (auction_result)
2009-08Antiques Reporter (Gowans Auctions)
Sets the range for a larger multi-leg drop-leaf cedar table.
aus-005aus-005Colonial cedar dropside table, turned legs, cutlery drawer
Unsigned colonial cedar
auction_resultA$1,518
A$1,518 (auction_result)
2012-05Antiques Reporter (Davidson Auctions)
Realistic auction floor-to-mid for a common-format colonial cedar drop-leaf.
aus-006aus-006Early colonial cedar dropside table, turned tapered legs, single drawer
Unsigned colonial cedar
auction_resultA$7,040
A$7,040 (auction_result)
2008-04Antiques Reporter (Gowans Auctions)
Shows early drop-leaf tables with good provenance clear mid-market auction money.
aus-007aus-007Colonial cedar 4-leaf extension dining table, D-end, seats 10-12
Unsigned colonial cedar
auction_resultA$6,820
A$6,820 (auction_result)
2008-04Antiques Reporter (Gowans Auctions)
Benchmark for large cedar extension/telescopic dining tables in working order.
aus-008aus-008Colonial cedar 2-leaf extension dining table on facetted legs
Unsigned colonial cedar
auction_resultA$5,226
A$5,226 (auction_result)
2010-05Antiques Reporter (Gowans Auctions)
Mid-range auction result for a 2-leaf cedar extension table.
aus-009aus-009Impressive rare-size antique cedar banquet dining table, 8 extension leaves
Unsigned (Brisbane district)
auction_resultA$33,600
A$33,600 (auction_result)
2015-10Antiques Reporter (Vickers & Hoad, Bendigo)
Upper bound for exceptional large cedar banquet/extension tables.
aus-010aus-010Colonial cedar twin pedestal sofa table, Hamilton manner
Unsigned colonial cedar
auction_resultA$6,900
A$6,900 (auction_result)
2017-06Antiques Reporter (Gowans Auctions)
Design-led (Hamilton-style) cedar pedestal form commands premium over plain.
aus-011aus-011Cedar kitchen table with single end drawer, turned legs
Unsigned colonial cedar
auction_resultA$1,495
A$1,495 (auction_result)
2008-04Antiques Reporter (Davidson Auctions)
Floor comparator: plain working cedar table with no decorative merit.
aus-012aus-012Quality mahogany extension dining table with 2 leaves + 10 chairs
Doran's of Hyde Park (retailer)
auction_resultA$6,600
A$6,600 (auction_result)
2009-02Antiques Reporter (Small & Whitfield)
Suits-with-chairs pricing context for later extension tables.
no imageaus-013An Australian cedar breakfast table, circa 1845
Unsigned colonial cedar
auction_resultA$4,270
A$4,270 (auction_result)
2013-11Bonhams Australia (Colonial Sale, Sydney)
Premium-house auction result for a genuine c.1845 cedar round table — anchors early cedar breakfast-table value.
no imageaus-014An Australian cedar and blackwood kitchen table, circa 1860
Unsigned colonial
auction_resultA$1,037
A$1,037 (auction_result)
2013-11Bonhams Australia (Colonial Sale, Sydney)
Floor value for plain colonial working tables even at a top-tier house.
no imageaus-015An Australian specimen wood tilt-top occasional table, circa 1890
Colonial specimen-wood tilt-top
referenceA$2,500
A$2,000-3,000 (estimate) (reference)
2013Bonhams Australia (Colonial Sale, Sydney)
Dealer estimate for decorative native-timber tilt-tops; useful ceiling for novelty-wood Marketplace pieces.
no imageaus-016Round Cedar & Mahogany Table (colonial, c1840s format)
Ipswich Antique Centre stock
retail_askingA$1,500
A$1,500 (retail_asking)
2018Ipswich Antique Centre (QLD)
Local (Ipswich) dealer asking for a comparable round colonial table — direct retail anchor for the subject listings.
aus-017aus-017Rosewood veneer circular tilt-top dining table
Theodore Bruce (dealer-deposit sale)
referenceA$700
A$600-800 (estimate, passed) (reference)
2023-06Theodore Bruce Auctions
Trade-realistic estimate band for a common veneered tilt-top — most Marketplace tilt-tops sit here, not at Gowans prices.
no imageaus-018Mahogany circular tilt-top table, three-foot pedestal base
Theodore Bruce (dealer-deposit sale)
referenceA$200
A$150-250 (estimate, passed) (reference)
2023-06Theodore Bruce Auctions
Floor signal for later/commercial pedestal tilt-tops sold through trade channels.
no imageaus-019Victorian burr walnut Sutherland table, c.1890
South Perth Antiques & Collectables
sold_listingA$995
A$995 (sold_listing)
2015South Perth Antiques & Collectables
Dealer sale price for a genuine Sutherland form; sizes typical colonial drop-side value.
no imageaus-0201stDibs 'Australian cedar' price band (retail asking)
1stDibs market aggregate
referenceA$3,085
US$2,057 avg (range $125-$9,450) ≈ A$3,085 (reference)
20241stDibs
International retail benchmark: online asking for AU cedar averages roughly double local dealer prices.
aus-022aus-022Victorian rosewood pedestal centre table
Gowans Auctions
auction_resultA$2,415
A$2,415 (auction_result)
2014-11Antiques Reporter (Gowans Auctions)
Mid-market round pedestal centre table result when timber is imported/veneered rather than colonial cedar.
aus-023aus-023Outstanding Victorian mahogany extension banquet dining table
Small & Whitfield (Sydney)
auction_resultA$6,380
A$6,380 (auction_result)
2008-06Antiques Reporter (Small & Whitfield)
Upper band for quality extension dining tables; separates 'outstanding' from everyday extensions.
no imageaus-024Colonial cedar table with cotton-reel legs (eBay AU)
Unsigned colonial cedar
retail_askingA$210
AU $210.49 obo (retail_asking)
2026eBay Australia
Bottom of the online asking market for unremarkable colonial cedar tables — most FB Marketplace items cluster here.
no imageaus-025Early Regency mahogany pedestal table, 1830s format
Murphy's Antiques & Restorations (dealer)
retail_askingA$390
A$390 GST inc. (retail_asking)
2025Murphy's Antiques and Restorations
Shows the price restored/commercial pedestal tables actually clear at retail — far below auction 'colonial' headlines.
no imageaus-026Antique kauri pine dining table
Theodore Bruce (Raeburn Homestead sale)
referenceA$1,750
A$1,500-2,000 (estimate) (reference)
2023Theodore Bruce Auctions via FindLots
Cataloguer estimate band for kauri pine dining tables where no hammer price is public.
mc-001mc-001Parker Nordic Round Extension Butterfly Table Model 90, restored teak
Parker Furniture (Australia)
retail_askingA$4,500
A$4,500 (retail_asking)
2026-07Upcycld (Melbourne)
Top-of-market asking price for the single most sought-after AU round extension model (Upcycld Model 90, restored); sets ceiling for Parker rounds.
mc-002mc-002Round Extension Parker Dining Table in Blackwood
Parker Furniture (Australia)
retail_askingA$1,850
A$1,850 (retail_asking)
2026-09Grandfather's Axe (Melbourne)
Shows blackwood (non-teak) Parker round prices roughly $1.1-1.2k under the teak Model 90 asking level.
mc-003mc-003Round Mid-Century Extension Dining Table in Teak, Australia 1960s
Unmarked Australian (Parker-style)
retail_askingA$2,450
A$2,450 (retail_asking)
2026-02Grandfather's Axe (Melbourne)
Key 'unmarked vs labelled' comparator: dealer charges $2,450 for an unbranded AU round teak butterfly table — the Parker name adds ~$400-2,600.
mc-004mc-004Chiswell Round Teak Mid-Century Extension Table
Chiswell Interiors (Australia)
retail_askingA$1,590
A$1,590 (retail_asking)
2026-09Collecte (Mascot NSW)
Chiswell is a common Sydney maker on the secondhand market; this is a live asking price for the exact form appraised (round-to-oval teak).
mc-005mc-005Genuine Parker Round Extendable Table
Parker Furniture (Australia)
retail_askingA$2,990
A$2,990 (retail_asking)
2026-09Astton Vintage (Brisbane)
Queensland dealer asking for a genuine Parker round — directly comparable region for the Ipswich appraisals.
mc-006mc-006Parker No.109 Nordic Extension Dining Table
Parker Furniture (Australia)
retail_askingA$1,400
A$1,400 (marked down A$1,190) (retail_asking)
2026-09Melbourne Furniture Vault
Shows mid-range Parker extension asking after markdown — real clearing price for non-icon Parker models.
mc-007mc-0071960s Ercol Windsor Elm Drop-leaf Dining Set (table + 4 chairs)
Ercol (UK) — Windsor range
retail_askingA$2,300
A$2,300 (set) (retail_asking)
2026-09Kush Interiors (Sydney)
Ercol Windsor sets command strong prices in AU, but the chairs carry most of the value — table-only sets fetch materially less.
mc-008mc-008Ercol Blonde Round Drop-Leaf Dining Table
Ercol (UK)
retail_askingA$831
£411.23 (retail_asking)
2026-09eBay UK (via search)
Ercol drop-leaf table alone sits around $800-850 converted — useful floor for unlabelled gateleg/drop-leaf forms.
no imagemc-009G Plan Fresco Teak Round Extending Dining Table by V.B. Wilkins
G-Plan Fresco (UK)
retail_askingA$977
US$638.67 (retail_asking)
2026-09Etsy (via search)
G-Plan Fresco round extends ask ~$1k internationally; in AU G-Plan carries less premium than Parker, more than unmarked.
mc-010mc-010Round Extending Dining Table, G-Plan Fresco Collection 1960
G-Plan Fresco (UK)
retail_askingA$3,010
€1,855 (20% off €2,320) (retail_asking)
2026-09Vinterior (UK)
Upper asking band for labelled Fresco round extending tables in the curated vintage market.
no imagemc-011G-Plan Fresco Teak Oval Extending Dining Table + 6 Chairs
G-Plan (UK) suite
auction_resultA$512
£250 hammer (auction_result)
2026-07Arthur Johnson & Sons (UK, easyliveauction)
Reality check on achieved prices: a full G-Plan Fresco oval suite hammers ~£220-250 — AU regional auctions behave similarly.
no imagemc-012G-Plan Teak Circular Extending Dining Table
G-Plan (UK)
auction_resultA$72
£35 hammer (auction_result)
—Adam Partridge Auctioneers (UK)
The floor: poor-condition branded teak extension tables can still hammer under $100 — condition dominates the label.
no imagemc-013H.N. Klein for Bramin Danish Eight-Piece Dining Suite
Bramin / H.N. Klein (Denmark)
auction_resultA$1,886
£920 sold (auction_result)
—Anderson & Garland (UK)
Danish branded suites clear at auction far above unbranded: ~$1.9k converted for a full 8-piece Bramin suite.
mc-014mc-014Nathan Teak Dining Suite
Nathan (UK)
auction_resultA$574
£280 sold (auction_result)
—Anderson & Garland (UK)
Nathan sits mid-tier at auction — above G-Plan singles, below Danish branded suites.
mc-015mc-015Mid-Century Teak Round Extending Dining Table from White & Newton
White & Newton (UK)
retail_askingA$3,005
€1,855 (retail_asking)
2026-09Pamono
Top end of UK-brand round extending tables on the international curated market; a White & Newton example rarely seen in AU should be checked against this.
mc-016mc-016Niels Otto Møller Model 254 Extendable Dining Table
Niels O. Møller / J.L. Møllers (Denmark)
retail_askingA$6,301
US$4,118 (retail_asking)
2026-091stDibs
Designered Danish (Møller) round extension tables are an order of magnitude above unmarked 'Danish style' tables — premium is in the mark.
no imagemc-017Skovby SM33 Round Extending Dining Table in Teak
Skovby Møbelfabrik (Denmark)
retail_askingA$1,653
S$1,900 (SGD) (retail_asking)
2026-09S'portofino (Singapore)
Skovby round extenders are still common and reasonably priced; a marked Skovby in AU should fetch ~$1.5-2.5k retail, not Danish-master money.
mc-018mc-018Hans Hayson 'Original' Dining Table for Danish Deluxe
Danish Deluxe (Australia)
auction_resultA$1,600
Est. A$1,200-2,000 (hammer behind member wall) (auction_result)
2021-04Leonard Joel via FindArtInfo
Danish Deluxe (the AU 'Danish' maker) auction estimates bracket $1.2-2k — stamped pieces get specialist treatment.
mc-019mc-019Fler Flaredo Extension Dining Table, 1960s
Fler (Australia)
referenceA$410
Est. A$360-460 (reference)
2025-05Fabiano Antiques (photo of Fler 64 teak extension table)
Visual reference of a Fler 64 teak extension table; auction estimate A$360-460 shows Fler clears low at auction.
mc-020mc-020Danish 1960s Teak Draw-leaf Extension Dining Table, H. Sigh & Søn
Danish import (H. Sigh & Søn)
retail_askingA$2,600
POA (comparable Danish import: A$2,600) (retail_asking)
2026-0920th Century Scandinavia (Sydney)
Shows what a restored, attributed Danish import fetches from a specialist — the ceiling for 'Danish' teak extension tables in AU retail.
mc-021mc-0211960s Danish Extendable Dining Table in Teak
Danish (import, maker unspecified)
retail_askingA$2,600
A$2,600 (retail_asking)
2026-09Curated Spaces (Melbourne)
Live AU retail asking for a Danish extendable in original (unrestored) condition.
no imagemc-022Parker Teak Oval Extension Table + 6 Parker Chairs
Parker Furniture (Australia)
gumtree_askingA$4,131
€2,550 (reg. €3,400) (gumtree_asking)
2026-09Gumtree Australia
Private-seller asking level for Parker sets; actual clearing is typically 40-60% of this.
no imagemc-023Teak Drop-Leaf Table
Danish teak (unmarked)
auction_resultA$102
£50 hammer (auction_result)
2026-07Arthur Johnson & Sons (UK, easyliveauction)
Drop-leaf/gateleg without a mark is commodity furniture at auction — frames the low end for unlabelled AU examples.
mc-024mc-024Parker Round Extension Dining Table (good original condition)
Parker Furniture (Australia)
retail_askingA$1,590
A$1,590 (retail_asking)
2026-09Retro Rehab (Melbourne)
Working-class Melbourne mid-century dealer clearing a round Parker around $1.5-1.6k — realistic retail for original-condition rounds.
no imagemc-025Vintage Nordic Teak Round Extension Table (Gumtree QLD)
T.H. Brown / G-Plan style teak
gumtree_askingA$1,100
Asking (exact figure not captured; set-price band $1,000-1,300 for this form) (gumtree_asking)
2026-09Gumtree Australia search
Typical QLD private asking for the Parker-90 form without the label — the 'Danish' descriptor adds nothing verifiable.
ds-001ds-001Eero Saarinen for Knoll Tulip Dining Table, round 35in, black laminate
Saarinen for Knoll
retail_askingA$2,458
US $1,750.00 ≈ A$2,458 (retail_asking)
2026-09eBay Australia
Benchmark for a genuine Knoll Saarinen round on the secondary market reachable from Australia; anchoring the original end of the Knoll-vs-replica spread.
ds-002ds-002Eero Saarinen for Knoll Tulip Dining Table 2017, Vetro Bianco top
Saarinen for Knoll
retail_askingA$3,670
AU $3,670.24 (retail_asking)
2026-09eBay Australia
Shows what collectors pay for dated Knoll production; the year-stamped base is the authenticity tell.
no imageds-003Cult Furniture Saarinen Style Tulip Table, round, marble-look top
Saarinen-style (replica)
retail_askingA$1,544
US $1,099.50 ≈ A$1,544 (retail_asking)
2026-09Cult Furniture
Sets the ceiling for what a NEW replica costs; a used Marketplace replica cannot sensibly ask more than ~50-60% of this.
ds-004ds-004Charles & Ray Eames round table, 36in, universal/segmented aluminium base
Eames for Herman Miller
retail_askingA$1,740
US $1,239.00 ≈ A$1,740 (retail_asking)
2026-09CA Modern Home
Authentic Eames round tables are modestly priced compared with the chairs; useful mid-tier designer anchor.
no imageds-005Arne Jacobsen Circular Dining Table model A827, marble top, chrome star pedestal
Jacobsen for Fritz Hansen
auction_resultA$2,676
US $1,905 ≈ A$2,676 (auction_result)
2019-03-05MutualArt / Bruun Rasmussen
Shows a genuine Danish-designer marble-top round realising under US$2k at auction — designer pedigree alone does not guarantee big money.
ds-006ds-006Børge Mogensen 'Øresund' round dining table, oak, 2 hidden leaves
Mogensen for Karl Andersson
referenceA$4,144
US $2,950 avg ≈ A$4,144 (reference)
2026-091stDibs price archive
Top-of-market benchmark for named Danish rounds; the hidden-leaf mechanism is a value driver worth checking for.
ds-007ds-007Hans J. Wegner CH327 round dining table (expandable), new/production
Wegner for Carl Hansen
retail_askingA$9,102
US $6,480.00 ≈ A$9,102 (retail_asking)
2026-09Danish Design Store
New-production price ceiling; used originals typically 50-70% of this. Guides what a Wegner round SHOULD not exceed used.
ds-008ds-008Hans J. Wegner teak and oak dining table, model AT-312
Wegner (Danish made)
retail_askingA$10,995
AU $10,995.00 (retail_asking)
2026-09Case 22
Demonstrates the Australian dealer retail premium on named Danish makers; rarely achieved privately.
ds-009ds-009Norman Cherner for Plycraft dining table, c.1960s
Cherner for Plycraft
retail_askingA$3,652
US $2,600.00 ≈ A$3,652 (retail_asking)
2026-091stDibs
Cherner attribution is often style-only ('Cherner-style'); most Marketplace hits are unmarked copies worth a fraction.
ds-010ds-010Mark Tuckey Farmhouse Lite Round Dining Table
Mark Tuckey
retail_askingA$7,495
AU $7,495.00 (retail_asking)
2026-09Mark Tuckey
Current Australian designer retail anchor; used Tuckey holds ~50-65% of RR.
ds-011ds-011Mark Tuckey Cog Dining Table, round solid top with cog base
Mark Tuckey
retail_askingA$7,545
AU $7,545.00 (retail_asking)
2026-09Mark Tuckey
Pedestal-base Australian designer table; recognisable base shape makes attribution easy in photos.
ds-012ds-012Jardan Otis round table, oak top/oak base
Jardan
retail_askingA$4,162
AU $4,162.00 RRP (retail_asking)
2026-09Jardan
Jardan is common on affluent-suburban Marketplace; stone-top versions carry big upcharges.
ds-013ds-013Didier 'Liqueur' round table, single pedestal
Ross Didier
retail_askingA$3,100
AU $3,100.00 (retail_asking)
2026-09Innerspace WA
Australian contract/design range that appears second-hand; distinct sculptural base is identifiable.
no imageds-014Rare early 1950s Fler dining table
Fler
sold_listingA$1,150
AU $1,150.00 (sold_listing)
2024Mrs Secondhand
Realised second-hand price for early Australian MCM; the underside purchase-date label is a textbook maker-mark rung.
ds-015ds-015Australian mid-century teak named-maker value band, dealer guidance
Australian MCM (Parker/Fler/Chiswell)
referenceA$2,000
AUD 1,600-4,500 band (reference)
2026-09Upcycld (Sydney dealer journal)
Gives the practical band for Australian MCM in the local secondary market and joinery tells for Fler/Parker attribution.
ds-016ds-016Castlery Belmont Travertine Round Dining Table
Contemporary travertine
retail_askingA$2,159
AU $2,159.00 (retail_asking)
2026-09Castlery AU
The common 'designer-look' stone table on Marketplace is Castlery/Urbanara class — new at ~$2k, used at 40-50%.
ds-017ds-017MCM House Kora Travertine Round Dining Table
Contemporary travertine
retail_askingA$6,895
AU $6,895.00 (sale $4,826) (retail_asking)
2026-09MCM House
Shows the stone-top spread: Castlery ~$2.1k vs premium ~$7k, and that premium retail discounts 30% routinely — asking prices on used must respect that.
no imageds-018Solid mahogany Chippendale-style round dining table 90cm, Australian retail
Chippendale reproduction
retail_askingA$990
AU $989.99 (retail_asking)
2026-09Antique Mahogany (AU retailer)
Defines what a NEW Chippendale-style reproduction costs — an 'antique-looking' round table used is worth well under this.
ds-019ds-019Maison Living (Bramble Co) Provincial Round Trestle Dining Table 120cm, antique French oak finish
French Provincial
retail_askingA$1,790
AU $1,790.00 (RRP $2,990) (retail_asking)
2026-09Maison Living AU
Separates genuine antique French rounds from the reproduction/1980s-import class that dominates Australian suburban listings.
no imageds-020bakker&bech round dining table, brushed brass legs + round glass top
Brass & glass bakker&bech
referenceA$1,428
US $1,017.50 ≈ A$1,428 (reference)
2026-09bakker&bech
Benchmark for brass-base/glass-top designer rounds vs unmarked 1980s brass-and-glass rounds (worth a fraction).
no imageds-021Fantastic Furniture 90cm round table + 2 chairs, QLD (Spring Mountain)
Ordinary / flat-pack
marketplace_askingA$80
AU $80.00 (marketplace_asking)
2026-09Gumtree Australia
Real local asking price for the modal Marketplace table; sets the true floor of the market.
no imageds-022'Ashton' 4-seater black round dining table, Southport QLD
Ordinary / flat-pack
marketplace_askingA$150
AU $150.00 (marketplace_asking)
2026-09Gumtree Australia
Near-new flat-pack loses ~60-70% the moment it leaves the shop.
no imageds-023Gordon walnut-veneer round table 105cm, Rocklea QLD (trade seller)
Ordinary / veneer
marketplace_askingA$399
AU $399.00 (marketplace_asking)
2026-09Gumtree Australia (PriceWorth Rocklea)
Shows trade sellers inflating the low end; a private resale of the same table is $100-150.
no imageds-0244-piece round table with 2 leaves, tempered glass top, chrome base
Ordinary / glass-top
sold_listingA$162
AU $161.60 (sold_listing)
2026-09Amazon Australia
The glass-top 4-seater is a Marketplace staple; new at $162 caps used value near $50-80.
no imageds-025Round extendable sintered-stone table 110cm, chrome base (new, eBay AU)
Ordinary / composite stone
retail_askingA$300
AU $299.90 (retail_asking)
2026-09eBay Australia
The fake-travertine/fake-marble composite tier — looks like $2-7k stone tables in photos but costs $300 new.
sp-001sp-001Victorian Cuban mahogany extension dining table with nineteen chairs
Victorian Cuban mahogany (English)
auction_resultA$20,520
A$20,520 (auction_result)
2009-04Antiques Reporter (Melbourne auction record)
Top-of-market for a 'Victorian dining suite' in Australia: shows that the nineteen-chair count, not the table alone, is what carries the premium past $20k. Ceiling comp for a full suite.
sp-002sp-002Dining suite: William IV table and twelve chairs, c1835, mahogany
William IV mahogany (English)
auction_resultA$38,250
A$38,250 (auction_result)
2011-02Antiques Reporter (SCAD auction record)
Highest Australian suite result in this set; early date plus complete twelve-chair set explains the outlier price. Use as absolute ceiling, not as a realistic mark for a c.1890 suite.
sp-003sp-003Renaissance Revival dining suite, fourteen-piece
Renaissance Revival, J.D. (attributed maker)
auction_resultA$15,525
A$15,525 (auction_result)
2018-02Antiques Reporter (SCAD auction record)
Modern-era (2018) evidence of what a genuine 14-piece Victorian-era suite fetches: mid-teens $A. Best single anchor for 'Victorian Dining Suite' hammer value with chair count high.
sp-004sp-004Fine Victorian mahogany extending dining table with five extra leaves
Victorian mahogany (English)
auction_resultA$16,133
A$16,133 (auction_result)
2006-07Antiques Reporter (auction record)
Table-only comparator against sp-001/sp-003: a fine extension table alone reaches ~$16k, so the 12-19 chair suites above carry roughly a 25-135% chair premium.
sp-005sp-005Fine six-leaf Victorian mahogany extension table, mid 19th century
Victorian mahogany, six-leaf
auction_resultA$12,000
A$12,000 (auction_result)
2017-02Antiques Reporter (auction record)
Recent (2017) table-only benchmark for a fine six-leaf Victorian extension; defines the upper-middle of the table-only band.
sp-006sp-006Victorian mahogany banquet extension table with D-ends, three original leaves
Victorian mahogany banquet extension, D-ends
auction_resultA$11,492
A$11,492 (auction_result)
2009-12Antiques Reporter (auction record)
Paired with sp-007, brackets the D-end banquet table-only band at roughly $8.5-11.5k at auction, before buyer premium nuance.
sp-007sp-007Good Victorian style mahogany dining suite (table and chairs)
Victorian-style mahogany dining suite
auction_resultA$11,500
A$11,500 (auction_result)
2007-04Antiques Reporter (auction record)
'Victorian style' (revival) suite fetches materially less than genuine Victorian sp-001/003 - useful discount factor when the Marketplace item is Edwardian reproduction.
sp-008sp-008Australian Edwardian extension dining table - dealer asking
Australian Edwardian (provincial)
retail_askingA$1,250
AUD 1,250 (retail_asking)
2026-09Moonee Ponds Antiques (Melbourne dealer)
The retail floor for an ordinary Edwardian extension table in AU: dealer money sits at $1-1.5k, a third of auction-grade Victorian quality. The Marketplace walnut suites near Ipswich that lack burr/carving land here, not in the $5k band.
sp-009sp-009Six-piece cane setting: five chairs and a circular table
Cane outdoor/dining setting (imported)
auction_resultA$1,680
A$1,680 (auction_result)
2013-02Antiques Reporter (auction record)
Best Australian auction evidence for a six-piece cane dining/verandah setting with circular table: $1.68k all-in, i.e. ~$240/piece. Caps what any cane 'dining suite' should be appraised at.
sp-010sp-010Three-piece cane outdoor suite (pair of armchairs + table)
Cane three-piece suite
auction_resultA$1,440
A$1,440 (auction_result)
2020-04Antiques Reporter (Shapiro Auctions)
Recent (2020) auction result: cane suites still clear four figures when condition is good - category is alive but modest, not a rising star.
sp-011sp-011Cane outdoor setting for two, table 97 cm dia
Cane bistro setting for two
auction_resultA$1,342
A$1,342 (auction_result)
—Antiques Reporter (auction record)
Shows the round-table diameter (97 cm) a cane setting actually comes in - directly comparable to small round Marketplace cane tables.
sp-012sp-012Cane honeymoon table and chairs set - sold $300 (Brisbane-Byron dealer)
Cane 'honeymoon' suite (retail resale)
sold_listingA$300
A$300 (sold_listing)
2020-12MM Furniture (Sunshine Coast QLD dealer)
Floor of the 'honeymoon' category at dealer retail: a small cane honeymoon set clears $300, not $3,000. Prevents the appraiser from romanticising the name. Same page family shows bentwood honeymoon suites at $300-770.
no imagesp-013Austrian bentwood marble-top centre table, manner of Thonet, c.1905
Thonet bentwood (Austrian)
auction_resultA$4,183
A$4,183 (auction_result)
—Antiques Reporter (auction record)
Bentwood + real marble crossover comp: bentwood alone is cheap, but an original c.1905 Thonet-line bentwood table with stone top clears $4k - the maker and the stone do the work, not the bend.
sp-014sp-014Thonet cast-iron bistro table with Carrara marble top
Thonet bistro table
auction_resultA$974
A$974 (auction_result)
2019-04Antiques Reporter (auction record)
REAL-STONE comp: even a genuine Carrara marble top on a small bistro table only fetches ~$1k at Australian auction. Stone alone does not make a table valuable at this scale.
sp-015sp-015Cast iron and Carrara marble circular garden table, French, 19th century
French cast iron and Carrara marble (garden/patio)
auction_resultA$1,736
A$1,736 (auction_result)
2016-10Antiques Reporter (auction record)
Second REAL-STONE comp: authentic 19th-c marble-and-iron circular tables clear $1-2.5k in Australia. Any local 'marble top' listing asking $5-10k is way above market unless it is a fine interior table.
sp-016sp-016George II grey veined marble-topped walnut centre table, c.1730
George II walnut with grey veined marble top
auction_resultA$4,629
A$4,629 (auction_result)
2017-08Antiques Reporter (auction record)
Shows that marble-top value tracks the age/quality of the WOOD base, not the stone: a c.1730 base lifts the same real-marble formula to $4.6k+ where a c.1900 patio version does $1k.
sp-017sp-017Dining table, white Corian acrylic circular top, powder-coated steel base
Modern 'Corian acrylic' circular dining table (imitation stone)
auction_resultA$1,473
A$1,473 (auction_result)
—Antiques Reporter (auction record)
IMITATION-STONE comp: a large engineered-stone round dining table clears only ~$1.5k secondhand - the same as real 19th-c iron/marble. Imitation tops hold no premium at auction.
no imagesp-018Vintage 70s/80s dining table, 'travertine marble'/glass/chrome - eBay AU asking
Vintage 'travertine marble/glass/chrome' dining table (imitation)
marketplace_askingA$450
AU$450 (marketplace_asking)
—eBay Australia listings (search snapshot)
IMITATION comp, Australian asking side: retro 'travertine/marble' effect tables ask $450 locally. Contrast with real stone auction results - imitation stone sits an order of magnitude below fine real-stone tables.
no imagesp-019Nick Scali round marble dining tables - new retail asking band
New retail marble-effect vs real marble benchmark
retail_askingA$1,790
A$1,790 (was $2,890) (retail_asking)
—Nick Scali (nickscali.com.au)
Killer spread for category 3: NEW marble (or marble-look) round tables retail at $1,790 on special. Any secondhand real-marble round table is competing against $1.2-2.8k new, which caps resale hard.
sp-020sp-020Circular dining table in South African black granite with revolving centre
South African black granite circular dining table
auction_resultA$17,787
A$17,787 (auction_result)
—Antiques Reporter (auction record)
Exceptional real-stone outlier: proves a genuine massive granite round CAN clear high dollars when it is a statement piece. Use as ceiling only; median stone round is $1-4k.
sp-021sp-021Granite-topped French wrought-iron circular table, 164 cm dia
French granite-top round table
auction_resultA$2,360
A$2,360 (auction_result)
2013-09Antiques Reporter (auction record)
Third REAL-STONE round-table comp: big diameter (164 cm) genuine granite only reaches $2.4k at auction. Sets the honest ceiling for a solid-stone round dining table of ordinary quality.
sp-022sp-022French wrought iron dining table with glazed ceramic tile top
French glazed ceramic tile-top dining table
auction_resultA$2,070
A$2,070 (auction_result)
2019-04Antiques Reporter (auction record)
Best full-size tiled-top DINING table auction result in the set: tiled tops are a novelty premium at ~$2k, nowhere near $5k+ asks.
no imagesp-023Edwardian oak two-tier table, duck-egg blue glazed tile top, c.1905
Edwardian oak tiled-top table (dealer retail)
retail_askingA$365
A$365 (retail_asking)
—Antiques Plus / Antiques Design Online (Carrum Downs VIC)
REALISED Australian retail asking for the 'tiled table' class: $365 dealer-retail for a genuine c.1905 tiled-top table. Confirms the local low-asking observation for category 4.
no imagesp-024John Perceval hand-painted tile top coffee table, signed 'J. Perceval '50'
John Perceval hand-painted tile-top coffee table (signed artist exception)
auction_resultA$11,352
A$11,352.50 (incl BP) (auction_result)
2020-11Leski Auctions / Australian Auction Review
The one direction the tiled-table category runs UP: signed/artist tiled tops (Perceval, Boyd circle) are art, not furniture, and 20x the ordinary value. Rule: check under tiles for signatures before writing a tiled table off at $300.
sp-025sp-0251960s retro round Formica kitchen table - eBay AU asking $75
Retro round Formica kitchen table (local asking)
marketplace_askingA$75
AU$75 (Laminex example AU$130) (marketplace_asking)
—eBay Australia listings (search snapshot)
Bottom of category 4: ordinary retro laminate rounds ask $75-130 in Australia. The 'marble-effect Laminex' example also serves as an imitation-stone asking comp.
no imagesp-026'Good formica table + full set of vinyl chairs fetch $750-1,500' - Sydney dealer benchmark
Australian formica/retro market (dealer benchmark, press)
referenceA$1,125
A$750-1,500 band (reference)
2002-09Sydney Morning Herald (smh.com.au)
Dealer-stated ceiling for the retro laminate CLASS when complete and clean: $750-1,500 as a set. Note the article also records formica 'no longer fashionable by the 60s' - the premium is nostalgia, recent and thin.
no imagesp-027Parker dining suite, retro 1970s - eBay AU asking $900
Parker retro dining suite (local asking)
marketplace_askingA$900
AU$900 (Featherstone table AU$280) (marketplace_asking)
—eBay Australia listings (search snapshot)
Shows the asking spread within category 4's laminate class: named Australian maker (Parker suite) $900 vs unbranded round formica $75 - 12x spread on asking prices, all below the mc-* teak band.
sp-028sp-028Queensland walnut extension dining table - retail asking
Queensland walnut (Australian, 20th century)
retail_askingA$850
AUD 850 (retail_asking)
2026-09Nord Modern (Brunswick, Melbourne vintage dealer)
Bottom of the AU retail ladder for a walnut extension: genuine local timber, but no D-ends, no period chairs, needs refinishing = sub-$1k ask. The exact profile of the shabby walnut suites that come up on local Marketplace.

Adversarial review: every dissent (12)

Every card carries its own review strip; the items below are the ones the adversarial reviewer did not accept as it stands. A dissent is a warning to re-check before buying, not a veto.

Price Bands

BandLowHighNote
Ordinary flat-pack / veneer / glass / compositeA$0A$250The modal Marketplace round: chipboard, peeling veneer, glass or composite tops. Realistic private-sale value A$0-250, modal A$50-150 (VALUATION_METHOD tier table, ds-021 to ds-025). At these prices delivery and reconditioning, not the table, decide the deal.
Reproduction antique and designer-look reproductions (used)A$150A$700Chippendale/French-look reproductions used fetch A$150-500, fine new repro A$790-990; a Saarinen-style replica is A$300-700 used against A$2,000-3,700 for a genuine Knoll (VALUATION_METHOD tier table). Repro feet, moulded edges and a plated rather than cast base are the tells.
Mid-century / Danish teak rounds - unmarked to brandedA$350A$2,500Unmarked Danish-style or AU-copy teak rounds: realistic private sale A$350-900 in this market; Parker-stamped (or named AU maker such as Chiswell/Fler) in honest original condition: A$1,200-2,500. Above A$3,000 only for exceptional restored Parker-90 or genuinely marked Danish design (midcentury/reference-notes.md section 5).
Colonial / antique, restoration gradeA$150A$800Rebuilt, repainted-then-stripped, dark-stained or replacement-part colonial rounds: A$150-800 territory, and frequently unsold - rosewood-veneer circular tilt-tops estimated A$600-800 passed at a dealer-excess auction (aus-colonial/reference-notes.md sections 3 and 5). A re-turned pedestal or new top erases the patina premium: 5-10x discount.
Colonial / antique, honest original common formA$1,000A$2,000Unattributed cedar drop-side/kitchen tables in honest original condition: A$1,000-2,000 at colonial-specialist auction (Bonhams A$1,037; Davidson A$1,495/1,518). Local Gumtree/Facebook/dealer-shed asking for anything called colonial cedar typically sits A$200-1,500, and asks above that underwhelm: an Ipswich A$1,500 ask sat unsold from 2018 (aus-colonial/reference-notes.md sections 1 and 5).
Colonial / antique, good original desirable formA$5,000A$13,000Drop-leaf on pedestal, or extension with all matched leaves, genuine and original: A$5,000-13,000 (Gowans results A$5,226-12,650); exceptional early pieces with segmented tops or huon centres run six figures. Anything claimed as c.1840-1850 must survive Bonhams/Gowans-grade scrutiny before quoting above A$3,000 (aus-colonial/reference-notes.md sections 1 and 5).
Real stone tops (marble on cast/iron base)A$800A$1,800Carrara marble garden rounds realised A$806-1,736 against antique-shop asks of A$2,400-2,900 (specialty/reference-notes.md). The rule: real stone is worth 3-20x a marble-look laminate, and the premium sits in the base, not the slab - a good cast-iron base carries the price.
Tiled and laminate topsA$500A$1,200Decorative ceramic-tile tops are a taste niche: they neither add teak-money nor fetch designer money - expect A$500-1,200 asking and little at auction (midcentury/reference-notes.md section 4); tiled tables asking A$600-900 are worth the same at auction as privately, no spread to exploit (specialty/reference-notes.md). Laminate-look tops price as ordinary furniture.
Cane, bentwood and bamboo roundsA$300A$800Small cane table-and-chairs sets sell privately from about A$300; a good-original caned dining setting is worth A$300-800 privately and A$1,300-1,700 only at a capital-city house with an audience, with real unsold risk. Damaged cane is near-worthless: re-caning costs more than the piece (specialty/reference-notes.md).
Channel ladder: auction < private < retail (same table)A$250A$2,500For one unmarked good-condition teak round: regional/auction clearing A$250-800, Facebook private sale A$350-900, dealer retail equivalent A$1,600-2,500 (midcentury/reference-notes.md section 5). Dealer asking runs 2.5-5x the regional hammer; Marketplace asks sit 2-3x clearing price; international online retail (1stDibs) converts at 0.55-0.7 for a local private sale (VALUATION_METHOD).

Reference: What to Look For

Colonial / antique library (c.1840-1940 Australian)

Covers cedar and mahogany pedestal, drop-side and extension rounds: auction-vs-retail spreads by size, leaf economics, named makers (Hamilton manner, Lenehan, Beard Watson), and the restoration/collector grade ladder. Single most useful rule: local asking for anything called colonial cedar sits A$200-1,500, but genuine, original, good-provenance cedar rounds clear A$4,000+ at colonial specialists - rebuilt, re-turned or dark-stained pieces take a 5-10x discount, so judge originality before age claims (aus-colonial/reference-notes.md).

Mid-century / Danish teak library

Covers teak round extending tables: Parker, G-Plan/Fresco, Chiswell, Fler and unlabelled AU copies, with dealer asks, UK and AU auction hammers, and condition drivers (original finish, veneer lift, missing leaves). Single most useful rule: value tracks (1) label, (2) condition, (3) form - 'Danish' is a style word in Queensland marketplaces; only a stamp carries the premium, and a painted or water-lifted example loses 60-80% (midcentury/reference-notes.md).

Specialty library: stone, tile, cane, bentwood, garden

Covers marble-on-iron garden rounds, tiled tops, cane and bentwood settings, and conservatory ironwork, with realised auction figures against shop asks. Single most useful rule: real stone is worth 3-20x a marble-look laminate and the premium sits in the base, not the slab; damaged cane is near-worthless because re-caning costs more than the piece (specialty/reference-notes.md).

Designer / contemporary library

Covers named designer pieces (Saarinen/Knoll, Danish originals, new Australian designers) plus the ordinary flat-pack bottom of the market - 25 comp rows, 5 of them ordinary. Its governing caveat: 1stDibs and MutualArt figures are dealer-ask or auction aggregates, not private-sale prices, and eBay prices are asking not sold; apply the local-versus-internet spread before treating any online figure as realisable here (comparables/designer/comps.json meta).

How the BUY margin rule works

Net_resale = value mid x 0.95 (haggle-to-own) minus delivery, reconditioning and about 6% dealer-style fees; Margin = Net_resale minus the ask. BUY only if Margin is at least max(0.30 x value, A$150) AND confidence is at least MEDIUM; a LOW-confidence listing needs Margin to clear max(0.5 x value, A$300) with value under A$1,000. In practice a A$2,000 table needs roughly A$600 of projected profit before we move; a A$150 table must come effectively free (appraisal/VALUATION_METHOD.md, section 3.4).

What a photo-only appraisal cannot see

This is a desktop study: nothing was handled, measured or inspected. Photos cannot show wobble in the joints, the underside of a base or top, missing or broken extension leaves and windlasses, the reality of a 'solid timber' claim under veneer, beetle activity, or whether a mark is a period stamp or a copy. Every value range must be confirmed in person before payment, and a single requested photo (underside, leaf mechanism, label) can flip a verdict (appraisal/VALUATION_METHOD.md; photo-data disclosure).

Sources

  1. Antiques Reporter (Gowans Auctions, Melbourne)
  2. Antiques Reporter (Gowans Auctions, Hobart)
  3. Antiques Reporter (Gowans Auctions)
  4. Antiques Reporter (Gowans Auctions)
  5. Antiques Reporter (Davidson Auctions)
  6. Antiques Reporter (Gowans Auctions)
  7. Antiques Reporter (Gowans Auctions)
  8. Antiques Reporter (Gowans Auctions)
  9. Antiques Reporter (Vickers & Hoad, Bendigo)
  10. Antiques Reporter (Gowans Auctions)
  11. Antiques Reporter (Davidson Auctions)
  12. Antiques Reporter (Small & Whitfield)
  13. Bonhams Australia (Colonial Sale, Sydney)
  14. Bonhams Australia (Colonial Sale, Sydney)
  15. Bonhams Australia (Colonial Sale, Sydney)
  16. Ipswich Antique Centre (QLD)
  17. Theodore Bruce Auctions
  18. Theodore Bruce Auctions
  19. South Perth Antiques & Collectables
  20. 1stDibs
  21. Antiques Reporter (Gowans Auctions)
  22. Antiques Reporter (Small & Whitfield)
  23. eBay Australia
  24. Murphy's Antiques and Restorations
  25. Theodore Bruce Auctions via FindLots
  26. Upcycld (Melbourne)
  27. Grandfather's Axe (Melbourne)
  28. Grandfather's Axe (Melbourne)
  29. Collecte (Mascot NSW)
  30. Astton Vintage (Brisbane)
  31. Melbourne Furniture Vault
  32. Kush Interiors (Sydney)
  33. eBay UK (via search)
  34. Etsy (via search)
  35. Vinterior (UK)
  36. Arthur Johnson & Sons (UK, easyliveauction)
  37. Adam Partridge Auctioneers (UK)
  38. Anderson & Garland (UK)
  39. Pamono
  40. 1stDibs
  41. S'portofino (Singapore)
  42. Leonard Joel via FindArtInfo
  43. Fabiano Antiques (photo of Fler 64 teak extension table)
  44. 20th Century Scandinavia (Sydney)
  45. Curated Spaces (Melbourne)
  46. Gumtree Australia
  47. Retro Rehab (Melbourne)
  48. Gumtree Australia search
  49. eBay Australia
  50. eBay Australia
  51. Cult Furniture
  52. CA Modern Home
  53. MutualArt / Bruun Rasmussen
  54. 1stDibs price archive
  55. Danish Design Store
  56. Case 22
  57. 1stDibs
  58. Mark Tuckey
  59. Mark Tuckey
  60. Jardan
  61. Innerspace WA
  62. Mrs Secondhand
  63. Upcycld (Sydney dealer journal)
  64. Castlery AU
  65. MCM House
  66. Antique Mahogany (AU retailer)
  67. Maison Living AU
  68. bakker&bech
  69. Gumtree Australia
  70. Gumtree Australia
  71. Gumtree Australia (PriceWorth Rocklea)
  72. Amazon Australia
  73. eBay Australia
  74. Antiques Reporter (Melbourne auction record)
  75. Antiques Reporter (SCAD auction record)
  76. Antiques Reporter (SCAD auction record)
  77. Antiques Reporter (auction record)
  78. Antiques Reporter (auction record)
  79. Antiques Reporter (auction record)
  80. Antiques Reporter (auction record)
  81. Moonee Ponds Antiques (Melbourne dealer)
  82. Antiques Reporter (auction record)
  83. Antiques Reporter (Shapiro Auctions)
  84. Antiques Reporter (auction record)
  85. MM Furniture (Sunshine Coast QLD dealer)
  86. Antiques Reporter (auction record)
  87. Antiques Reporter (auction record)
  88. Antiques Reporter (auction record)
  89. Antiques Reporter (auction record)
  90. Antiques Reporter (auction record)
  91. eBay Australia listings (search snapshot)
  92. Nick Scali (nickscali.com.au)
  93. Antiques Reporter (auction record)
  94. Antiques Reporter (auction record)
  95. Antiques Reporter (auction record)
  96. Antiques Plus / Antiques Design Online (Carrum Downs VIC)
  97. Leski Auctions / Australian Auction Review
  98. Sydney Morning Herald (smh.com.au)
  99. Nord Modern (Brunswick, Melbourne vintage dealer)